Matthew Murray, an attorney representing the Alaska State Employees Association, presents the union’s arguments in its lawsuit against the Dunleavy administration to the Alaska Supreme Court on Oct. 13, 2022. (Screenshot from Gavel Alaska livestream)

Matthew Murray, an attorney representing the Alaska State Employees Association, presents the union’s arguments in its lawsuit against the Dunleavy administration to the Alaska Supreme Court on Oct. 13, 2022. (Screenshot from Gavel Alaska livestream)

Dunleavy illegally altered rules for union dues, state supreme court rules

Nearly $450,000 in damages and costs awarded to ASEA as judgement in 2019 lawsuit upheld

A lower court ruling that the Dunleavy administration acted illegally by unilaterally changing union-dues rules for state employees was upheld Friday by the Alaska Supreme Court.

The court awarded the Alaska State Employees Association nearly $450,000 in damages, legal fees and interest for its lawsuit against Gov. Mike Dunleavy and officials in his administration, stemming from a 2019 executive order by Dunleavy requiring employees to opt in to union membership via a form filed annually with the state. That prevented the union from automatically collecting dues from paychecks of its roughly 8,000 member employees.

The order was based on a 2018 U.S. Supreme Court decision government employees can’t be forced to contribute to labor unions representing them in collective bargaining.

An Anchorage superior court judge ruled in 2021 that Dunleavy’s order violated the state’s contract with the union and the Alaska Constitution, awarding damages of $186,000. The state appealed the case to the state Supreme Court, which heard arguments in October.

“This decision makes it clear that the governor, attorney general and commissioner of administration were wholly motivated by political calculus and anti-union hostility, rather than sound legal footing,” said Heidi Drygas, executive director of ASEA Local 52, in a news release issued immediately after Friday’s ruling. “It backfired. By pursuing this meritless legal action, the Governor and members of his administration wasted public resources to the tune of millions of dollars rather than invest in the critical public services and public employees that are needed to carry them out.”

The union argued that the federal case — generally known as Janus — applied only to non-union workers required to pay fees to unions, but attorneys for the Dunleavy administration argued the decision also covers union members by implication. Attorney General Treg Taylor, in a prepared statement Friday, said he believes the U.S. Supreme Court needs to clarify the matter.

“For the state this case is about protecting the First Amendment rights of public sector employees,” he said. “While the decision from the Alaska Supreme Court was disappointing it was not surprising as clarification in regard to the Janus decision ultimately has to come from the United States Supreme Court given its federal constitutional underpinnings. We are hopeful that we can get clear guidance from this court in order to make sure state action does not jeopardize individual liberties.”

Friday’s ruling declares the administration’s position has “three major flaws.” In addition to the Janus case applying only to nonmember public employees, it also doesn’t require the state to implement opt-out rules and that employees are allowed sufficient First Amendment protection in merely deciding to join a union without the requirement for an annual formal declaration with the state.

’• Contact Mark Sabbatini at or (907) 957-2306

More in News

The Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Encore docks in Juneau in October, 2022. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
Ships in Port for the Week of May 28

Here’s what to expect this week.

Michael Ruppert inspects percussion instrumentation that’s part of the setup for the 1928 Kimball Theatre Pipe Organ in the State Office Building. Ruppert, co-owner of Rose City Organ Builders in Oregon, spent two days this with with fellow co-owner Christopher Nordwall tuning and restoring the organ to playable condition. The instrument has not been played since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, but local officials and musicians are hoping to schedule a lunchtime concert during the next couple of weeks. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Clearing the old pipes

Tuners revive 1928 Kimball organ in State Office Building; lunchtime concerts may resume next week

Michele Elfers, deputy director of CBJ Parks and Recreation, speaks to about 15 residents who attended a public meeting discussing the final version of the Montana Creek master plan at the Trail Mix Inc. shop Wednesday evening. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)
The Montana Creek master plan is finalized — now what?

Management officials emphasize openness to future ideas not included in plan.

Tuckerman Babcock hosts a rally in Soldotna during his campaign for state Senate in October of 2022. On Wednesday he was appointed to the University of Alaska’s Board of Regents by Gov. Mike Dunleavy. Babcock has a long and controversial political history in Alaska, including illegally demanding hundreds of state employees sign loyalty oaths to Dunleavy or be fired. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Tuckerman Babcock gets recess appointment to UA board by Dunleavy

Selection of controversial political strategist comes after Legislature’s rejection of Bethany Marcum.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Tuesday, May 30, 2023

This report contains information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Christopher Koch, music director of the Juneau Symphony, conducts a rehearsal of the theme from the 1989 “Batman” movie in the auditorium at Juneau-Douglas High School: Kalé in preparation for two concerts this weekend at the school featuring familiar soundtrack compositions from films with “showdown” plot lines. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
A final ‘Showdown’ for Juneau Symphony’s 60th season

Songs from epic confrontation films and an original by Taylor Vidic scheduled this weekend at JDHS.

This image shows the cover of Kate Troll’s new book “All In Due Time: A Memoir of Siblings, Genealogy, Secrets and Love.” Troll will be hosting a book signing at Hearthside Books on Friday evening. Her event is one of the many First Friday events scheduled for June. (Cirque Press)
Here’s what’s happening for First Friday

New artistic exhibitions, LGBTQ+ events and more.

Most Read