Prosecuting Attorney John Darnall, from the Office of Special Prosecutions, gives his closing argument in Juneau Superior Court on Monday, Oct. 7, 2019, during the trial of Laron Carlton Graham. Graham is facing two counts of first-degree murder for the November 2015 shooting deaths of 36-year-old Robert H. Meireis and 34-year-old Elizabeth K. Tonsmeire. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire)

Prosecuting Attorney John Darnall, from the Office of Special Prosecutions, gives his closing argument in Juneau Superior Court on Monday, Oct. 7, 2019, during the trial of Laron Carlton Graham. Graham is facing two counts of first-degree murder for the November 2015 shooting deaths of 36-year-old Robert H. Meireis and 34-year-old Elizabeth K. Tonsmeire. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire)

Prosecution sticks to evidence as defense attacks witnesses in closing arguments

The trial for a 2015 double murder is now in the hands of the jury

The defense and prosecution presented their closing arguments Monday, wrapping up weeks of witness testimony in the trial for a 2015 double murder.

The trial of Laron Carlton Graham, 42 — charged with two counts of first-degree murder for the deaths of Elizabeth Tonsmeire, 34, and Robby Meireis, 36 — has moved on to its next stage. The jury broke to deliberate around 2 p.m. Fourteen jurors heard the case, and two were let go Monday, leaving 12 to decide verdict.

“The defendant admitted to James LeBlanc-Tweedy that he shot Robby Meireis and shot Elizabeth Tonsmeire,” prosecuting attorney John Darnall said during closing arguments. “Dead men don’t tell tales. That’s what the defendant told Phillip Drummer, when he inquired about the details of the murders of Robby Meireis and Elizabeth Tonsmeire.”

Prosecution sticks to evidence as defense attacks witnesses in closing arguments

Darnall went on to lay out the timeline of events, from when Graham was hanging out doing drugs at Tonsmeire’s apartment Friday night, to the last time Meireis was seen alive on Saturday, to when Meireis’ phone user activity abruptly stopped, to John “Kelly” Tonsmeire’s frantic 911 call on Sunday. Darnall illustrated the means, motive and opportunity.

“Dislike is a motive. Robbery is a motive,” Darnall said. “Maybe it’s just because Robby Meireis was a racist, skinhead bigot.”

Laron Carlton Graham sits in Juneau Superior Court on Monday, Oct. 7, 2019, before closing arguments in his trial. Graham is facing two counts of first-degree murder for the November 2015 shooting deaths of 36-year-old Robert H. Meireis and 34-year-old Elizabeth K. Tonsmeire. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire)

Laron Carlton Graham sits in Juneau Superior Court on Monday, Oct. 7, 2019, before closing arguments in his trial. Graham is facing two counts of first-degree murder for the November 2015 shooting deaths of 36-year-old Robert H. Meireis and 34-year-old Elizabeth K. Tonsmeire. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire)

Darnall also pointed out that Graham had taken pictures posted to Facebook holding a weapon that could be a 10mm Glock, one of the types of murder weapons crime lab technicians thought was likely to be used in the killing, and that Graham would have been alone with Tonsmeire and Meireis Saturday afternoon.

Graham would have wanted a refund for bad drugs sold to him by Meireis, Darnall alleged. In an alleged confession note written to neighboring inmate LeBlanc-Tweedy, Graham allegedly said that upon asking Meireis to refund his purchase, Meireis told him to get out and called him the n-word. Graham shot him in the face, LeBlanc-Tweedy alleges the confession said.

“For a man of color, raised in the south, to hear that racial epithet, caused the defendant to snap and shoot Robby Meireis,” Darnall said.

[Defense calls final witnesses before resting, suggests another suspect in killing]

Darnall then outlined some of the details that LeBlanc-Tweedy gleaned from Graham’s alleged confession, including the amount of money Graham allegedly stole from Meireis and the type and quantities of drugs Meireis had.

Defense attorney Natasha Norris passionately countered against Darnall’s straight-line progression of evidence, attacking witnesses and calling into doubt their credibility, particularly LeBlanc-Tweedy.

“There is no forensic evidence linking Mr. Graham to the crime. No DNA, no fingerprints, no footprints,” Norris said. “The state wants you to believe their botched facts when they want you to, and not when it’s inconvenient for them.”

LeBlanc-Tweedy, charged with sexual abuse of minor in 2014, was incarcerated in Lemon Creek Correctional Center in 2016, at the same time as Graham. Housed next to each other, LeBlanc-Tweedy and Graham frequently exchanged notes, as Graham was reportedly paranoid that verbal conversations were being recorded.

“Mr. LeBlanc-Tweedy claims that on Feb. 23, 2016, Mr. Graham passed over a note confessing to the two murders,” Norris said.

Defense Attorney Natasha Norris gives her closing argument in Juneau Superior Court on Monday, Oct. 7, 2019, during the trial of Laron Carlton Graham. Graham is facing two counts of first-degree murder for the November 2015 shooting deaths of 36-year-old Robert H. Meireis and 34-year-old Elizabeth K. Tonsmeire. Juneau Superior Court Judge Philip Pallenberg, right, and Graham, left, listen. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire)

Defense Attorney Natasha Norris gives her closing argument in Juneau Superior Court on Monday, Oct. 7, 2019, during the trial of Laron Carlton Graham. Graham is facing two counts of first-degree murder for the November 2015 shooting deaths of 36-year-old Robert H. Meireis and 34-year-old Elizabeth K. Tonsmeire. Juneau Superior Court Judge Philip Pallenberg, right, and Graham, left, listen. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire)

Norris went on the point out that LeBlanc-Tweedy did not immediately reproduce the note (the original was allegedly thrown away in a toilet) to show authorities, as he had initially claimed, but the next day. She also pointed out a number of inconsistencies with the note and factual details that LeBlanc-Tweedy had gotten incorrect.

“He assumed they were dating. They were not dating,” Norris said. “He assumed that Mr. Graham was angry about fake China White (a nickname for a brand of heroin). Mr. Graham used meth.”

Norris also turned her guns on the Juneau Police Department, attacking their methodology in investigating the case, and questioning their evidence. Norris claimed the JPD failed to return to talk to neighbors to gather more data, failed to inspect the dumpster at the Admiralty apartments, failed to call for assistance from the Alaska State Troopers or Alaska Bureau of Investigation, and failed to develop other suspects, including Jose Delgado, who she termed suspicious in his repeated visits to the crime scene.

“Delgado got out of the car taking pictures until Officer Phelps told him to go away, that it was a crime scene. That is bizarre behavior,” Norris said. “Then they find out that he threatened Mr. (Zachary) Stubblefield with a gun to the face and made what Stubblefield thought was an admission (to the murders).”

“The only fair and just verdicts in the case is not guilty and not guilty,” Norris said.

Darnall rebutted her argument, saying that while LeBlanc-Tweedy’s recollection might not have been word perfect, it was fundamentally sound. Darnall also said the timeline of Meireis’ death, placing it at roughly 1:10 p.m. in the afternoon, was logical.

“Robby Meireis’ phone went dark at 1:10 p.m.,” Darnall said. “He wasn’t asleep. He was taking the big nap. He was dead.”

More in News

The Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Encore docks in Juneau in October of 2022. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire file photo)
Ships in port for t​​he Week of April 22

Here’s what to expect this week.

The Hubbard, the newest vessel in the Alaska Marine Highway System fleet, docks at the Auke Bay Ferry Terminal on April 18. It is generally scheduled to provide dayboat service between Juneau, Haines and Skagway. (Photo by Laurie Craig)
Ongoing Alaska Marine Highway woes are such that marketing to Lower 48 tourists is being scaled back

“We just disappoint people right now,” AMHS’ marine director says during online public forum Monday.

Sen. Cathy Giessel, R-Anchorage, speaks during a news conference on Wednesday, March 1, 2023. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
Alaska Senate considers plan that would allow teens to independently seek mental health care

Amendment by Sen. Cathy Giessel, R-Anchorage, would lower the age for behavioral health care to 16

Rep. George Rauscher, R-Sutton, speaks during a news conference on Tuesday, March 28, at the Alaska State Capitol. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
House approves tougher route for environmental protections on Alaska rivers, lakes

HB95 would require lawmakers approve any “Tier III” labeling, the highest level of federal protection.

Rep. Andi Story (left, wearing gray), Rep. Sara Hannan (center, wearing purple) and Sen. Jesse Kiehl (wearing suit) talk with constituents following a legislative town hall on Thursday at Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
All three members of Juneau’s legislative delegation seeking reelection

Reps. Andi Story and Sara Hannan, and Sen. Jesse Kiehl unopposed ahead of June 1 filing deadline

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Sunday, April 21, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

The “Newtok Mothers” assembled as a panel at the Arctic Encounter Symposium on April 11 discuss the progress and challenges as village residents move from the eroding and thawing old site to a new village site called Mertarvik. Photographs showing deteriorating conditions in Newtok are displayed on a screen as the women speak at the event, held at Anchorage’s Dena’ina Civic and Convention Center. (Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon)
Relocation of eroding Alaska Native village seen as a test case for other threatened communities

Newtok-to-Mertarvik transformation has been decades in the making.

Bailey Woolfstead, right, and her companion Garrett Dunbar examine the selection of ceramic and wood dishes on display at the annual Empty Bowls fundraiser on behalf of the Glory Hall at Centennial Hall on Sunday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Empty Bowls provides a full helping of fundraising for the Glory Hall

Annual soup event returns to Centennial Hall as need for homeless shelter’s services keeps growing.

Juneau Mayor Beth Weldon and her husband Greg. (Photo courtesy of the City and Borough of Juneau)
Greg Weldon, husband of Juneau Mayor Beth Weldon, killed in motorcycle accident Sunday morning

Accident occurred in Arizona while auto parts store co-owner was on road trip with friend

Most Read