Analysis: Election results present mixed messages

An Auke Bay poll worker helps a voter determine which ballot she wants to use during Tuesday's Aug. 16, 2016 primary election.

An Auke Bay poll worker helps a voter determine which ballot she wants to use during Tuesday's Aug. 16, 2016 primary election.

On Tuesday night, Alaska political reporter Casey Reynolds gathered a handful of the state’s political experts for a live blog on the results of the statewide primary.

As the results began to come in, former U.S. Senator Mark Begich asked a rhetorical question: “The outcome of tonight’s election will tell us where we are going as state. So the question is, what direction will we go?”

The answer to that question may not come until November.

Tuesday’s vote offered voters a referendum on the Alaska Legislature’s failure to balance the state’s multibillion-dollar budget.

While the purpose of a primary election is to pick candidates for a general election, the winners of 16 primary races will face no opposition in November — the other party hasn’t bothered to field a candidate.

Many of the others face only independent opposition or are in districts that tilt toward one party or another, making them largely uncompetitive in a general election.

“Forty percent of the elections this year will be determined by the primary race,” said Rep. Sam Kito III, D-Juneau, who faces no opposition in either the primary or general elections.

For that reason, Kito and his Juneau co-worker, Rep. Cathy Muñoz, R-Juneau, said they planned to keep a close eye on a handful of House and Senate races.

On the North Slope, initial indications were that Democratic challenger Dean Westlake was leading incumbent Democratic Rep. Benny Nageak.

Nageak is a member of the Republican-led House Majority and has consistently opposed higher taxes and lower subsidies on oil companies.

Precincts on the North Slope are small and isolated, with results not typically published until the following day.

In Southwest Alaska, incumbent Democratic Rep. Bob Herron faced a big challenge challenger Zach Fansler for a seat representing Bethel. As on the North Slope, Herron was a member of the Republican-led House Majority, and as on the North Slope, results were not expected until later Wednesday.

Muñoz and Kito said they’re also watching a handful of Republican races in Southcentral. Those races concern members of the “Musk Ox Caucus,” a group of moderate Republicans who have been willing to defect from the House Majority on some budget issues.

Most members of that caucus are facing stiff primary election challenges. If they stay in office and Democrats win seats in November, there could be a joint Republican-Democratic majority in the House.

With nine of 11 precincts reporting results by 10 p.m., Rep. Jim Colver of Palmer (a member of the caucus) was losing 45-55 to George Rauscher, a more traditional Republican.

Conversely, incumbent Rep. Paul Season (another Musk Ox) was leading his three-way race in Homer, 55-22-23, with four of nine districts reporting results.

Any attempt to create a theme from Tuesday’s election will run into a significant problem: turnout.

In 2000, just 17.2 percent of Alaska’s registered voters participated in the state primary. In 1982, the high-water mark, that figure was 57.6 percent. Initial indications are that this year’s turnout will approach the 2000 figure as the lowest ever.

With fewer than 1 in 5 Alaska voters participating Tuesday, it will be difficult for anyone to say they have a referendum based on the results.

Read more election news:

Tuesday’s election results promise at least seven new faces in Legislature

Polls bare: Few turn out for primary in Juneau

Statewide races: Full 2016 primary election results

More in News

A cat says hello at Juneau Animal Rescue in February 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire file photo)
New animal shelter site approved by Juneau Assembly

Juneau Animal Rescue secures eight-acre lease, but fundraising remains.

The trans-Alaska pipeline, seen on Oct. 8, 2008, threads over snow-covered terrain in the Brook Range foothills. A gryfalcon is perched on one of the pipeline’s thermosphyons in the lower center of the photo. (Photo by Craig McCaa/U.S. Bureau of Land Management)
Alaska revenue forecast predicts more oil, but its importance to the state budget is declining

The Permanent Fund, not oil, is Alaska’s No. 1 source of general-purpose money and has been for years

A mound of a snow obscures a “student drop off” sign near Sít’ Eetí Shaanàx-Glacier Valley School. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire file photo)
Juneau schools closed, city facilities delayed Monday due to weather

NWS released a weather warning in effect through the evening.

The emergency cold-weather warming shelter is seen in Thane on Thursday, April 10, 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire file photo)
Man charged for alleged rape at warming shelter

Staff have increased the frequency of safety rounds, and are discussing potential policy changes.

Photo by James Brooks/Alaska Beacon 
Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy speaks during a news conference in Juneau on Thursday, April 27, 2023. To his side is a screen displaying significant budget deficits and exhausted savings accounts if oil prices perform as expected.
Disasters, dividends and deficit: Alaska governor unveils first-draft state budget

In his final year, Gov. Dunleavy again proposes to spend from savings in order to pay a larger Permanent Fund dividend

Eaglecrest Ski Area photo 
Eaglecrest Ski Area as seen in a photo posted to the hill’s Facebook page on Tuesday, Dec. 11, 2025.
Eaglecrest boots up for a limited opening this weekend

15 degree highs usher in the hill’s 50th season.

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, speaks Wednesday, April 23, 2025, on the floor of the Alaska Senate. (Photo by James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
State senators express skepticism about proposed Juneau ferry terminal backed by Dunleavy

In a Friday hearing, members of the Alaska Senate spoke critically about… Continue reading

SouthEast Alaska Regional Health Consortium is one of the primary health care providers in Juneau, accepting most major public and private insurance plans. (Mari Kanagy / Juneau Empire)
Marketplace health premiums set to rise in 2026

Here’s what you need to know about how coverage is changing, and for whom.

Most Read