City employees, employees of North Pacific Erectors and their familes take a walk onto the new sea walk starting in front of Taku Smokeries after a ribbon cutting by the city assembly in April 2011.

City employees, employees of North Pacific Erectors and their familes take a walk onto the new sea walk starting in front of Taku Smokeries after a ribbon cutting by the city assembly in April 2011.

Seawalk, whale statue bid busts

The city will cancel the bids for the construction of the Downtown Seawalk leading to a bronze whale statue after they came in millions higher than the estimated cost.

Only two bids came in for the project, which was estimated to cost slightly more than $11 million. The lower of the two bids was nearly $14 million — about 25 percent more than the engineer’s estimate. The other bid was about $3.5 million more than projected.

“With this one, we need to look at it and say ‘OK are there ways we can adjust it? Maybe take some things out?’” said City Manager Kim Kiefer. “The options here are cutting pieces out or adding money to it.”

Rorie Watt, the city’s director of engineering, said that one or the other — or both — will likely have to happen. It’s still too early to say how exactly the city will move forward with this project, but cancelled bid process will likely delay the completion date set for next fall by about six months. Watt hopes to have a new bid out for the project within a few weeks, but first he has to find out what caused this bid to go sideways.

Each bid package provides contractors with a specific outline for the project they’re bidding on. These packages contain everything from directions and timelines to cost estimates for everything down to the planting soil and bark mulch. They also provide a “great degree of detail,” Watt said, to make sure that city is able to control the vision for the project and to keep costs down. This is because the city is required to award the project to the lowest “responsive and responsible” bidder.

“When it works well, you get great pricing,” Watt said. “It just didn’t work well in this case.”

The problem is that both of the contractors who bidded on this project — North Pacific Erectors Inc. and Dawson Construction Inc. — and the city had wildly different estimates for many of the project’s components. For instance, the city estimated that the water feature piping for the whale sculpture would cost about $300,000. North Pacific Erectors, however, estimated this piping to cost more than $900,000, and Dawson Construction estimated it would cost $475,000. The bids were full of such discrepancies.

“I had to get out my Ouija board to try and understand why the contractors did things the way they did,” Watt said. “Obviously, we’re all not operating on the same assumptions.”

And in order to fix the bid package so that the city can put it out for a second try, Watt has to make sure that the city and any potential contractors are on the same page. He will be meeting with contractors during the next few weeks to try to ensure a more successful second round of bidding, but for now the city is “back at square to step one” in the bidding process.

Kiefer said that it isn’t unusual for bids to come in over the city’s estimated cost, and Watt agreed. He has seen several bids go over the city’s estimates during his time here, but they don’t typically run over by such a large margin.

According to Watt, roughly 90 percent of bids come in less than the engineer’s estimate, and about half of the remaining 10 percent come in more expensive than the estimate but are still affordable. The case of the Downtown Seawalk project, however, falls safely within the remaining 5 percent of bids: the ones that come in over the estimate and that are too pricey too move forward with as planned.

Though city estimates are on target far more frequently than they’re not, this isn’t the first time Watt has seen a bid so far removed from estimate. Between 2006 and 2007, the engineer’s estimates missed their mark fairly often, he said. As the national economy headed into a recession, the price of commodities such as copper and oil skyrocketed, outpacing the city’s bid estimates.

Though the city doesn’t yet know what caused this bid process to be so far off, Watt said he thinks that the city may have underestimated how competitive the construction market currently is. This may have led an engineer’s estimate that was lower than it should’ve been.

“I think we have to admit that our optimism was a little excessive,” Watt said.

But there are certainly other factors that likely played into the discrepancy between the engineer’s estimate and the bids received. Projects like the Seawalk can be difficult to estimate and to bid on because they lack the precedent that comes with other, more frequently bid projects. Both parties generally have a better understanding of cost when dealing with projects like roofing or building small structures.

“Contractors can’t just say ‘Hey, what did we bid on the last Seawalk and giant whale project?’” Watt said.

More in News

A Princess Cruise Line ship is docked in Juneau on Aug. 25, 2021. (Michael Lockett / Juneau Empire File)
Ships in Port for the week of Aug. 7

Here’s what to expect this week.

Supporters of U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski wait for an opportunity to talk to her at her newly Juneau campaign headquarters Thursday evening at Kootznoowoo Plaza. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Murkowski opens up at Juneau HQ debut

Senator chats with supporters about U.S. vs. Belgium voting, moose chili and Project Veritas

U.S. Senate candidate Shoshana Gungurstein stars in a campaign sign within view of the Alaska governor’s mansion. Gungurstein, an independent, got exposure this week for being a Hollywood actress under a different last name after questions about her past went unanswered throughout the campaign. She is one of 19 candidates seeking to be among the four selected in next Tuesday’s primary to compete in the November general election. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Senate candidate sheds more light on background

Shoshana Gungurstein responds at length to recent report on past film career.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Drug arrest made in Skagway

Police say a suspicious package was intercepted.

This late-April photo shows a damaged sticker on a door at Thunder Mountain High School reminding people to social distance and wear masks inside the building. Masks will not be required in school buildings this year. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire File)
No mandatory masks or COVID-19 tests for new school year

No mandatory masks or COVID-19 tests for new school year

(Juneau Empire File / Michael Penn)
Police calls for Friday Aug. 12, 2022

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

From left, Kelsey Dean, watershed scientist with the Southeast Alaska Watershed Coalition, and Kaagwaan Eesh Manuel Rose-Bell of Keex’ Kwáan watch as crew members set up tools to drag a log into place. Healthy salmon habitat requires woody debris, typically provided by falling branches and trees, which helps create deep salmon pools and varied stream structure. (Courtesy Photos / Mary Catharine Martin)
The SalmonState: Bringing the sockeye home

Klawock Indigenous Stewards and partners are working to a once prolific sockeye salmon run.

(Juneau Empire File / Michael Penn)
Police calls for Thursday, Aug. 11, 2022

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police ID man missing from cruise ship

Coast Guard suspends search efforts

Most Read