Kathleen Turley, second from right, waits with supporters for the Juneau District Court to open for a lawsuit against her by trapper John Forrest for interfering with his traps on the Davies Creek Trail in December.

Kathleen Turley, second from right, waits with supporters for the Juneau District Court to open for a lawsuit against her by trapper John Forrest for interfering with his traps on the Davies Creek Trail in December.

Judge: Trap-springer liable, but won’t pay

A Juneau hiker was not justified when she set off two fur-bearing traps after she rescued an ensnared bald eagle, but she won’t owe the trapper any money, a Juneau District Court judge ruled Friday.

Judge Thomas Nave found that trapper John Forrest failed to prove at trial that hiker Kathleen K. Turley caused him any loss of income by springing two of three traps unnecessarily.

“It is the conclusion of this court that defendant Ms. Turley is liable to plaintiff Mr. Forrest for any loss due to her unjustified interference with his trap at half mile on the trail but that plaintiff failed to prove any damages,” Nave wrote.

Forrest sued Turley last month, seeking $5,000 in damages, for springing several of his lawfully set traps on Davies Creek trail in December 2014. The lawsuit did not pertain to the trap that snared the eagle on Dec. 24, but to three other traps that Turley said she sprung on the same trail that day and on Dec. 27 out of safety concerns.

After hearing testimony Monday and closing arguments Thursday, Nave found Turley was justified in springing a marten trap close to the wolverine trap that incidentally caught an eagle. Turley had three dogs with her and tied them to a bush as she worked for an hour to free the eagle. The eagle was still alive, but later had to be euthanized.

“As a cautionary measure, she sprung that trap to assure that, while she was working, the dogs didn’t get loose and invade that trap, adding to the emergency,” Nave wrote. “When evaluating the circumstances and objectively applying facts as the defendant reasonably perceived them, the court finds that she was justified when she rendered the trap near the eagle harmless.”

But, the judge said, it wasn’t necessary for Turley to spring another marten box trap as she hiked back down the trail. She sprang the same trap again — unnecessarily, the judge said — on Dec. 27 as she led a group of Juneau Alpine hikers down the trail at dusk.

Nave said Turley had other options to ensure safety. She could have leashed her dogs, and, “if she was concerned about that particular trap, she could have placed herself in front of it or asked someone else to do so while all the hikers passed,” Nave wrote of the second instance. “Other alternatives existed.”

Because Turley was found liable for springing those two traps, Nave said she could have owed Forrest money if he had proved he lost income over it. But Nave said he didn’t have a basis to calculate the loss of income.

“During the week in question, he recalls trapping a large beaver and a mink but could not be more specific and had not apparently given the matter much thought until asked (by the court),” Nave wrote. “Better evidence of damages might have been weekly logs of animals taken noting which traps and what portion of the trap line was productive.”

Nave continued, “Mr. Forrest may have caught a marten in the trap one half mile up the trail or he may not. It could be that he has never caught anything in a trap in that particular area.”

The plaintiffs originally sued for $5,000, then lowered that amount to $1,000 just before the trial. Forrest in his testimony Monday said he would be satisfied with $500 to $700 to account for loss of income, and in closing arguments, his attorney Zane Wilson requested between $1,000 and $1,200 to cover both income loss and punitive damages.

Nave declined to award punitive damages, which are designed to punish defendants for wrongdoing and deter others from repeating the act.

“The court cannot find by clear and convincing evidence the acts committed by Ms. Turley were outrageous, including acts done with malice or bad motives or they evidenced reckless indifference to the interest of another person,” Nave wrote.

Turley’s attorney, Nicholas Polasky, said he was pleased Turley was not held liable for one of the traps, but disappointed she was found responsible for the other two.

“We are disappointed because we disagree that Ms. Turley ever had any intent to hinder or obstruct trapping,” he told the Empire by email. “And, we continue to believe that trapping that follows the minimum applicable rules is not responsible trapping. But we had a trial, the judge heard all the evidence, Judge Nave is a very good judge, and he made a different decision. We respect that.”

Polasky added that the judge’s decision “split the baby,” in his opinion.

“My client was worried about paying more than $5,000 for something she does not think she did wrong — and she avoided that outcome,” Polasky said. “Mr. Forrest wanted to make a point about how a person should not set off traps — and on two of the three traps he made his point.”

Forrest’s attorney, Zane Wilson, said in a phone message left with the Empire that his client’s main purpose was achieved with Friday’s ruling.

“The court’s finding that Ms. Turley violated the law accomplished the primary objective Mr. Forrest had in this case,” he said.

More in News

A Princess Cruise Line ship is docked in Juneau on Aug. 25, 2021. (Michael Lockett / Juneau Empire File)
Ships in Port for the week of Sept. 18

Here’s what to expect this week.

An Alaska judge has ruled that a state lawmaker affiliated with the Oath Keepers, Rep. David Eastman, shown in this February 2022 photo, may stay on the general election ballot in November even though he's likely ineligible to hold public office  (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)
Judge keeps Oath Keepers lawmaker on November ballot

Judge ordered delaying certifying the result of the race until a trial scheduled for December.

Water rushes down Front Street, just a half block from the Bering Sea, in Nome, Alaska, on Saturday, Sept. 17, 2022 as the remnants of Typhoon Merbok moved into the region. It was a massive storm system — big enough to cover the mainland U.S. from the Pacific Ocean to Nebraska and from Canada to Texas. It influenced weather systems as far away as California, where a rare late-summer storm dropped rain on the northern part of the state, offering a measure of relief to wildfire crews but also complicating fire suppression efforts because of mud and loosened earth. (AP Photo / Peggy Fagerstrom)
Repair work begins in some Alaska towns slammed by storm

ANCHORAGE — There’s been significant damage to some roads and homes in… Continue reading

j
Sniffen indicted on sexual abuse counts

Sniffen will be arraigned Monday.

In this undated file photo the Trans-Alaska pipeline and pump station north of Fairbanks, Alaska is shown. (AP Photo / Al Grillo)
Oil price drop endangers plan to fund Alaska schools a year early

If oil prices fall, amount is automatically reduced to an amount the state can afford. At

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Juneau Police Department announces technology and reporting updates

Emergeny services and direct reporting will not be interrupted

The hoverfly can perceive electrical fields around the edges of the petals, the big white stigma, and the stamens. (Courtesy Photo / Bob Armstrong)
On the Trails: Electric flowers and platform plants

You cannot see it, it’s electric.

(Juneau Empire File / Michael Penn)
Police calls for Tuesday, Sept. 20, 2022

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Most Read