Senate candidates debate fisheries issues

Republican U.S. senator Lisa Murkowski addresses a crowd during a keynote speech during the Alaska Chamber’s 2016 Fall Forum on Thursday, Oct. 13, 2016 at the Kenai Shopping Center in Kenai, Alaska. She was one of several speakers throughout the Alaska Chamber’s 2015 Fall Forum hosted in Kenai this week.

Republican U.S. senator Lisa Murkowski addresses a crowd during a keynote speech during the Alaska Chamber’s 2016 Fall Forum on Thursday, Oct. 13, 2016 at the Kenai Shopping Center in Kenai, Alaska. She was one of several speakers throughout the Alaska Chamber’s 2015 Fall Forum hosted in Kenai this week.

JUNEAU — U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski cast herself as a champion for Alaska’s fishing industry Wednesday, while independent Margaret Stock questioned the pace of progress by Alaska’s congressional delegation on several issues during a Senate debate in Kodiak.

The fisheries-focused debate, which was broadcast on public radio, also featured Democrat Ray Metcalfe and independent Breck Craig.

Libertarian candidate Joe Miller was absent, on a swing through Southeast Alaska instead, according to his campaign. Miller spokesman Randy DeSoto has said Miller plans to visit Kodiak later.

Murkowski, a Republican, defended her record, including in drawing State Department attention to concerns raised by conservationists and fishermen about the impact of Canadian mining activity on waters that flow across the border into southeast Alaska. She said headway is being made but it’s been difficult because the State Department hasn’t seen the issue as warranting urgent attention.

Stock suggested that more could be done. Some of those concerned about the mining activity have urged the involvement of an international commission. Requests for the commission’s involvement must come from the national governments.

The delegation has raised that issue. The State Department, in a recent response to a delegation letter, said it planned to broach options for addressing the concerns with Canadian officials later this month. Murkowski called that “somewhat assuring.”

Wednesday’s debate was the first of four debates or forums to which Murkowski has committed ahead of the November general election. Both her campaign and Stock’s streamed the debate on their Facebook pages.

Miller’s campaign had taken issue with some of the events that Murkowski agreed to participate in, seeing them as friendly to her. Murkowski spokesman Robert Dillon said this should put to rest the accusation that Murkowski is avoiding debates.

Murkowski lost the 2010 Republican primary to Miller but held onto the seat by waging a successful general election write-in campaign.

In this race, Murkowski is touting her seniority and casting herself as a pragmatist. On Wednesday night, she said she’d continue to be a champion for the fishing industry and oceans.

Stock, an immigration attorney, sees the debates as a chance to raise her visibility. One area of concern for her is health care, which she said is not affordable in Alaska. Congress needs to either fix or replace the current federal health care law, she said.

While Stock has won support from factions of the state Democratic party and from prominent Democrat Mark Begich, a former senator, Stock said she is a true independent, motivated to run because she was frustrated by the partisan gridlock in Congress.

Stock has not said who she would caucus with if elected, saying that’s a decision that can be made after the election.

Miller has said that if he wins, he’d caucus with Republicans. In a recent interview, he also said that he has no plans to change his party affiliation from Libertarian.

Metcalfe, who has feuded with Democratic party leaders over the direction of the party, has focused on anti-corruption platform.

In one of the more unusual exchanges during the debate, Metcalfe questioned how Stock could have accepted the endorsement of Begich, who he sees as part of a corrupted political culture. Stock said she was pleased to have Begich’s support. The question drew a reminder from the debate moderator to stick to fishing industry topics.

Craig, a first-time candidate who’s garnered little attention in the race, has expressed frustration with the direction of government. He has said members of Congress need to be more willing to compromise.

More in News

A truck with a snowplow drives along Douglas Highway on Dec. 31, 2025. (Mari Kanagy / Juneau Empire)
Warnings pile up under record-breaking snowfall in Juneau

December 2025 is the snowiest December in the city’s history.

Alaska's Department of Transportation and Public Facilities issue a warning of increased avalanche hazard along Thane Road. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Avalanche advisory in effect for Thane, Downtown

The alert is not an evacuation notice, but officials urge residents to stay informed.

Emergency lights flash on top of a police car. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire file photo)
Child dies in car accident on Christmas Eve, Juneau community collects donations

Flying Squirrel will serve as a collection point for donations for the child’s family.

Dense, wet snowpack piles up beneath a stop sign on Great Western street. (Mari Kanagy / Juneau Empire)
More heavy, wet snow forecast for the Juneau area this week

Capital City Fire and Rescue cautioned residents without four wheel drive from taking on the roads.

Photo by James Brooks / Alaska Beacon
Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy greets a child during the governor’s annual holiday open house on Tuesday, Dec. 12, 2022 at the Governor’s Mansion in Juneau.
Pipeline deal and disasters were highlight and low point of 2025, Alaska governor says

Alaska’s traditional industries got a boost from the Trump administration, but more drilling and mining are likely years away

The Seward-based band Blackwater Railroad Company plays onstage ahead of their New Year’s concert in Juneau at Crystal Saloon. (photo courtesy Blackwater Railroad Company)
Transience and adventure: Alaska band returns to Juneau for New Year’s concerts

The Blackwater Railroad Company talks about their ‘Alaska Music’ ahead of their shows.

A page of the Juneau Empire from a Nov. 29, 1915 edition. (Mari Kanagy / Juneau Empire)
Empire Archives: Juneau’s history for Dec. 27 & 28

1915 Juneau reporters reflect on holiday celebrations and look forward to the New Year.

A residence stands on Tuesday, Dec. 23 after a fatal house fire burned on Saturday, Dec. 20. (Mari Kanagy / Juneau Empire)
2 house fires burn in 3 days at Switzer Village

Causes of the fires are still under investigation.

A house on Telephone Hill stands on Dec. 22, 2025. (Mari Kanagy / Juneau Empire)
Court sets eviction date for Telephone Hill residents as demolition plans move forward

A lawsuit against the city seeks to reverse evictions and halt demolition is still pending.

Most Read