State attorneys Elizabeth Bakalar, foreground left, and Margaret Paton-Walsh, foreground right, listen to arguments made by attorney Jon Choate on Thursday, Sept. 21, 2017 in Alaska Superior Court in Juneau. At background left is Judge Philip Pallenberg. (James Brooks | Juneau Empire file)

State attorneys Elizabeth Bakalar, foreground left, and Margaret Paton-Walsh, foreground right, listen to arguments made by attorney Jon Choate on Thursday, Sept. 21, 2017 in Alaska Superior Court in Juneau. At background left is Judge Philip Pallenberg. (James Brooks | Juneau Empire file)

State appeals Democrats’ win in ballot lawsuit

The State of Alaska is appealing a decision that would allow independent political candidates to run in the primary election of the Alaska Democratic Party.

On Friday, the state said Juneau Superior Court Judge Philip Pallenberg made a mistake by concluding the state’s actions were a violation of the First Amendment, and that he made a second mistake by not considering how a winning independent’s name would appear on the general election ballot.

“We don’t agree with the superior court that the party membership requirement in state statute places an unconstitutional burden on political parties,” Attorney General Lindemuth said in a prepared statement. “This case presents significant constitutional questions that should be decided by the Alaska Supreme Court.”

The appeal pushes the case into the arms of the Alaska Supreme Court, and the state is asking for the court to take the case on an expedited basis.

That matters because the deadline for a candidate to file for next year’s party primary is June 1. If the Supreme Court affirms Pallenberg’s verdict after that date, the ruling wouldn’t be effective until the 2020 election.

An independent who runs in (and wins) the Democratic primary for office could have an advantage in the general election. By winning the Democratic primary, the independent would knock out any Democratic challenger, leaving the independent to face only the Republican and third-party candidates in the general election.

A positive verdict for the plaintiff would also have significant impact on the state’s election system. Many of the laws governing that system assume that a party election winner belongs to a particular party. Title 15 of Alaska law (dealing with elections) is rife with references to rights and privileges granted to recognized political parties. In Superior Court, assistant attorney general Margaret Paton-Walsh said a ruling in favor of the Democratic Party would be like a collapsing Jenga tower.

Jon Choate is representing the Alaska Democratic Party in the case. By text message, he said. “The decision to appeal is the state’s prerogative. I believe the law and facts favor the Alaska Democratic Party’s position. Political parties in Alaska have the right to allow independent candidates to compete for their nomination, just as they have the right to allow independent voters to help choose their nominees.”

The Alaska Democratic Party filed its lawsuit in February, oral arguments were held Sept. 21, and the decision was issued Oct. 17. The February filing followed a similar attempt by the Alaska Democratic Party in 2016. In that earlier lawsuit, the judge ruled that the party needed to change its own rules before asking the state to change its rules. The party duly changed its internal rules, and the February lawsuit filed.

According to an analysis conducted last year by the Alaska Judicial Council, Pallenberg’s decisions are rarely overturned on appeal. He has a 99 percent affirmation rate on criminal cases and a 77 percent affirmation rate for civil cases. (ADP v. State is a civil case.)

• Contact reporter James Brooks at or call 523-2258.

More in News

The Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Encore docks in Juneau in October, 2022. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
Ships in Port for t​​he Week of Sept. 17

Here’s what to expect this week.

A rainbow appears over downtown as residents check out rows of electric vehicles at Juneau’s EV E-bike Roundup Saturday afternoon. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)
Capital city celebrates 10th annual Juneau EV and E-bike Roundup

Juneau’s electric vehicle growth among fastest in the country, organizers say.

U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan, R-Alaska, gives a live speech via video from Washington, D.C., to attendees at the annual Southeast Conference meeting in Sitka on Thursday. (Screenshot from video by Southeast Conference)
Murkowski, Sullivan warn of domestic, foreign threats to Southeast Alaska’s economy

Issues from Russian seafood imports to ferry funding cited by senators during Southeast Conference.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Thursday, Sept. 21, 2023

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

This is a photo of Juneau International Airport. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
Email threat to Alaska airports doesn’t appear credible, police say

Heightened presence of officers at Juneau airport planned Friday.

A 2023 municipal election ballot is placed in the drop box at Douglas Library/Fire Hall Community Building. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
Number of residents registered to vote ‘nearly identical’ to last year

More than 1,100 ballots counted so far during this municipal election.

Samantha Crain, of the Choctaw Nation, sings to the crowd during a performance Thursday night as part of the Áak’w Rock music festival at Centennial Hall. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)
‘It’s pure resiliency’: Áak’w Rock kicks off

The three-day Indigenous music festival attracts full crowds during its first night.

U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan, R-Alaska, walks down a hallway Tuesday, Feb. 7, 2023, at the Alaska State Capitol. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
With Alaska’s federal judge vacancy nearing 2-year mark, Sullivan breaks from nomination tradition

Murkowski appears skeptical about the switch, saying she’s prepared to advance nominees to Biden

Jordan Creek flows over a portion of a footbridge behind a shopping center Thursday evening. The National Weather Service has issued a flood warning for Jordan Creek, Montana Creek and Auke Lake until 10 a.m. Friday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Flood warning for Jordan Creek, Montana Creek and Auke Lake issued until 10 a.m. Friday

Glacier Highway, structures near Jordan Creek may inundated, according to National Weather Service.

Most Read