Youth plaintiffs in the climate change lawsuit, Held vs. Montana, arrive at the Lewis and Clark County Courthouse, on June 20, 2023, in Helena, Mont., for the final day of the trial. A Montana judge on Monday sided with young environmental activists who said state agencies were violating their constitutional right to a clean and healthful environment by permitting fossil fuel development without considering its effect on the climate. (Thom Bridge/Independent Record via AP, File)

Youth plaintiffs in the climate change lawsuit, Held vs. Montana, arrive at the Lewis and Clark County Courthouse, on June 20, 2023, in Helena, Mont., for the final day of the trial. A Montana judge on Monday sided with young environmental activists who said state agencies were violating their constitutional right to a clean and healthful environment by permitting fossil fuel development without considering its effect on the climate. (Thom Bridge/Independent Record via AP, File)

Victors in landmark climate change lawsuit reset sights on Alaska

Montana ruling establishes youths’ rights to clean environment, after similar case failed in Alaska.

A quote by attorney Andrew Welle in this story has been corrected to refer to the significance of the Sagoonick decision in Alaska, rather than the Montana ruling. A statement by Welle about the dissenting opinion in the Alaska case has been omitted.

A landmark environmental court ruling in Montana on Monday has striking implications for Alaska, particularly with the vow by the organization behind it to bring a similar case here. It won’t be the first time they’ve done it, but this time there’s a lot more science — and precedent.

The Montana case is being heralded as a groundbreaking victory because it is the first time a judge has found a governmental duty to protect citizens from climate change. The case, brought by 16 youths ranging in age from 5 to 22, found state agencies in Montana violated the plaintiffs’ constitutional right to a clean and healthful environment by permitting fossil fuel development without considering climate impacts.

An attorney with the firm that brought that case was the lead counsel for the Sagoonick case in Alaska, which also involved 16 youths. The lead plaintiff was Summer Sagoonick, an Inupiaq resident of Unalakleet, who emphasized Alaska Natives count on wildlife and the land for survival. The lawsuit targeted the governor, the State of Alaska and various agencies over greenhouse gas emissions.

The court dismissed the case in 2018, saying it more properly belonged before the state legislature. Our Children’s Trust appealed the decision, beginning an appellate process that concluded with a narrow loss in the Alaska Supreme Court in January 2022.

“The most important thing about the Sagoonick decision for Alaska is that it shows a path forward for the state’s youth to secure their right to a safe climate system,” said Andrew Welle, a senior staff attorney at the non-profit law firm Our Children’s Trust, which brought the case in Montana, as it has all 50 states, including in Alaska in 2017.

Welle confirmed Our Children’s Trust is actively working on a new case to be brought in Alaska following the Montana decision, but declined to provide specifics, including timing.

The ruling this week in Held v. Montana was welcomed by local environmental activists.

“We’re thrilled with the Montana decision,” said Elaine Schroeder, co-chair of Juneau350. The local environmental group has been working to stop two fossil fuel extraction efforts on the North Slope: the Willow project planned by ConocoPhillips and the Alaska LNG Project.

“We’re eager to support the filing of a new climate lawsuit against the state of Alaska,” she said.

“You have to look at the different constitutional provisions — and each court weighs how each case is presented,” said Carole Holley, managing attorney in the Alaska regional office of Earthjustice, a non-profit environmental law group that was not involved in the Montana lawsuit. “What Our Children’s Trust was able to do was to present an impressive amount of climate science and information that was quite persuasive to the district court judge. I am excited to see what they can bring to Alaska.”

The Montana case had an interesting twist during the trial, Welle said. The government had requested five days to present its case. In the end it used just part of the first day.

“Alaska’s constitution includes strong protections of access — and equal access — to natural resources,” Welle said. He referenced Article 8 in the state constitution, which governs natural resources. Known as the public trust doctrine, it contains language about development of its resources consistent with the public interest.

The Alaska Supreme Court ruling on the Sagoonick case in early 2022 was a split decision. Justices Peter J. Maassen and Justice Susan M. Carney dissented, writing that “a balanced consideration of prudential doctrines requires that we explicitly recognize a constitutional right to a liveable climate.” Both remain on the court.

The Montana ruling opens a new door.

“It’s indicative of a shift in the tide of constitutional climate litigation,” Welle said. “Ten years ago courts were punting on the issue, not understanding the importance of the separation of powers in determining whether the government’s action is endangering the health and safety of young people, and violating their constitutional rights.”

• Contact Meredith Jordan at meredith.jordan@juneauempire.com or (907) 615-3190.

More in News

(Juneau Empire File)
Aurora forecast for the week of Nov. 27

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

The Hubbard state ferry (left), the newest vessel in the Alaska Marine Highway System fleet, is back in service in northern Southeast Alaska after a maintenance period as the LeConte, which also serves the region, undergoes a scheduled annual overhaul until March 3. (Photo courtesy of the Alaska Marine Highway System)
AMHS leaders hopeful staffing, sailings are trending up

More employees at key positions hired, restoration of cross-Gulf sailings next summer envisioned.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Wednesday, Nov. 30, 2023

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

A ConocoPhillips oil rig operating during winter on Alaska’s North Slope is featured on the cover of the U.S. Bureau of Land Management’s report recommending approval of the Willow oil project. (U.S. Bureau of Land Management)
Judge rejects calls to halt winter construction work on Willow oil project in Alaska during appeal

A federal judge in Alaska on Friday rejected requests from environmental groups… Continue reading

Strips of chum salmon hang on a drying rack on Aug. 22, 2007. A new study by federal and state biologists identies marine heat waves in the Bering Sea and Gulf of Alaska as the likely culprit in the recent crashes of Western Alaska chum salmon runs. (Photo by S.Zuray / U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)
Study points to concurrent marine heat waves as culprit in Western Alaska chum declines

Successive marine heat waves appear to have doomed much of the chum… Continue reading

Marzena Whitmore (elf) and Dale Hudson (Santa), pose for a photo with Benny Orvin (partially obscured), 6, and his siblings Lilly, 4, and Remi, 2, taken by their mother Alex as their father Randy watches during Gallery Walk in downtown Juneau on Friday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Coming together as one giant community family at Gallery Walk

Thousands share an evening of entertainment in the outdoor chill, visiting shops and hot chocolate.

Girls teams face off on the twin courts of the main gym at Juneau-Douglas Yadaa.at Kalé High School during the Juneau Invitational Volleyball Extravaganza on Oct. 15, 2022. The Juneau Board of Education on Friday unanimously voted to seek advice from outside council on a new state policy banning transgender girls from high school sports teams. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
School board unanimously votes to seek outside legal advice on new statewide transgender sports ban

Juneau reportedly first district to take step that may lead to lawsuit challenging policy.

A Capital City Fire/Rescue truck parks outside the main entrance of the Riverview Senior Living complex Monday after Nathan Bishop, 58, is found alive in the attic 40 hours after being reported missing from the facility where he is a resident. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
State reviewing Riverview Senior Living after missing resident found in attic 40 hours later

Officials unaware of similar cases in Alaska; facility says steps to prevent such incidents underway

Search and rescue officials examine the area about 11 miles south of the center of Wrangell where a landslide occurred on Nov. 20. Five people are confirmed dead from the landslide and one still missing. (Photo courtesy of Alaska Department of Public Safety)
Body of fifth Wrangell landslide victim found; one person still missing

Otto Florschutz, 65, found Thursday evening; Derek Heller, 12, still missing among family of five.

Most Read