A cruise ship passenger photographs the Radiance of the Seas in Juneau’s downtown harbor on Tuesday, August 29, 2017. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

A cruise ship passenger photographs the Radiance of the Seas in Juneau’s downtown harbor on Tuesday, August 29, 2017. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

Judge makes ruling on cruise ship lawsuit against city

Decision could have national implications

The lawsuit between the cruise industry and the city appears to be coming to an end, though there are still questions as to the specifics of a long-awaited ruling that came Thursday.

U.S. District Court Judge H. Russel Holland issued his decision Thursday, mostly favoring the Cruise Lines International Association’s (CLIA) Alaska affiliate in its case against the City and Borough of Juneau. The case was to determine how exactly cities can spend the money they collect from marine passenger fees and port development fees, also known as head taxes, which are fees collected from each cruise ship passenger.

Holland ruled that it’s constitutional for a city to collect these fees, which CBJ City Manager Rorie Watt said was good news to them. Holland also ruled that municipalities can only spend the revenue from those fees on “endeavors that facilitate the marine operations of plaintiffs’ members’ vessels.” In other words, the money can be used to benefit the cruise ships, not the cruise passengers or the general public.

“Passenger benefits are not relevant,” Holland wrote in his 35-page decision. “The proper question as to each category of expenditure by (the CBJ) is: Does the expenditure provide a service to a vessel? If the answer is yes, the expenditure is constitutional. If the answer is no, the expenditure is unconstitutional under the Tonnage Clause.”

In essence, the Tonnage Clause of the U.S. Constitution prohibits the states from charging for a vessel’s cargo without providing a service to the boat, as CLIA’s attorney Jonathan Benner explained in oral arguments in September. Benner still hadn’t been able to fully digest everything in the decision when reached for comment Thursday, but said he was “very pleased” with Holland’s decision.

Watt said CBJ staff members have been carefully examining the wording of the decision to try and figure out what exactly constitutes a service to a vessel. In his ruling, Holland listed a few examples of what’s constitutional and what isn’t. Maintenance costs for a gangway that benefits passengers getting on and off the cruise ship is fine, he said, because it benefits the boat as well as the passengers. Salary for crossing guards and maintenance costs for sidewalks, he wrote, are not constitutional because there’s no benefit to the ship itself.

Still, Watt said, the ruling doesn’t include an ironclad definition on what it means to benefit a vessel.

“Given that the cruise ship’s whole point of existence is to move around people on vacation,” Watt said, “I think that’s the question. What is the service to a vessel when the vessel’s whole point of existence is to take people on vacation?”

The decision sets a precedent for more than just Juneau and Alaska, Benner pointed out, as this is a constitutional argument and can be applied to municipalities all around the country. Holland acknowledged in his ruling that “the case is ripe for declarations of law.”

“The general principle is that fees cannot be used as a kind of revenue stream to finance things away from the vessel itself but may have some incidental benefit to passengers,” Benner said, “or are primarily the kinds of things that, if it were Jamestown, New York or some internal city, would be paid for out of general municipal revenues.”

CBJ officials and attorney Bob Blasco (representing the city) have argued that the city has used funds to serve cruise passengers. Blasco stated during oral arguments in September that he wanted CLIA officials to be more specific about the ways they thought the CBJ had misused passenger fees.

In the original complaint in 2016, CLIA pointed to the construction of an artificial island for Juneau’s whale statue as an example of a violation, asserting that it was too far away from the cruise docks to serve the passengers. As time has gone on, the statue has become less and less of a focus in the case.

CLIA’s lawsuit isn’t seeking to make the CBJ pay, but Benner and CLIA President John Binkley have said previously that they’re just looking for a clarification in the law.

Benner said he’s not sure what the next steps will be, saying it depends on if the CBJ wants to file an appeal. From reading Holland’s decision, Benner said he believes the decision is meant to be a final ruling in the case.

“We think (Holland) has resolved the key issue,” Benner said.

• Contact reporter Alex McCarthy at 523-2271 or amccarthy@juneauempire.com. Follow him on Twitter at @akmccarthy.

President of CLIA Alaska John Binkley (left) and former Juneau Mayor Ken Koelsch talk as Juneau residents tour the Norwegian Bliss after Plaque Presentations on Tuesday, June 12, 2018. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

President of CLIA Alaska John Binkley (left) and former Juneau Mayor Ken Koelsch talk as Juneau residents tour the Norwegian Bliss after Plaque Presentations on Tuesday, June 12, 2018. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

More in News

The Aurora Borealis glows over the Mendenhall Glacier in 2014. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Aurora forecast

Forecasts from the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute for the week of Jan. 22

Library Director Dave Berry and Advisory Board Chair Kate Finn participate in Library Advisory Board meeting on Tuesday Jan. 17, 2023, at Homer City Hall, in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Emilie Springer/Homer News)
Homer Library Advisory Board upholds decision to retain LGBTQ+ books

A citizen’s group last year submitted a petition asking that the books be removed from the children’s section

Courtesy Photo / Juneau Police Department 
This photo shows Woodrow Farrell Eagleman who police say after going missing on Jan. 11 was seen leaving town on Jan. 12 via airport surveillance.
Police: Man reported missing took plane out of town

A Juneau man recently reported as missing was found leaving town on… Continue reading

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Thursday, Jan. 26

This report contains information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Juneau-based actor Xáalnook Erin Tripp was recently named one of the 2023 Artists in Business Leadership Fellows for First Peoples Fund program. Tripp said she intends to use to program’s grant funding to set up a professional recording studio in Juneau for her voice acting career and to share with other artists in the community. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
First Peoples Fund to help Juneau actor create recording studio for voice acting

Xáalnook Erin Tripp among artists with Southeast ties to earn the award.

Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire 
Katie Botz, a Juneau school bus driver honored by Gov. Mike Dunelavy for her advocacy on behalf of abuse victims, stands to applause during his recognition of her during the State of the State speech Monday night at the Alaska State Capitol.
‘A victory for all of us’: Juneau woman recognized among Resilient Alaskans for her advocacy

Katie Botz’s presence — and brief absence — as a victims advocate led to a big win and governor’s honor.

Arnold Vosloo as Colonel Bach addresses US soldiers in latest film, “Condor’s Nest” in theaters and digital release on Friday. (Courtesy Photo / PMKBNC)
‘Popcorn thriller’ set in South America features actor from Alaska

“Condor’s Nest” will be available on demand Friday.

Jim Cockrell, commissioner of the Alaska Department of Public Safety, speaks in Wasilla at a May 3, 2022, news conference. Cockrell has ordered an investigation after troopers mistakenly took a school principal into custody for a mental health exam. (Photo by Yereth Rosen / Alaska Beacon)
Troopers, misled by false court order, detained principal for mental health check

State troopers mistakenly took Alaska’s 2022 Principal of the Year into custody…

The Juneau School District’s recently announced the new principals for Juneau Community Charter School and Mendenhall River Community School who are set to start in their positions this fall. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
District selects new principals for Juneau Community Charter and Mendenhall River Community School

The new school heads will join the district in the coming academic year in the fall

Most Read