The End. The End?

I recently finished Marissa Meyer’s delectable YA series, “The Lunar Chronicles.” Or so I thought.

Originally planned as a quartet with one book per fairytale heroine: “Cinder,” “Scarlet,” “Cress,” and “Winter,” a prequel, “Fairest,” got added between books three and four. That was all well and good with me, it was actually interesting to read how the evil queen got evil.

But then, on closing the pages of “Winter,” I learn not only about a book of short stories, “Stars Above,” which Meyer herself views as “The End” but also spinoff graphic novel series focusing on an (admittedly awesome) side character.

Cool. Cool. I will read your short stories — because I honestly do love the series — and I’ll probably read the graphic novels too. Just one question: When is it actually going to end?

Seriously, not complaining. I was the one who went to your signing last fall and fangirled terribly. The type of fangirling where you find yourself both unable to form coherent sentences and unable to stop talking. You were incredibly kind and gracious.

But where will it end? I’m not sure if I can sustain the tension.

And it’s not just Meyer whose success has triggered an avalanche of sequels and tie-ins. For instance, there’s Kiera Cass, whose original Selection trilogy I wrote up in “What YA novels taught me about how America will be destroyed” (Still one of my favorite columns ever, Then she published four tie-in stories in a companion book, “Happily Ever After.” Then, suddenly, there was a sequel series following the children of the characters in the first series consisting of “The Heir” and what I’m told is the fifth and final book, “The Crown,” due out in May. Right, “fifth and final.” I’ll believe it when I see it.

I mean, I get it. I love what you guys do and it seems to be working for you too but don’t you ever worry about diminishing returns. I’m talking about the Tolkien Conundrum: One good book in “The Hobbit,” one astonishing series in “The Lord of the Rings.” But then he couldn’t leave Middle Earth and we were stuck with such works as “The Silmarrillion” and “The Children of Húrin.”*

We get it. Some of us never want the story to end, but if each succeeding work has a decreasing literary value, maybe it’s time to move on to fresher pastures? Or is it possible for a writer to get stuck in one imaginary world and never, ever move out?

But then there’s the opposite problem, what I will call the J.K. Rowling Experience: Nobody really likes her other work as much. Sure “A Casual Vacancy” and her three Cormoran Strike mysteries have sold millions, but they’re frequently met with disdain by a press and fans still moon-struck by Harry Potter.

Is it any wonder then that she has moved back into the world of Harry Potter with the upcoming “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” movie series — her screenwriting debut — and the highly-anticipated “Harry Potter and the Cursed Child,” a play being billed as the 8th story (a collaboration between her, John Tiffany and Jack Thorne).

I know I for one met the announcement with childish glee and went eagerly to Hearthside to pre-order my copy of the script (release date: July 31). And even as I stood there browsing, I overheard the employees debating whether a midnight release party was merited nine years after Harry Potter 7, an argument in which I weighed in decidedly for. (Come on Hearthside, I never got to go to them as a kid! I want to dress up as Harry or better yet, come in my house colors — Ravenclaw rules!)

So maybe Meyer can’t win either way, if she keeps extending the story or tries her hand at something new. Speaking of which, her new novel “Heartless” is a standalone take on a young Queen of Hearts and will come out this November.


* Admittedly, this isn’t Tolkien’s fault but the fault of his estate which decided to posthumously publish everything he’d written about Middle-earth regardless of its state or worth.

More in Neighbors

Maj. Gina Halverson is co-leader of The Salvation Army Juneau Corps. (Robert DeBerry/The Salvation Army)
Living and Growing: “Don’t cry because it’s over, smile because it happened.”

Ever have to say goodbye unexpectedly? A car accident, a drug overdose,… Continue reading

Visitors look at an art exhibit by Eric and Pam Bealer at Alaska Robotics that is on display until Sunday. (Photo courtesy of the Sitka Conservation Society)
Neighbors briefs

Art show fundraiser features works from Alaska Folk Festival The Sitka Conservation… Continue reading

U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski meets with Thunder Mountain High School senior Elizabeth Djajalie in March in Washington, D.C., when Djajalie was one of two Alaskans chosen as delegates for the Senate Youth Program. (Photo courtesy U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski’s office)
Neighbors: Juneau student among four National Honor Society Scholarship Award winners

TMHS senior Elizabeth Djajalie selected from among nearly 17,000 applicants.

The 2024 Alaska Junior Duck Stamp Contest winning painting of an American Wigeon titled “Perusing in the Pond” by Jade Hicks, a student at Thunder Mountain High School. (Photo courtesy of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)
THMS student Jade Hicks wins 2024 Alaska Junior Duck Stamp Contest

Jade Hicks, 18, a student at Thunder Mountain High School, took top… Continue reading

(Photo courtesy of The Central Council of the Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska)
Neighbors: Tunic returned to the Dakhl’aweidí clan

After more than 50 years, the Wooch dakádin kéet koodás’ (Killerwhales Facing… Continue reading

A handmade ornament from a previous U.S. Capitol Christmas Tree. (Photo courtesy of U.S. Capitol Christmas Tree)
Neighbors briefs

Ornaments sought for 2024 U.S. Capitol Christmas Tree The Alaska Region of… Continue reading

(Photo by Gina Delrosario)
Living and Growing: Divine Mercy Sunday

Part one of a two-part series

(City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Neighbors Briefs

Registration for Parks & Rec summer camps opens April 1 The City… Continue reading

Easter eggs in their celebratory stage, before figuring out what to do once people have eaten their fill. (Photo by Depositphotos via AP)
Gimme A Smile: Easter Eggs — what to do with them now?

From Little League practice to practicing being POTUS, there’s many ways to get cracking.

A fruit salad that can be adjusted to fit the foods of the season. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking for Pleasure: A Glorious Fruit Salad for a Company Dinner

Most people don’t think of a fruit salad as a dessert. This… Continue reading