Kylie Morris argues NATO should have an increased presence in the Baltic states as a timer indicates time remaining during a drama, debate and forensics tournament Saturday at Thunder Mountain High School. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire)

Debating on home turf

TMHS hosts first home tournament in two years

Resolved: Juneau Drama, Debate and Forensics team members are happy to be hosting in-person home meets again.

Over the weekend, teams from around Southeast Alaska gathered at Thunder Mountain High School for Juneau’s first in-person drama, debate and forensics tournament in two years. The Juneau tournament was the high school season’s third live event after COVID-19 forced all competition online last year.

“It was the closest to normal we have felt in the last two years,” said James Marks, who coaches the combined teams that represent TMHS and Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé. “It was a miracle that we could do anything last year.”

Marks said that only one student on the team had participated in an in-person home meet before, so the experience of competing on home turf was new. In the age of COVID-19, the experience also raised questions, like should competitors shake hands or bump fists at the end of the match? (No clear winner emerged.)

“It went great,” he said. “The biggest highlight was the excitement I could sense from all the students throughout the tournament.”

[Award-winning chef brings new flavors to Juneau]

During each tournament, students compete across a variety of categories, including speaking, acting and debate. Events include miming, dramatic interpretation, solo acting, original oratory and extemporaneous speaking—an event where competitors draw three potential topics out of an envelope and give an off-the-cuff speech with preparation.

The debate topic changes each month, and students must prepare by researching the affirmative and negative sides of the issue. Marks said that students don’t know which side of the debate they will argue until they meet their competitor. The November debate topic asks students whether NATO nations should significantly increase their defense commitments to the Baltic states.

Community members volunteered to judge the events. Saturday’s crop of judges included a state senator, a University of Southeast Alaska professor, local teachers and administrators, City and Borough of Juneau City Assembly members and other volunteers.

Marks said that the atmosphere gets more charged as teams progress through the preliminary elimination rounds to the finals.

Learning and growing

Team members say that the research and prep required for the events make them better students, help them feel heard and provide a community of people who all enjoy public speaking.

“I see the skills that I learn from my debates and speeches and even my occasional acting event shine through in my English assignments especially, but also with how I interact with my teachers and peers every day,” Kylie Morris, a TMHS junior and a team captain.

In a Monday evening email to the Empire, she said participating in the team helps her feel like she has a voice.

“Last season, I wrote a speech on a speech impediment called articulation disorder, which has affected me growing up. This year I decided to tackle the issue of poverty which also has touched pieces of my childhood. Feeling like I have a voice, as well as being able to spread awareness of issues that have affected me personally is one of the main reasons why I love the DDF team.”

[Gaps in ferry service remain as new board takes shape]

Fellow team captain and TMHS junior Reese Bunten said the community the team offers is the best part of each season.

“I get to see the gears clicking as new debaters learn how to formulate their cases and sharpen their wit to exemplify their positions and become better speakers. It’s also a team that is filled with inside jokes and laughter that are memories I will cherish for years to come,” Bunten said.

Results

Marks said that the tournament was full of outstanding performances and several awards for Juneau’s combined team. Here’s a list of winners:

Acting events

— Solo Acting: Rachel Wood, second place

— Dramatic Interpretation: Madeline Germain, second place

— Duet Acting: Rachel and Kyra Wood, second place

— Humorous Interpretation: Rina Basaliso, fourth place

— Mime: Madeline Germain and Rina Basaliso, second place

Speech Events

— Extemporaneous Speaking: Reese Bunten ,first place

— Original Oratory: Grace Stewart, second place

Debate

— Reese Bunten and Devin Moorehead, third place

— Kylie Morris and Ethan Madsen, fifth place

• Contact reporter Dana Zigmund at dana.zigmund@juneauempire.com or 907-308-4891.

More in News

Jasmine Chavez, a crew member aboard the Quantum of the Seas cruise ship, waves to her family during a cell phone conversation after disembarking from the ship at Marine Park on May 10. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Ships in port for the week of Sept. 28

Here’s what to expect this week.

Workers install Hesco Barriers along the Los Angeles River to protect against El Niño flooding in 2016. Similar barriers along the Mendenhall River are being considered by Juneau city leaders. (U.S. Army Corps of Engineers photo)
Building blocks toward flood prevention being sought by city, community group

Four-mile levy using giant sand barriers proposed to Assembly; neighborhood group seeks own solutions.

Supporters of Mayor Beth Weldon and Juneau Assembly candidate Neil Steininger wave signs to motorists on Egan Drive at the Douglas Bridge intersection on Tuesday morning. Both are well ahead in their two-candidate races in the first batch of ballots tallied Tuesday night, with official results scheduled to be certified on Oct. 15. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Leaders in mayoral, Assembly races cautiously ponder issues ahead as more ballots tallied

Mayor Beth Weldon, Assembly hopeful Neil Steininger have solid leads; Maureen Hall a narrower edge

Juneau Municipal Clerk Beth McEwen (right) and Deputy Clerk Diane Cathcart await the arrival of election materials as early ballots are counted at the Thane Ballot Processing Center on Tuesday night. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Ship-Free Saturday losing, Weldon leads mayor’s race, school board recalls failing in early election results

Unofficial partial count shows Steininger, Hall leading Assembly races; school board incumbents also ahead.

Lemon Creek Correctional Center in Juneau is among the state prisons housing inmates whose names were included in material improperly accessible to the public on a website for months, according to officials. (Jonson Kuhn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Update: Inmate records improperly online for months contained fictitious health data, company says

Investigation rebuts illegal health data leak accusations by ACLU, which still finds fault with explanation

Dan Kenkel sets up an election sign outside City Hall as in-person voting begins at 7 a.m. Tuesday in Juneau’s municipal election. Voting locations and ballot dropoff boxes are open until 8 p.m. tonight.
Election Day arrives with Assembly, school board, municipal bond and cruise ship items on ballot

In-person voting and dropoff boxes open until 8 p.m.; initial results expected sometime after 10 p.m.

The Donlin Gold airstrip, with the camp at the far end on the right, is seen from the air on Aug. 11, 2022. The mine site is in the hilly terrain near Southwest Alaska’s winding Kuskokwim River. The mine won a key permit from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in 2018, but a federal judge ruled on Monday that the environmental study on which that permit was based was flawed because it failed to consider the impacts of a catastrophic dam failure. (Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon)
Federal judge faults environmental analysis for planned huge gold mine in Western Alaska

Regulators failed to consider impacts of a dam failure when issuing Donlin mine permit, judge rules.

(Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Three women arriving on flights arrested on drug charges in two incidents at Juneau’s airport

Drugs with a street value of more than $175,000 seized during arrests, according to JPD.

Most Read