Fog drifts through the trees in the Tongass National Forest on Monday, Dec. 9, 2019. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

Fog drifts through the trees in the Tongass National Forest on Monday, Dec. 9, 2019. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

My Turn: A response to ‘There are no Landless Natives in Southeast Alaska’

Where to begin?

Rebecca Knight’s — at best implicitly xenophobic and factually incorrect – opinion piece published Sept. 20 not only misconstrues the present legislation’s purpose, but also wholly whitewashes issues of stolen Indigenous land in Alaska.

Beginning her piece with a 27-year-old quote from the wrongly attributed “[Deputy Assistant] Secretary Jim Lyons” shows how dated and misled Knight is.

When a federal government that has taken unceded land from Indigenous peoples refuses to return it, that is called perpetuation of colonial behavior, not precedent.

The fact that national officials said such inflammatory remarks is part of the problem, not validation for warped and oppressive policy oversight to continue unchanged. Knight’s entire rant is — one hopes — misguidedly built from the perspective of an occupying bureaucrat.

Knight then makes another troublingly capitalist assumption that the “gifted” land is “for the purpose of forming urban corporations.” There can be no better illustration of how perspective affects argumentation. The land would be returned to Alaska Natives that have stewarded it since time immemorial, thereby reuniting communities with the very spaces that healed and protected them for thousands of years. Simply put, it is traumatic to not have that land.

Wading quickly through her remaining remarks, as there is much inaccuracy to correct — here is the truth:

All existing public use and public access on these lands would remain.

All taxpayer infrastructure would remain open for public use.

Landless legislation has never failed in Congress.

Some of the in-question communities did not have “a majority Native population” because they were so effectively gentrified in the preceding decades by fear and force.

The University of Alaska’s Institute of Social and Economic Research’s (ISER) report concluded that “the omission of the study communities is not clearly explained in any provision of ANCSA or in the accompanying conference report.”

Similarly, the ISER report stated, “the urban corporations have generated direct financial benefits…far in excess of those received by at-large shareholders of Sealaska.”

Let’s step back a moment. Why is Knight scared? That is because — to her credit — she loves Alaska, as we all do. But a real and painful pattern has been occurring lately that we must address: it seems some lovers of Alaska’s wild places do not understand that these lands would never have existed in their pure form without the intergenerational stewardship of Alaska Native peoples. Pretending that Indigenous peoples did not do that is ridiculous.

The Tongass National Forest is named after the Tongass people, Taantʼa Ḵwáan, of Kichx̱áan (Ketchikan), which remains today tragically unacknowledged by ANCSA and — yes — landless.

Indigenous peoples have stewarded the entirety of Southeast Alaska since time immemorial. These five communities are asking that one-half of 1% of it be returned to their care, acknowledging both that they made it what we love and that they are Alaska Native villages.

Some small-time conservationists are hesitant to release land from federal control and return it to its original Indigenous stewards. Quite bluntly, this is problematic. The inaction on its own perpetuates colonialism, and the assumptions that lead to it are born of ignorance, which is why national conservation groups have begun acknowledging this error.

This leads us to Knight’s two closing concerns. One, we can agree on: “A healthy public examination about the validity of landless claims is taboo due to social sensitivity.” Yes, this is true. Why? Because rhetoric like Knight’s is not only unhealthy and unfortunately predominant, but also false.

When we productively discuss the topic, it sounds like this: These claims are valid. This is Indigenous land. Why has it taken us so long to say so? Who has been holding back this progress? What should we do now?

The last answer is obvious: pass the Landless legislation. It is unanimously championed by Alaska’s duly elected bipartisan delegation. It is broadly supported by tribal leaders. A plethora of factual research details the economic, cultural, and ecological benefits for all involved.

Knight’s final bit of fearmongering might very well be the strongest case against her own stance, in that passage of the Landless legislation would indeed further the cause of Alaska Native peoples through empowering Indigenous stewardship, values and communities.

That is not a nightmare; it is a dream worth realizing for the betterment of all Alaskans.

• Mike Schwartz is 82 years old, born and raised in Petersburg. His great-grandchildren are the seventh generation of family residents there. He was adopted and named by Tlingit elder Pete Martin Sr. decades ago, into a Tlingit society that has been proven to exist in Southeast Alaska for 10,000 years.

More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

From left, Senators Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) and Susan Collins (R-Maine) head to the Senate chamber at the Capitol in Washington on Tuesday morning, July 1, 2025. Senate Republicans were racing on Tuesday morning to lock down the votes to pass their sweeping tax and domestic police bill, after an all-night session of voting and negotiating with holdouts left Trump’s agenda hanging in the balance. (Tierney L. Cross/The New York Times)
My Turn: Murkowski’s moment of shame

She has no excuse for not following the model Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., set when he killed Joe Biden’s biggest initiative in 2021.

Gov. Mike Dunleavy speaks about his decision to veto House Bill 57 during a press conference at the Alaska State Capitol on Monday, May 19, 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Governor deposits a veto to help predatory lenders

Thousands of Alaskans get so squeezed on their finances every year that… Continue reading

Deven Mitchell is the executive director and chief executive officer of the Alaska Permanent Fund Corp. (Photo courtesy of the Alaska Permanent Fund Corp.)
Opinion: The key to a stronger fund: Diversification

Diversification is a means of stabilizing returns and mitigating risk

The Tongass National Forest sign seen en route to the Mendenhall Glacier Visitor Center on Wednesday, Aug. 28, 2019. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: Environmentalists without an honest cause

I took a little liberty with their statement because they took a lot of liberty with the facts.

A Juneau Police Department vehicle patrols a neighborhood near Juneau International Airport after warning a person camped along the side of the road they need to move their campsite on Saturday, May 24, 2025. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Homeless, not helpless — Part 2

In January 2017, I penned a My Turn entitled “Homeless Not Helpless”… Continue reading

In this June 23, 2016, photo, the Alaska Marine Highway ferry Matanuska passes Eagle Glacier. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
More competitive wages will shore up AMHS workforce

The Alaska Marine Highway System provides transportation along thousands of miles of… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Life is harder when you outlive your support group

Mom was ready to die, knowing the world would be OK. Or so she thought.

Participants in “No Kings” protest walk down Egan Drive waving an American flag on Saturday, June 14, 2025 (Natalie Buttner / Juneau Empire)
Opinion: Why we protest

Along with more than a thousand other Juneauites, I attended the “No… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Public broadcasting is part of the fabric of Alaska’s rural communities

Public broadcasting forms an essential part of the fabric of Alaska’s rural… Continue reading

Members of the Yées Ḵu.oo Dance Group perform at the Cancer Survivors Day walk on Sunday, June 8, 2025, at Overstreet Park. (Ellie Ruel / Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Thank you

Each June, people around the world commemorate National Cancer Survivors Day. Cancer… Continue reading

U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Jan. 24, 2025. (Tom Brenner / The New York Times)
My Turn: But wait a minute, if…

I thought it might be worthwhile to add some historical perspective to… Continue reading