Tax reform? Give me a break

  • By JERRY SMETZER
  • Wednesday, November 15, 2017 7:06am
  • Opinion

This is a late response to Anselm Staack’s My Turn on the Empire’s editorial page of Sept. 27. Anselm’s comments made my day. His comments in September were partly about the GOP’s campaign to “Repeal Obamacare.” With the total failure by the Republican Congress and Trump White House to “Repeal Obamacare,” we can now move on to Anselm’s next issue, the Trump/GOP version of this month’s latest hot ticket meme: tax reform. To me, there is nothing like a full-throated rant against the Koch-financed, hate-filled propaganda campaigns at the root of the Trump/GOP versions of “Repeal Obamacare,” and “tax reform.”

If eventually successful, both these programs — by forcing people to pay the private insurance industry for increasingly expensive, increasingly needed healthcare for themselves and their families, and by slowly removing tax breaks, over time, from individuals, families and small businesses — the Trump/GOP will take increasing amounts of money out of the pockets of the unemployed, the homeless, the underemployed, the low-income people, the middle-income people, and even the relatively high-income people.

In the Trump/GOP propaganda that supports the “tax reform” meme we hear a lot about how wealth will “trickle-down” from the wealthy to the poor. That is a bogus argument. The evidence of wealth flows over history since the beginning of the industrial age, says otherwise. Over time, in the absence of one or more of the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse, wealth will “trickle up,” from the poorest to the richest. Under the Trump/GOP coalition, that historic trend will rapidly escalate upward.

With all that extra tax revenue diverted out of our pockets into the public treasury in the name of “tax reform,” the Trump/GOP coalition can further stuff the personal pockets, and the mostly off-shore bank accounts, of the already unimaginably wealthy. The accounts of the unimaginably wealthy are already overstuffed with excess, underutilized cash. The two Koch brothers, for example, were reported, recently, to have a net worth of $96.6 billion. Their continuing, very public financial support for those who want to take American democracy away from the “We the People…”, specified in the Preamble to the U.S. Constitution, probably amounts to less than the rounding error on the value of Koch wealth.

Give me a break.

For more on the subject of too much money being held in fiscal limbo, by way too few people, read Jane Mayer’s 2016 book, “Dark Money.”

For those in my own community who want to restore the senior tax exemption to the glory days when every purchase was tax-exempt. Forget it. I’m a senior, and I’d rather pay my sales tax money to the CBJ for local public schools, higher education, police and fire protection, and well-maintained utilities, transportation and healthcare systems than see my money end up in the hands of some international corporation that hides their profits overseas and spends all their time – and all the time of their high-paid lobbyists — whining to the Trump/GOP coalition about how they don’t want to pay their taxes.

I look forward to Anselm’s next commentary.


• Jerry Smetzer resides in Juneau. My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire.


More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

Photo by Nathaniel Herz/Northern Journal
Text messages between Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy and President Donald Trump.
Commentary: Alaska’s governor said he texts Trump. I asked for copies.

A couple of months ago, I was reporting on the typhoon that… Continue reading

Faith Myers stands at the doors of the Alaska Psychiatric Institute in Anchorage. (Photo courtesy Faith Myers, file)
Alaska’s system of protecting Trust beneficiaries is 40 years behind best practice

The lower 48 has a 3-century headstart on protecting people in locked psychiatric facilities.

veggies
File Photo 
Community organizations that serve food at their gatherings can do a lot by making menus of whole, nutritious offerings according to health and wellness coach Burl Sheldon.
Food served by “groups for good” can be health changemakers

Health and wellness coach thinks change can start on community event menus

Construction equipment operating at night at the White House. (photo by Peter W. Stevenson/The Washington Post)
Opinion: Gold at the center of power

What the White House’s golden ballroom reveals about Modern America

Win Gruening (courtesy)
Opinion: Affordability message delivered to Juneau Assembly; but will it matter?

On October 7, frustrated voters passed two ballot propositions aimed at making… Continue reading

Alaska Children’s Trust Photo
Natalie Hodges and Hailey Clark use the online safety conversation cards produced by the Alaska Children’s Trust.
My Turn: Staying connected starts with showing up

When our daughter was 11 and the COVID lockdown was in full… Continue reading

Telephone Hill as seen from above (Photo courtesy of City and Borough of Juneau)
Letter: For Telephone Hill, remember small is adaptable

Writer finds the finances don’t add up on planned development

Doug Mills/The New York Times 
President Donald Trump disembarks the USS Harry S. Truman before delivering remarks for the Navy’s 250th anniversary in Norfolk, Va., Oct. 5, 2025.
Opinion: Trump’s job is done

The ultra-rich have completed their takeover of America.

Google Maps screenshot
The star shows the approximate location of the proposed Cascade Point Ferry terminal by the Alaska Department of Transportation & Public Facilities in partnership with Goldbelt, Inc.
Opinion: An open letter to Cascade Point ferry terminal proponents

To: Governor Dunleavy, DOT Directors, and Cascade Point ferry terminal project consultants,… Continue reading

My Turn: Supreme Court decision treats Alaskans with mental illness worse than criminals

A criminal in Alaska who’s in custody must be presented with charges… Continue reading

Win Gruening (courtesy)
Gratitude for our libraries, museums and historians

The thanksgiving weekend is a chance to recognize those who preserve local history