In this Nov. 12, 2018 file photo, ballots are prepared to be tabulated in Maine’s 2nd Congressional District election in Augusta, Maine. Alaska’s Measure 2 would change the state’s voting system to a ranked-choice voting system like the one used in Maine, among other election reforms. (Robert F. Bukaty/Associated Press)

In this Nov. 12, 2018 file photo, ballots are prepared to be tabulated in Maine’s 2nd Congressional District election in Augusta, Maine. Alaska’s Measure 2 would change the state’s voting system to a ranked-choice voting system like the one used in Maine, among other election reforms. (Robert F. Bukaty/Associated Press)

Election reform measure goes beyond party lines

Supporters, opponents trade barbs over Measure 2

Supporters and detractors of a state ballot measure to change the state’s election process gave very different portrayals of what the reforms might mean for Alaska in talks this week.

Alaska’s Ballot Measure 2, a bundle of three election reforms, which if passed, would either bring clarity and equity to a system manipulated by entrenched interests or undermine and confuse a trusted process with proven results, depending on who you ask.

Measure 2 would, according to its description on sample ballots provided by the state “create an open nonpartisan primary where all candidates would appear on one ballot…establish ranked-choice voting for the general election…(and) require additional disclosures for contributions to independent expenditure groups and relating to the sources of contributions.”

It’s a bundle of voting reform measures that have never been passed together, said Shea Siegert, campaign manager for Alaskans for Better Elections, a group supporting the measure.

“We would be the first state to implement all three,” Siegert said in a video interview with the Empire. “Open primaries have led to increased turnout in the cities and states that have passed it.”

Siegert said ranked-choice voting had been implemented with great success in Maine, where voters approved the change in 2016. But Maine’s experience with ranked-choice voting was portrayed very differently Thursday during the Juneau Chamber of Commerce Luncheon.

[Initiative would bring ranked-choice voting, other changes to Alaska]

“In Maine, it’s been a horror story,” said Brett Huber, campaign manager for Defend Alaska Elections, the group opposing Measure 2.

According to PBS, ranked voting in Maine has become a partisan issue with the state Republican Party leading the effort to repeal the measure. Republicans have twice failed to have ranked voting declared unconstitutional by a federal judge, PBS said, and are currently promoting a referendum to repeal ranked-choice voting there.

Forms of ranked-choice voting have been used in Australia and the Republic of Ireland among other countries, according to the New York Times.

Opposition to ranked-choice voting and other election reforms has been bipartisan, with Democrats and Republicans falling on both sides of the issue. During his presentation, Huber, who previously worked for Gov. Mike Dunleavy, cited a quote from California Gov. Gavin Newsom criticizing ranked-choice voting.

“All parties are against ranked-choice voting,” Huber told the Chamber, but Siegert pointed out the Alaska Democratic Party had used ranked-choice voting for its own primary elections this summer.

Speaking to the Chamber, Huber called the changes in Measure 2 “laborious and hard to understand” and “a failed experiment that has failed in other places.”

But Siegert and Robert Dillon, senior communications manager for ABE, argued complications were being overstated by the opposition, and the process was easy to understand.

With ranked-choice voting, voters select their top four candidates. If none of those candidates receives an outright majority, the candidate with the fewest first-choice votes is eliminated. Those who voted for the eliminated candidate will have their votes go to the candidate they marked as their second choice. The process repeats until a candidate has a majority. Ranked-choice voting would only be used in general elections.

“It’s as easy as counting to four,” Siegert said. “Most people I talk to, they can count to four.”

Ranked-choice voting is just one of the legs of Measure 2, another is open primaries, which puts all primary candidates on the same ballot, rather than the separate partisan ballots currently in place. Open primaries give voters more options, Dillon said, which was a good fit for Alaskan politics which often don’t fall along strict party lines.

“The problem with turnout is people think their vote doesn’t matter, or they don’t think they can make a difference,” he said. “By opening primaries, we ensure they can vote on all candidates, even if their first choice isn’t chosen.”

[At 101, Alaskan aviatrix reflects on ‘best and happiest’ days of her career]

But Huber countered that open primaries can squeeze out minority parties in areas dominated by a single political party. Open primaries, which Huber called “jungle primaries” had created several congressional districts where voters for a minority party had little hope of seeing their candidates in the general election.

“There are 17 congressional districts that are being decided between Democrat 1 or Democrat 2. Or Republican 1 or Republican 2,” he said.

The third leg of Measure 2 concerns campaign disclosures for so-called “dark money.” According to the ABE website, dark money is when a donor uses a third-party, typically a political action committee, to try to shield the source of the money. Requiring campaign disclosures would let voters know what kind of groups were supporting political campaigns in Alaska.

But the Measure 2 campaign is itself running a dark money campaign, Huber told the Chamber, saying ABE was doing the very thing it claimed to be opposing.

ABE is largely funded by out-of-state groups working to promote ranked-choice voting and other voting reforms nationally, but Siegert said the campaign is upfront about that fact and provided its campaign disclosures on its website.

Both Huber and ABE said their respective efforts were meant to curtail the influence of wealthy out-of-state interests. But after Huber elaborated on the billionaire philanthropists promoting ranked-choice voting nationally and funding ABE, a member of the audience asked about out-of-state spending more generally, specifically on Ballot Measure 1, an oil-tax initiative that will also appear on November ballots in Alaska.

The largest opposition group to that measure, OneALASKA, is largely being funded by out-of-state and international oil companies such as BP and ExxonMobil.

”There is no pure money,” Huber said in response to the question. “You just have to decide where you want to be economically.”

More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast for the week of April 15

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Wednesday, April 17, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Newly elected tribal leaders are sworn in during the Central Council of the Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska’s 89th annual Tribal Assembly on Thursday at Elizabeth Peratrovich Hall. (Photo courtesy of the Central Council of the Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska)
New council leaders, citizen of year, emerging leader elected at 89th Tribal Assembly

Tlingit and Haida President Chalyee Éesh Richard Peterson elected unopposed to sixth two-year term.

A waterfront view of Marine Parking Garage with the windows of the Juneau Public Library visible on the top floor. “Welcome” signs in several languages greet ships on the dock pilings below. (Laurie Craig / For the Juneau Empire)
The story of the Marine Parking Garage: Saved by the library

After surviving lawsuit by Gold Rush-era persona, building is a modern landmark of art and function.

A troller plies the waters of Sitka Sound in 2023. (Photo by Max Graham)
Alaska Senate proposes $7.5 million aid package for struggling fish processors

The Alaska Senate has proposed a new aid package for the state’s… Continue reading

Current facilities operated by the private nonprofit Gastineau Human Services Corp. include a halfway house for just-released prisoners, a residential substance abuse treatment program and a 20-bed transitional living facility. (Gastineau Human Services Corp. photo)
Proposed 51-unit low-income, long-term housing project for people in recovery gets big boost from Assembly

Members vote 6-2 to declare intent to provide $2M in budget to help secure $9.5M more for project.

Members of the Alaska House of Representatives watch as votes are tallied on House Bill 50, the carbon storage legislation, on Wednesday. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
Alaska House, seeking to boost oil and gas business, approves carbon storage bill

Story votes yes, Hannan votes no as governor-backed HB 50 sent to the state Senate for further work.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Tuesday, April 16, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Most Read