Southeast Alaska LGBTQ+ Alliance Board Chair JoLynn Shriber reads a list the names of killed transgender people as Thunder Mountain High School students Kyla Stevens, center, and Laila Williams hold flags in the wind during a transgender remembrance at Marine Park on Wednesday, Nov. 20, 2019. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)

Southeast Alaska LGBTQ+ Alliance Board Chair JoLynn Shriber reads a list the names of killed transgender people as Thunder Mountain High School students Kyla Stevens, center, and Laila Williams hold flags in the wind during a transgender remembrance at Marine Park on Wednesday, Nov. 20, 2019. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)

Opinion: The toxic debate about transgender care

There are three bills related to transgender issues in public schools that are working their way through the state House. It’s an understatement to say they’re contentious. And as with any debate over a complex subject this one shouldn’t be reduced to the common binaries of good and bad.

For my part, I’m going to venture into what journalist Jesse Signal describes as “an absolute minefield” by trying to bring attention to a report that some of America’s major media outlets chose to ignore.

Signal’s piece, titled “The Cass Review Won’t Fade Away” was published in The Dispatch on Monday. I was drawn to it after reading an earlier article in The Atlantic by British journalist Helen Lewis.

“In a world without partisan politics,” she wrote, “the Cass report on youth gender medicine would prompt serious reflection from American trans-rights activists, their supporters in the media, and the doctors and institutions offering hormonal and surgical treatments to minors.”

The implication in her opening paragraph is that parts of the media weren’t interested in seriously examining what appears to be a very important and detailed study about transgender medical treatment. She’s right. As Singal pointed out, it wasn’t covered at all by CNN, NPR and several other major outlets.

The Cass Review, as it’s formerly called, was commissioned by the English National Health Service. It placed Dr. Hilary Cass, a former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, at its helm. The 388-page final report was published April 10. Lewis referred to it as “the most thorough consideration yet of this field.”

If that’s true, then it was irresponsible journalism not to cover the story.

Singal and Lewis began writing about trans issues years ago. Their interests are well aligned with the objective Cass described in the forward to her report.

“It is about what the healthcare approach should be, and how best to help the growing number of children and young people who are looking for support from the NHS in relation to their gender identity.”

But to trans-rights activist groups, she crossed the line by, among other things, stating the long-term outcomes of interventions for gender-related distress is “an area of remarkably weak evidence.”

She expected the criticism. And probably the “pretty vile emails” that arrived after the report was published. It’s one of the few “areas of healthcare where professionals are so afraid to openly discuss their views,” she wrote, because they’ll be “vilified on social media” where name-calling echoes the worst bullying behaviour.”

That toxicity has also impacted journalists who, as Signal wrote, try “to write about this issue in a journalistic rather than a cheerleading way.”

For years Lewis advocated for trans rights and equality. Then after raising concerns related to transgender accommodations at domestic violence shelters she was labeled a “transphobe.”

The Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLADD) accused Signal of using his journalist platform “to spread misinformation and harm LGBTQ people.” They highlighted an earlier Atlantic cover story he wrote that focused on a “small but vocal group of men and women who have transitioned, only to return to their assigned sex,” and complained he privileged their stories over others by not including “a single happy, well-adjusted trans teen among its host of central characters for the first 9,000-plus words.”

That’s a curious argument coming from an organization that’s defending an obvious minority population. What Signal did is give the minority within that minority a voice they too deserve.

But there’s a strategy to discrediting the messenger. It’s intended to discourage debate.

As is demanding that writers “Stop questioning science that is SETTLED.”

That’s exactly what GLADD did two months ago in an open letter to the New York Times. It was signed by Alaskans Together For Equality and dozens of others who believe the Times’ coverage of transgender people is irresponsibly biased.

The Cass Review says the science is far from settled. The Atlantic and New York Times were right to cover it. The rest of the news media should have too.

With three bills up for debate, our legislators can’t avoid the issue. What they should do is pick up the report. They’ll learn a lot more from an in-depth study by healthcare professionals than the activist groups in either corner claiming they have all the answers.

• Rich Moniak is a Juneau resident and retired civil engineer with more than 25 years of experience working in the public sector. Columns, My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire. Have something to say? Here’s how to submit a My Turn or letter.

More in Opinion

Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom addresses the crowd during an inaugural celebration for her and Gov. Mike Dunleavy at Elizabeth Peratrovich Hall on Jan. 20, 2023. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: The many truths Dahlstrom will deny

“Now more than ever, we need real conservative leadership in Washington to… Continue reading

A person departs Bartlett Regional Hospital on July 26, 2023. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: The importance of a strong, independent community hospital

Juneau’s city-owned Bartlett Regional Hospital (BRH) is in the news, presenting our… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Disappointed by JAHC director’s opposition to Ship-Free Saturdays

As a member of the Juneau Arts and Humanities Council, I was… Continue reading

Juneau residents pack a room at the downtown public library for a June 6 meeting of Eaglecrest Ski Area’s board of directors. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Eaglecrest unplugged

Serving on a board or commission is hard work and that service… Continue reading

Downtown Juneau in late October of 2022. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Mitigating the loss of tax revenue from cruise ship free Saturdays

The cruise ship free Saturday initiative presents us with a modified lesson… Continue reading

Leaders at Bartlett Regional Hospital listen to comments from residents during a forum Monday about proposed cuts to some services. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
My Turn: Bartlett board faces challenges

Once upon a time, Alaska’s capital had a well-run municipal hospital, but… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: SEARHC’s goals seem likely to limit, rather than expand, health options in Juneau

Max Mertz’s comments at the Bartlett Regional Hospital public forum about SEARHC’s… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Allow locals to have their town back once a week during the summer

Perhaps Nate Vallier shrugs when he sees eagles and bears (My Turn,… Continue reading

Former President Donald Trump arrives at Trump Tower after he was found guilty of all counts in his criminal trial in New York on May 30. (Hiroko Masuike/The New York Times)
Opinion: Trump’s new fixers

“Alaska Republicans back Trump after historic conviction in hush money case,” the… Continue reading

A Carnival cruise ship is berthed Juneau’s cruise ship docks during the summer of 2022. (Michael S. Lockett / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Ignoring the consequences of ship-free Saturdays?

Backers of a cruise initiative to block large cruise ships from docking… Continue reading

Two skiers settle into a lift chair as they pass trees with fresh snow at Eaglecrest Ski Area on Dec. 20, 2023. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Eaglecrest Ski Area attempting to do too much without sensible leadership

Ever wonder what the 50-year-old clearcut above the beginner slopes at Eaglecrest… Continue reading