My Turn: Our search for villains and heroes

  • By Rich Moniak
  • Friday, October 30, 2015 1:03am
  • Opinion

Americans love political villains. For some on the left, Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wisc., accommodated that need last week. His statement that he wouldn’t accept the speakership of the House if he had to give up time with his family was met with swift charges of hypocrisy. But aren’t we really looking for heroes whenever we’re so quick to identify a villain?

Ryan’s sin, in Erin Gloria Ryan’s words, was spending “much of his political career fighting laws that promote realistic work-life balance for parents of all socioeconomic levels.” If he hadn’t, she wrote “asking for family time would make him look more like a hero and less like a hypocrite.”

Jessica Valenti at The Guardian separated the message from the messenger though. “It’s fantastic to see a male politician prioritize his family life as he considers a national position of power,” she wrote, before concluding, “let’s point out Ryan’s hypocrisy and take him to task on his policies — but let’s do it strategically.”

That strategic approach isn’t how Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., and former Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley responded to the revelations about Exxon’s climate change research. The two Democratic presidential candidates joined a few members of Congress and a small chorus of scientists and activists calling for an investigation by the Justice Department.

As I wrote last week, the oil giant funded research which reportedly showed links between burning fossil fuels and the rise in global temperatures. However, their public position has been that human activity isn’t contributing to climate change. If that’s true, did they break a federal law?

The problem is a criminal investigation would more than likely put Exxon on the defensive and seriously delay a full release of their findings. For anyone who believes climate change is the greatest threat to civilization, the critical need is to put a spotlight on that information, not identify a villain. Like Valenti’s nuanced approached to Ryan’s story, we need to slow down and look for ways to leverage Exxon’s research toward a greater good.

If we can avoid turning Ryan and Exxon into villains, do we still need heroes for these causes? Who would they be and what purposes could they serve?

Scott T. Allison is professor of psychology at the University of Richmond and has written several books about heroes and leadership. “Heroes show us the secrets to unlocking our fullest potential as human beings,” he wrote when reflecting on the legacy of Nelson Mandela. “They do so by role-modeling virtue, by clarifying complex and paradoxical life truths, by equipping us with emotional intelligence, and by revealing how their journey can be our journey, too.”

Like Mandela, Martin Luther King Jr. is remembered as America’s civil rights hero. His story leads us to the nonviolent resistance effectively practiced by Mohandas K. Gandhi. And one of the primary influences in Gandhi’s life was Henry David Thoreau’s essay “Civil Disobedience.”

For many in America’s environmental movement, Thoreau’s book “Walden” earned him the title of national hero. But in a recent New Yorker article titled “Pond Scum,” Kathryn Schulz questions why we admire him at all given “his hypocrisy, his sanctimony, his dour asceticism, and his scorn.” For evidence, Schulz quotes directly from Walden. “Sometimes, when I compare myself with other men” Thoreau wrote, “it seems as if I were more favored by the gods than they.”

Yes, Thoreau’s personality was villainous. And he never led a movement or brought about change in his time. Maybe that’s because, as Schultz pointed out, he was too absorbed in his own little world.

But Gandhi was a genuinely humble man inspired by Thoreau’s writings. He never glamorized Thoreau’s life or focused on his faults. In following Gandhi’s model, King also separated the message from the messenger and applied it to his cause. The hero was born from an idea, not the person.

We’re not supposed to worship real life heroes. They’re not gods, and we don’t want to be reduced to a cult. As Allison suggests, our journey can mirror theirs if we look at them as teachers instead of heroic personalities.

“Be the change that you wish to see in the world,” Gandhi famously said. Whether its family values, climate change or any other issue that means looking inward first, if we can discover the hero within us there would be less of a need for superheroes, both fictional and real. And maybe then we wouldn’t spend time looking for villains to condemn.

• Rich Moniak lives in Juneau and is a retired civil engineer with more than 25 years of experience in the public sector.

More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

Former Juneau Mayor Ken Koelsch in 2018. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Assembly needs to retreat

We might not be privy to what the Assembly’s agenda is, but… Continue reading

The Stikine River Flats area in the Tongass National Forest is viewed from a helicopter on July 19, 2021. The Stikine River flows from British Columbia to Southeast Alaska. It is one of the major transboundary rivers impacted by mines in British Columbia. (Photo by Alicia Stearns/U.S. Forest Service)
Opinion: Facing transboundary mining, Alaskans shouldn’t buy industry rhetoric

“Rest assured,” writes Michael Goehring, president of the British Columbia Mining Association,… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire File)
Letter: Attorney general’s letter to libraries are an abuse of office

Earlier this month Treg Taylor, Alaska’s attorney general, published a letter to… Continue reading

An aging outhouse overlooks Tenakee Inlet. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire File)
My Turn: Murkowski’s bill will dramatically change map of public land in Southeast Alaska

There has been very little reporting on federal legislation that would greatly… Continue reading

(Photo courtesy of the City and Borough of Juneau)
Opinion: Choosing a seat at the table

To advocates for limiting cruise ship tourism and combatting climate change, partnering… Continue reading

A photo of Juneau featured on the front cover of this year’s annual “Economic Indicators and Outlook” by the Juneau Economic Development Council. (Juneau Economic Development Council)
Opinion: Troubling trends deserve Assembly attention

The economic indicators report published last month by the Juneau Economic Development… Continue reading

Passengers return to the Norwegian Sun on Oct. 25, the final day of this year’s cruise ship season in Juneau. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire File)
My Turn: “Partnering” with cruise ship industry isn’t in Juneau’s interests

Regarding Jim Powell’s lecture at the Evening at Egan event on Friday,… Continue reading

Sen. Tommy Tuberville, R-Ala., questions Navy Adm. Lisa Franchetti during a Senate Armed Services Committee hearing on Sept. 14 on Capitol Hill in Washington. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)
Opinion: Music to the ears of America’s adversaries

Two weeks ago, U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan made a commendable effort to… Continue reading

Fog drifts through the trees in the Tongass National Forest on Monday, Dec. 9, 2019. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)
My Turn: A response to ‘There are no Landless Natives in Southeast Alaska’

Where to begin? Rebecca Knight’s — at best implicitly xenophobic and factually… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire File)
Letter: Thankful to see the construction by local Native organiztions

Sitting in my living room listening to nails pounding into the old… Continue reading

Alaska Permanent Fund Corp. board members, staff and advisors meet Oct. 30 at the corporation’s headquarters in Juneau to discuss a proposal to raise the fund’s rate of return by making riskier investments. The idea stalled when advisors suggested the strategy and timing are ill-advised. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire File).
My Turn: Need for accounting and legislative oversight of the Permanent Fund

The governor or Legislature or both need to conduct an audit format… Continue reading