My Turn: Makers and takers

  • By JERRY SMETZER
  • Monday, June 27, 2016 1:00am
  • Opinion

“Trickle-down” theories of wealth have always struck me as bogus. Now I have no doubt. I have a reading list (below), and my thinking is in these paragraphs. Many years ago I began to wonder why Wall Street was hiring so many graduates with advanced degrees in math, mostly calculus. Calculus is used to find points of inflection in processes changing over time especially when those processes intersect. I asked myself, then, aren’t adding machines powerful enough to total stock trades?

My retirement funds are in the stock market, and I watch trends. Several months ago I began to wonder why Wall Street’s Dow Jones Industrial Average ­— and other indexes — were going up so fast. After all, real wealth comes from businesses developing and selling products competitive with similar domestic products and likely imports. They sell to businesses looking for competitive advantage and to consumers with long-term jobs that pay well enough to enable the purchase of such products. However, many U.S. businesses are no longer really trying to make any products to sell; salaried positions are giving way to short-term “contractors,” and wages for working people are still stagnant following the massive housing-industry crash in 2008.

So why was the Dow Jones Industrial Average rising? My nerdy itch caused me to start reading. In recent months, the gyrations in the Dow Jones and other indexes in the Stock Market are making me think that a financial derailment worse than 2008 is possible. My itch to learn more about finance got more intense, and I resolved only to read the stuff worth reading. Readings, in other words, of analytics and interpretations that are derived based on lots of real-world data.

Here are three books that have helped me gain some footing in answering the question of “what…” (in the words of that great Republican, Donald Trump) “… the hell is going on?” Book 1.) “Capital in the Twenty-First Century,” by Thomas Piketty (Published 2014. Dense with historic data and data-based analytics on global Capital Flows. I can’t say I have read this whole book, but the summary chapters and the data presentations are excellent, and the message is unmistakable); Book 2) “The Big Short,” by Michael Lewis (Published 2011. A great study of the Stock Market “players” in full lemming mode in the run-up to the 2008 collapse; plus, it is fun to actually understand how a Credit Default Swap (CDS), and a Collateralized Debt Obligation (CDO) actually work. I read this one twice. The movie was good too); Book 3.) “Makers and Takers — The Rise of Finance and the Fall of American Business,” by Rana Foroohar (Published: 2016. This author was recommended to me by a serious business guy who owns a manufacturing company in Connecticut that actually makes things. This is a 350-page read on a not very fun subject, but if you want to know why corporate America is now putting all its’ idle cash (estimated here at 4.5 trillion (with a “T”) dollars) into stock market, bond, and currency manipulations (This is where Wall Street needs the advanced calculus) designed to assure maximum quarterly performance reports; and why they no longer want to invest in longer term R&D and innovation, in product development, in long-term good paying jobs; and in the kinds of things that produce real wealth, this is the book to start with.)

Apple Computer gets some attention in Foroohar’s book. An iconic Corporate “Maker” under Steve Jobs Apple is now becoming a corporate “taker” under Job’s successor, Tim Cook. Cook has decided that rather than try for the “next big thing,” he would rather do market manipulations with Apple’s abundant cash reserves, now estimated at $160 billion.

For those of you who might be involved with our Republican-controlled Alaska Legislature, there is plenty of explanation in Foroohar’s book about how big oil (BP and the Koch bros are highlighted) has become mostly a taker, and no longer a maker. Their takings and stock market manipulations are one major reason behind the global oil-price collapse that has put Alaska’s governing process into a tail spin; a tail spin that could turn into what airplane pilots would call a graveyard spiral. If you think big oil is going to do any serious oil-field development in the future (the kind of Alaska-based, in-state field development the annual payment of $800 million oil tax credits authorized under SB 21 are supposed to guarantee), better read Foroohar’s book before casting your next vote.

• Jerry Smetzer is a long-time resident of Juneau.

More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

Northern sea ice, such as this surrounding the community of Kivalina, has declined dramatically in area and thickness over the last few decades. Photo courtesy Ned Rozell
20 years of Arctic report cards

Twenty years have passed since scientists released the first version of the… Continue reading

Dr. Karissa Niehoff
OPINION: Protecting the purpose

Why funding schools must include student activities.

A sign reading, "Help Save These Historic Homes" is posted in front of a residence on Telephone Hill on Friday Nov. 21, 2025. (Mari Kanagy / Juneau Empire)
OPINION: The Telephone Hill cost is staggering

The Assembly approved $5.5 million to raze Telephone Hill as part of… Continue reading

Win Gruening (courtesy)
OPINION: Eaglecrest’s opportunity to achieve financial independence, if the city allows it

It’s a well-known saying that “timing is everything.” Certainly, this applies to… Continue reading

Gov. Mike Dunleavy gestures during his State of the State address on Jan. 22, 2026. (Photo by Corinne Smith/Alaska Beacon)
OPINION: It’s time to end Alaska’s fiscal experiment

For decades, Alaska has operated under a fiscal and budgeting system unlike… Continue reading

Atticus Hempel stands in a row of his shared garden. (photo by Ari Romberg)
My Turn: What’s your burger worth?

Atticus Hempel reflects on gardening, fishing, hunting, and foraging for food for in Gustavus.

At the Elvey Building, home of UAF’s Geophysical Institute, Carl Benson, far right, and Val Scullion of the GI business office attend a 2014 retirement party with Glenn Shaw. Photo by Ned Rozell
Alaska Science Forum: Carl Benson embodied the far North

Carl Benson’s last winter on Earth featured 32 consecutive days during which… Continue reading

Van Abbott is a long-time resident of Alaska and California. He has held financial management positions in government and private organizations, and is now a full-time opinion writer. He served in the late nineteen-sixties in the Peace Corps as a teacher. (Contributed)
When lying becomes the only qualification

How truth lost its place in the Trump administration.

Jamie Kelter Davis/The New York Times
Masked federal agents arrive to help immigration agents detain immigrants and control protesters in Chicago, June 4, 2025. With the passage of President Trump’s domestic policy law, the Department of Homeland Security is poised to hire thousands of new Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents, and double detention space.
OPINION: $85 billion and no answers

How ICE’s expansion threatens law, liberty, and accountability.

Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon
The entrance to the Alaska Gasline Development Corp.’s Anchorage office is seen on Aug. 11, 2023. The state-owned AGDC is pushing for a massive project that would ship natural gas south from the North Slope, liquefy it and send it on tankers from Cook Inlet to Asian markets. The AGDC proposal is among many that have been raised since the 1970s to try commercialize the North Slope’s stranded natural gas.
My Turn: Alaskans must proceed with caution on gasline legislation

Alaskans have watched a parade of natural gas pipeline proposals come and… Continue reading

Win Gruening (courtesy)
OPINION: Juneau Assembly members shift priorities in wish list to Legislature

OPINION: Juneau Assembly members shift priorities in wish list to Legislature