People walk past commercial properties in downtown Juneau on June 3. Earlier this year, the city increased the base land value throughout the borough by 50%  as part of the annual assessment process- a move that increased the tax bill for commercial property owners and generated more than 200 appeals. Wednesday night, Jeff Rogers, finance director for CBJ, said that despite complaints, the city's process was sound and the adjustment was needed. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire)

Commercial tax assessments under review

City finance director updates committee

On Wednesday night, Jeff Rogers, finance director for the City and Borough of Juneau, told the city’s Finance Committee that he stands by this spring’s commercial property assessments —despite the volume of complaints and appeals the city has faced over the changes.

After a decade of relatively flat assessments, commercial property owners saw their property’s assessed valuation increase dramatically earlier this year.

“The issue of commercial tax assessment and appeals is receiving a lot of public attention. I’m eager as the finance director to defend our process and the staff that performed it. But, my effort is not meant to be defensive,” Rogers said.

Rogers said the city increased the base land value throughout the borough by 50% as part of this year’s assessment — a move that generated more than 200 appeals, many more than past years. The reassessment also spurred a group of commercial property owners to organize in opposition.

Committee members peppered him with questions about the process but acknowledged that assessments and appeals are an area in which members don’t have sway because the process is designed to be free from the influence of elected officials and their direct employees.

In a memo to the committee, Rogers said that the “2021 commercial assessment changes are intended to correct a systemic economic inequity.”

Strictly commercial: Property owners chafe at new assessments

That inequity, Rogers said, grew over 10 years in which the city did not adjust the base value of land in the borough. Rogers said that assessors chose not to increase assessments due to a lack of data.

“You really face a crossroads where you continue to say we don’t have enough data to be confident or you use the data you have as confidently as you can to make the best decision you can, and that’s what we did,” Rogers said. “Obviously, that has been unsatisfactory to many commercial property owners.”

In the memo to the committee, Rogers explained that the issue ultimately affects homeowners in the borough.

“Over time, this failure to keep commercial property assessments in line with market prices shifted the property tax burden from commercial landowners to residential homeowners. As a result, commercial landowners simply have not paid their fair share of property tax over the past decade. This tax shift represents a systemic economic inequity that the 2021 assessments are intended to correct,” read the memo.

Rogers said the city is following the appeal process defined in state and local law for all appeals. He noted that while the number of appellants is large, more than 98% of property owners did not appeal their 2021 assessments.

“While no one wishes for more appeals than absolutely necessary, this year’s appeals are the direct consequence of inadequate information and inadequate adjustment over the last decade,” he said in the memo to the committee.

Process questions

The heart of the issue involves the way the city conducted the assessment that led to the increase.

Rogers said the city used a mass appraisal model to determine the right assessment level. He said the model looks at available selling prices and compares them to assessed value. He said the assessor works with very limited data because buyers and sellers are not required to disclose sales data to the city.

Opponents contend that each section of town should be evaluated independently.

Rogers shared an analysis that showed that most commercial land assessments had not increased in the last 10 years. He explained that city officials know that commercial properties sell for more than they did ten years ago.

He said that using the flat 50% increase on land makes sense because it applies to all the land in the city and lays on top of the current valuation, which takes location into account.

Wresting with a taxing issue: Increase value of commercial properties could reduce property tax rates

A second check

Rogers said that CBJ will work with Marty McGee, former state assessor within the Department of Commerce and the long-time assessor for the Municipality of Anchorage, on a contract basis to review the methodology the city used for the assessment.

He also said the local team is inviting Joe Caissie, who is currently the state assessor, to “look over our shoulder” to see if he has any concerns with the city approach or results.

Rogers also suggested that the city explore a process with an industry group to have an experienced third-party assessor audit the work.

“I think the sunshine is good,” Rogers said, acknowledging that with the volume of appeals currently on the books, the additional audit is likely better slated for a different time.

Doing better

Rogers said that more data — through more disclosed sales prices — is the key to improved assessment accuracy.

He said that the 2020 ordinance requiring buyers and sellers to disclose sales prices has not resulted in a big increase in reporting.

Assembly member Loren Jones, who will leave the body in October due to term limits, suggested that future assembly members explore ways to compel greater transaction disclosure.

Contact reporter Dana Zigmund at dana.zigmund@juneauempire.com or 907-308-4891.

More in News

The Norwegian Bliss arrives in Juneau on Monday, April 14, 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire file photo)
Ships in port for the week of April 20

This information comes from the Cruise Line Agencies of Alaska’s 2024 schedule.… Continue reading

Participants of the 2024 Sustainable Southeast Partnership annual retreat in Sheet’ká (Sitka). This week more than 150 people are gathering for the 12th annual retreat to strengthen relationships, accelerate ideas and energize work already happening across the region. (Photo by Bethany Goodrich)
Woven Peoples and Place: Celebrating values in action

Mentorship and storytelling with Shaelene Grace Moler.

Rep. Andi Story (D-Juneau), co-chair of the House Education Committee, speaks in favor of overriding Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s veto of an education funding bill during a joint session of the Alaska Legislature on Tuesday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Legislature fails to override Dunleavy’s veto of $1,000 increase in per-student education spending

Lawmakers supporting veto note state’s financial shortfall, suggest smaller BSA increase or new revenue.

Sarah Palin arriving at the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York on Tuesday, April 22, 2025. (Andres Kudacki / For The New York Times)
Jury rules against Palin in libel case against the New York Times

After two hours of deliberation, claim rejected she was defamed in newspaper’s 2017 editorial.

The Norwegian Bliss cruise ship docks in downtown Juneau on Monday, April 21, 2025. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Ballot petition to restrict daily and annual cruise passengers in Juneau certified for signatures

Opponent of measure argues it violates due process, free travel and other constitutional rights.

Workers process pollock. (Photo provided by Thompson and Co. PR on behalf of the Alaska Pollock Fishery Alliance)
Murkowski and other US lawmakers seek guest worker visa exception for seafood industry

Legislation would exempt seafood companies from a cap on the number of H-2B visa workers.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Sunday, April 20, 2025

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Will Muldoon’s official campaign profile photo as a Juneau Board of Education candidate in the 2024 municipal election. Muldoon resigned from the board on Monday. (City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Former write-in candidate Will Muldoon resigns from Juneau Board of Education

Muldoon, first write-in to win local election in 29 years in 2021, won easily reelection last fall.

Dancers exit the main conference room at Elizabeth Peratrovich Hall as part of the opening ceremonies for the Central Council of the Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska’s 90th Tribal Assembly on Wednesday, April 16, 2025. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Tlingit and Haida votes to give smaller Southeast communities more representation at tribal assembly

Change during constitutional convention significantly shrinks delegations in Anchorage and Seattle.

Most Read