Alaskans speak up about bill to smother smoking

The Alaska Senate is again considering a bill to prohibit smoking in bars, restaurants and public places across Alaska.

Senate Bill 1 was the first piece of legislation proposed in the Senate last year, but it was sidelined by the need to address the state’s $3.7 billion budget deficit. On Monday morning, the Senate Finance Committee heard public testimony on the bill, with 45 people from across the state giving their opinions.

Opponents of the proposed ban said it would restrict personal and business freedom. “We are against Senate Bill 1 because we believe business owners have the right to make their own choices,” said Carmen Lunde of the Kodiak Cabaret, Hotel, Restaurant, and Retailers Association (CHARR).

Ban proponents – who significantly outnumbered opponents – said a smoking ban is a matter of workplace and public safety. Employees are forced to breathe smoky air, and there is no doubt that smoking causes cancer.

“Secondhand smoke is no different than any other workplace hazard we have laws against,” said Jenny Ohlendorff of Soldotna. “Signing this bill into law will protect all Alaska workers.”

Bill Ross of Anchorage, delivering an emotional speech, said his wife died in his arms from smoking-related cancer. Since then, he’s made it his duty to oppose smoking wherever possible.

“It is our right to engage in hazardous activities and behaviors, but it does not give the right to kill other people with the same behaviors,” he said.

The bill exempts fishing boats, private homes (excepting those used as day cares or senior care facilities) and long-haul trucks.

While Juneau, Anchorage and other Alaska cities have already restricted indoor smoking, some communities, including Kodiak, have voted not to.

“If the state moves forward, the state will invalidate the actions of those communities,” said Dale Fox, president of Alaska CHARR.

The bill puts e-cigarette use under the definition of smoking, effectively banning e-cigarette use indoors. There is an exemption allowing smoking in special rooms within tobacco stores and e-cigarette shops, but that exemption does not cover marijuana smoking in retail marijuana shops.

Fifth-grader Maureen Narus said by phone that she was in Fred Meyer when she met someone using an e-cigarette and puffing out a big cloud of vapor. Her mother told her to hold her breath while she walked by.

“I think that it is important that I have the right to protect my lungs in public places,” she said.

After the public hearing, MacKinnon said the bill would be set aside for the time being. On Monday afternoon, it did not appear on the calendar this week, and committee staff said it is uncertain when the bill will appear again.

If approved by the finance committee, SB1 will head to a vote of the full Senate. If approved there, it will go to the House.

• Contact reporter James Brooks at

More in News

(Juneau Empire File)
Aurora forecast for the week of Nov. 27

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

The Alaska Marine Highway System ferry LeConte at the Auke Bay Terminal on Monday, March 5, 2018. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Petition seeks name change for LeConte state ferry

Petersburg man calling attention to what he calls Joseph LeConte’s racist history.

The deadly landslide that struck Wrangell on the night of Nov. 20 is seen the next day. Southeast Alaska is, by nature, vulnerable to such landslides, but climate change is adding to the risk by bringing more precipitation and more extreme rainfall events. (Photo provided by Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities)
Deadly Wrangell landslide is part of a pattern in vulnerable Alaska mountainous terrain

Scientists warn climate change, by increasing precipitation and extreme rainfall, adds to risks.

Jonson Kuhn / Juneau Empire File
Even the Grinch got into the holiday spirit at last year’s Gallery Walk on Friday, Dec. 2, 2022.
An abundance of traditional and new ways to capitalize on this year’s Gallery Walk

More than 50 events scheduled Friday afternoon and evening from downtown to Douglas.

This view is from Wrangell on Sept. 11, 2022. (Photo by Joaqlin Estus/ICT)
Conservation group supports formation of new Alaska Native corporations

The conservation group the Wilderness Society has changed its position and now… Continue reading

From her hospital bed on Friday, Nov. 24, Christina Florschutz demonstrates how she pulled pajama bottoms that she found in the landslide debris over her legs, arms and head to keep warm. Her house was destroyed in the landslide, and after spending the night in the wreckage, she was rescued the morning of Tuesday, Nov. 21. (Caroleine James / Wrangell Sentinel)
Elementary school aide who survived Wrangell landslide calls circumstances a miracle

Christina Florschutz trapped overnight by landslide that killed at least 4 people, with 2 missing.

Lylah Habeger (left) and Jaila Ramirez lead the Konfeta Corps during a rehearsal of Tchaikovsky’s “The Nutcracker” at Juneau Dance Theatre. The ballet will be performed in the Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.At.Kalé auditorium Friday through Sunday. (Photo courtesy of Juneau Dance Theatre)
‘Nutcracker’ tradition, with a twirl of new choreography

This year’s performances feature a cast of 93, ages 5 to 78

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Sunday, Nov. 26, 2023

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Saturday, Nov. 25, 2023

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Most Read