Opinion: Tolerating dissent is good business and good for democracy

Opinion: Tolerating dissent is good business and good for democracy

Confident leadership understands that some dissention in the ranks fosters critical thinking and builds solid morale.

It’s too early to know how many nonpolitical public employees appointed by Gov. Bill Walker or his predecessor will leave their jobs after receiving requests for resignation letters from governor-elect Mike Dunleavy. For many, it may hinge on whether they interpret the request as a benign formality or a demand for loyalty to a partisan political agenda.

The list of positions who received them include criminal prosecutors, geologists and petroleum engineers and health care professionals. According to Walker, it’s caused a lot of “anxiety and uncertainty” for dedicated public servants who weren’t subjected to similar requests when he took office four years ago.

Tuckerman Babcock, who will serve as Dunleavy’s chief of staff, said the request wasn’t “meant to intimidate or scare anybody.” The intent was to give them a chance to indicate if they want to “work on this agenda” by working “in this administration.” But if they don’t “express a positive desire” to do so, they’re likely to be terminated.

And that’s where the “pledge of loyalty” begins to make its appearance. It’s how Charles Wohlforth described the request before wondering if state employees will be fired for not supporting all “64 points of the Alaska Republican Party platform.”

Of course, few people know what’s in that entire platform. But Wohlforth’s point is that during the campaign Dunleavy didn’t articulate a detailed agenda. For instance, he points out that Dunleavy “never said specifically how he would address crime or how the Department of Law would work differently.” So prosecutors asked to submit their resignations are in the dark. And the inconsistent statements Dunleavy made about health care and education make it less clear for people in those professions.

The only policies Dunleavy firmly committed to relates to the budget. He promised to balance it by slashing state spending while restoring the Permanent Fund Dividend and enacting no new personal taxes.

That means public employees across the board will be expected to do more with less. Maybe “a lot more with less,” which is how, only a month after being sworn into office, President Donald Trump described his approach to the federal budget. Just as former House Speaker John Boehner claimed in 2013. “Republicans have shown that the federal government can, and must, do more with less,” he said, adding a balanced budget was achievable “if the president and Washington Democrats come to the table willing to make the same tough choices.”

Of course, that’s all proven to be hollow rhetoric. Congress hasn’t balanced a budget for almost 20 years. Deficits grew while George W. Bush was president and Republicans controlled both house of Congress. It’s no different now under Trump. Except that many Republican fiscal hawks chose to bow to Trump instead of defending that principle.

At the state level the issue isn’t as complicated. So, it’ll be easier for Dunleavy than it was for Bush, Trump and Boehner to remain committed to deep cuts in government spending. But that doesn’t mean his fiscal policy will be good for Alaskans or our economy.

And for Babcock, the more important agenda may be loyalty to the Republican Party.

Babcock was elected party chairman in May 2016. After the election the following November, Reps. Gabrielle LeDoux of Anchorage, Louise Stutes of Kodiak and Paul Seaton of Homer, all Republicans, aligned themselves with 17 Democrats and two independents to form a majority coalition.

How did Babcock respond? By recommending the party “actively recruit and support a transparent, honest member of the Republican team for the next election cycle.” As that approached, he tried to prevent them from appearing on the Republican primary ballot. All along it appears he was “less bothered by the moderate ideology of the three” than how they “abandoned the team.”

Seaton compared the party’s governance under Babcock to a “central committee” like those ruling Iran and China. It “chooses the candidate” he said, then when people get to vote, they “can only vote on the approved candidate.”

Confident leadership understands that some dissension in the ranks fosters critical thinking and builds solid morale. As chairman of the state Republican Party, it was within Babcock’s right to repress it. But it’ll be bad for our government if he’s allowed to operate that way as the governor’s chief of staff.


• Rich Moniak is a Juneau resident and retired civil engineer with more than 25 years of experience working in the public sector. He contributes a weekly “My Turn” to the Juneau Empire. My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire.


More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

Dan Allard (right), a flood fighting expert for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, explains how Hesco barriers function at a table where miniature replicas of the three-foot square and four-foot high barriers are displayed during an open house Nov. 14 at Thunder Mountain Middle School to discuss flood prevention options in Juneau. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Our comfort with spectacle became a crisis

If I owned a home in the valley that was damaged by… Continue reading

The site of the now-closed Tulsequah Chief mine. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Maybe the news is ‘No new news’ on Canada’s plans for Tulsequah Chief mine cleanup

In 2015, the British Columbia government committed to ending Tulsequah Chief’s pollution… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Voter fact left out of news

With all the post-election analysis, one fact has escaped much publicity. When… Continue reading

The Alaska Psychiatric Institute in Anchorage. (Alaska Department of Family and Community Services photo)
My Turn: Rights for psychiatric patients must have state enforcement

Kim Kovol, commissioner of the state Department of Family and Community Services,… Continue reading

People living in areas affected by flooding from Suicide Basin pick up free sandbags on Oct. 20 at Thunder Mountain Middle School. (City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Opinion: Mired in bureaucracy, CBJ long-term flood fix advances at glacial pace

During meetings in Juneau last week, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE)… Continue reading

Rosa Parks, whose civil rights legacy has recent been subject to revision in class curriculums. (Public domain photo from the National Archives and Records Administration Records)
My Turn: Proud to be ‘woke’

Wokeness: the quality of being alert to and concerned about social injustice… Continue reading

The settlement of Sermiligaaq in Greenland (Ray Swi-hymn / CC BY-SA 2.0)
My Turn: Making the Arctic great again

It was just over five years ago, in the summer of 2019,… Continue reading

The Alaska Psychiatric Institute in Anchorage. (Alaska Department of Family and Community Services photo)
My Turn: Small wins make big impacts at Alaska Psychiatric Institute

The Alaska Psychiatric Institute (API), an 80-bed psychiatric hospital located in Anchorage… Continue reading

President Donald Trump and Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy pose for a photo aboard Air Force One during a stopover at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson in Anchorage in 2019. (Sheila Craighead / White House photo)
Opinion: Dunleavy has the prerequisite incompetence to work for Trump

On Tuesday it appeared that Gov. Mike Dunleavy was going to be… Continue reading

After Hurricane Katrina in 2005, many Louisiana homes were rebuilt with the living space on the second story, with garage space below, to try to protect the home from future flooding. (Infrogmation of New Orleans via Wikimedia, CC BY-SA)
Misperceptions stand in way of disaster survivors wanting to rebuild safer, more sustainable homes

As Florida and the Southeast begin recovering from 2024’s destructive hurricanes, many… Continue reading

The F/V Liberty, captained by Trenton Clark, fishes the Pacific near Metlakatla on Aug. 20, 2024. (Ash Adams/The New York Times)
My Turn: Charting a course toward seafood independence for Alaska’s vulnerable food systems

As a commercial fisherman based in Sitka and the executive director of… Continue reading