Opinion: New study shouldn’t revive fluoridation in Juneau

Opinion: New study shouldn’t revive fluoridation in Juneau

Let’s focus instead on good nutrition, proper dental hygeine.

While fluoridation of the municipal water supply in Juneau has been a dead issue since it was resoundingly defeated in a 2007 referendum, a recent study reported in the Empire and elsewhere has resurrected it. This study found an increase in the number of dental carie (cavity) procedures in Juneau Medicaid recipients under 7 years of age in 2012 as opposed to 2003. It found no statistically significant increase in the number of procedures in older children.

Even the authors admit this study is limited in scope, since it covers only two single years, nine years apart. It fails to account for any other factors besides fluoridation that might have contributed to an increase in carie treatment under Medicaid. Most notably, the measure of tooth decay in the study was Medicaid reimbursement rates and procedures, yet the study made no attempt to account for changes in Medicaid coverage between the two years. This is huge.

It is entirely possible that the increase in dental carie procedures was not due to more cavities from lack of fluoride, but to more aggressive treatment of borderline cases that may not have been treated previously. If Medicaid increased their reimbursement rates or made it easier for dentists to obtain Medicaid reimbursements, then dentists might bill more treatments to Medicaid.

[Opinion: Ending Juneau’s water fluoride program was a mistake]

The paper admits changes in reimbursement rates when it notes: “According to retired State Dental Chief Dr. Whistler … Medicaid made adjustments in the form of increases for dental claims CDT codes in 2009 and 2010, which may have resulted in Medicaid reimbursement increases even without the provision of more services.”

Remember this study is not measuring the actual amount of tooth decay, but the number and cost of dental caries procedures reimbursed under Medicaid. The failure to account for the impact of changes in Medicaid reimbursement seriously undermines the study’s results and conclusions.

Whatever you think about this or any study, the discussion about fluoridation in Juneau was never solely about potential benefits of putting fluoride in the water. It was about weighing those benefits against the potential risks, especially to specific subsets of the population, such as infants and the elderly.

It was about whether the water supply is the best way to administer fluoride, given that its benefit is primarily topical and fluoride toothpaste and gels are universally available to those who want them. And it was about the public’s right to choose whether to ingest fluoride, since the municipal water supply belongs to all of us and we all have a right to clean drinking water.

[Opinion: 53 packs of tortillas]

If fluoride was some utterly benign substance that impacted only teeth, it would be one thing. It isn’t. There is credible research indicating fluoride is a neurotoxin that impacts the developing brains of fetuses and infants. It can affect the thyroid gland in doses close to those recommended in fluoridated water. Research shows it can cause arthritic symptoms and bone fractures. There is a reason every tube of fluoride toothpaste sold in this country has a poison warning label that starts by saying “do not swallow.”

In 2007 there was robust debate about all these issues. Fluoridation proponents spent more than $160,000 to make their case, outspending opponents 20-1. The public was not convinced. The proposition was overwhelmingly rejected 61-37 percent.

This recent study was newsworthy, mostly because it was about our own town. However, given the study’s serious limitations and the fact that Juneau thoroughly considered the issue and came to a clear conclusion, it is unlikely that an attempt to resurrect fluoridation is in the cards — nor should it be.

Let’s focus instead on those things we agree improve dental health: good nutrition, proper dental hygiene, sealants and fluoride treatments when appropriate. We can encourage education and adoption of these proven measures in our homes and in our schools, and leave the issue of fluoridating Juneau’s water in its grave where it belongs.


• David Ottoson is a resident of Juneau. My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire.


More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Quality of treatment at Bartlett Regional Hospital is excellent

I recently experienced a relatively serious chest injury and received treatment at… Continue reading

Passengers of the Norwegian Bliss look out across downtown Juneau as they wait to disembark on April 17, 2023. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Juneau’s economy is not on the line — Ship-Free Saturdays is about better balance

Judging by the “Save Juneau” posters one would think that Juneau’s economic… Continue reading

U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan addresses a joint session of the Alaska State Legislature in the House chambers on Feb. 7, 2023. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Sen. Sullivan sinks to a new low

Last week, Sen. Dan Sullivan mimicked Donald Trump’s endless stream of baseless… Continue reading

Members of local business organizations greet cruise passengers with maps and other handouts as they disembark from the Norwegian Bliss on April 25, 2022. (Michael S. Lockett / Juneau Empire file photo)
A call for collaboration, not restrictions on cruise ship tourism

Please don’t sign. I feel it is time to speak up about… Continue reading

Juneau School District Superintendent Frank Hauser provides an overview of restructuring options being considered during a Community Budget Input Session at Thunder Mountain High School on Jan. 31. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Smearing school board members and the superintendent is vindictive and destructive

A school consolidation plan announced by the Juneau School District (JSD) has… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Gloomy predictions for ship-free days are a misleading scare tactic

“What? Only one day a week ship-free? Can’t we have Sundays too?”… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: A day of rest from cruise ships is good for Juneau

A lot has been said about the Saturday free day from large… Continue reading

Most Read