Gavel (Courtesy photo)

Some public funds OK for private education, decision says

Not OK to replace core services.

Alaska’s Constitution prohibits spending “public funds for the direct benefit of a private educational institution” — except under some circumstances when people can, according to an opinion issued Monday by the state attorney general’s office.

The 19-page opinion evaluates if publicly funded correspondence schools — which have been found permissible under the state’s constitution — can pay for services from private schools. Deputy Attorney General Cori Mills, during a press briefing Monday, stated the answer depends largely on if the services are supplementing or replacing public school programs.

“The balancing act is determining whether you are really supplanting a public education with a private one with the backing of public dollars,” she said. “Under that balancing we know what you can’t do is pay for a student’s tuition to attend full-time private school. That leaves a lot of options open for school districts to allow students to fulfill their public education requirements.”

Mills said the decision tries to provide guidance on spending that is clearly constitutional and unconstitutional, and the seemingly large gray area in-between. When asked if that’s likely to result in differing opinions by different school districts (and governors as subsequent ones are elected) she said that will be up the districts and administrations to determine.

“I feel pretty confident that we came to the right balance,” she said. “When we’re talking about the final arbitrator, if somebody sues it’ll be the courts.”

Juneau offers correspondence instruction through the school district’s HomeBRIDGE Home School and the Raven Correspondence School that is part of a statewide Fairbanks-based program.

“The opinion will apply to the Juneau School District HomeBRIDGE program, but it is too early for us to know the specific impact it will have on our district program,” Kristin Bartlett, chief of staff for the district, stated in an email Monday afternoon. “We will wait for further guidance from the Department of Education and Early Development.”

A current program under such scrutiny is Mat-Su Central, a home school program within the Matanuska-Susitna Borough School District. Principal Stacey McIntosh told the Alaska Beacon the school currently reimburses families for secular classes at private schools and it is allowed under state statute. The Beacon also notes a charter school in Anchorage is planning to reimburse for private school classes starting this fall.

Mills said she authored the decision because Attorney General Treg Taylor recused himself from the matter in May since his wife wrote an opinion piece about school choice and allotments that month for the Alaska Policy Forum website. That article and a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision declaring states can’t limit religious schools from accessing public funding just because they are religious brought questions about using state correspondence funding for private education to the forefront.

Mills, in her decision, notes the 6-3 Supreme Court decision that some observers said fundamentally shifts the use of public funds for private/religious schools isn’t applicable to the issues being considered here.

“This conclusion is not changed by the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent decisions interpreting the federal Free Exercise Clause; nor are those decisions likely to invalidate Alaska’s restriction on using public correspondence allotments only for nonsectarian services and materials,” Mills wrote in her decision.

The issue itself is not new, Mills said, noting the Alaska Legislature in 2014 enacted a statute authorizing districts to “provide an annual student allotment to a parent or guardian of a student enrolled in the correspondence study program for the purpose of meeting instructional expenses for the student.”

In her opinion, Mills states using limited public funds for materials and services from a private vendor to fulfill student’s individual learning plan “does not, on its face, violate the Alaska Constitution’s prohibition against spending public funds for the direct benefit of a private educational institution.”

“The nature of the private educational institution providing the materials or services does not impact this conclusion,” she wrote. “Neither the Alaska Constitution nor the statutes make any distinction between religious or non-religious educational institutions and online or in-person education.”

However, she adds, “the constitution does not permit supplanting public education with private school education by using public allotment funds to pay tuition for full-time enrollment in a private school.”

• Contact reporter Mark Sabbatini at mark.sabbatini@juneauempire.com

More in News

The Aurora Borealis glows over the Mendenhall Glacier in 2014. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Aurora forecast

Forecasts from the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute for the week of Jan. 22

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Juneau man indicted on child pornography charges

A Juneau man was indicted Thursday on charges of possessing or accessing… Continue reading

Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire 
Juneau’s municipal and state legislative members, their staff, and city lobbyists gather in the Assembly chambers Thursday meeting for an overview of how the Alaska State Legislature and politicians in Washington, D.C., are affecting local issues.
Local leaders, lawmakers and lobbyists discuss political plans for coming year

Morning meeting looks at local impact of state, national political climates.

This photo shows pills police say were seized after a suspicious package was searched. (Juneau Police Department)
Police: 1,000 fentanyl pills, 86 grams of meth seized

Juneau man arrested on felony charges.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Friday, Jan. 27, 2023

This report contains information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

A resident and his dog walk past the taped off portion of the Basin Road Trestle after it suffered damaged from a rockslide earlier this week. The trestle is open to pedestrians, but will remain closed to vehicular traffic until structural repairs are made, according to city officials. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)
Rocky road: Basin Road Trestle open to pedestrians, remains closed to vehicles

City officials say repairs are currently being assessed after damaging rockfall

Library Director Dave Berry and Advisory Board Chair Kate Finn participate in Library Advisory Board meeting on Tuesday Jan. 17, 2023, at Homer City Hall, in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Emilie Springer/Homer News)
Homer Library Advisory Board upholds decision to retain LGBTQ+ books

A citizen’s group last year submitted a petition asking that the books be removed from the children’s section

Courtesy Photo / Juneau Police Department 
This photo shows Woodrow Farrell Eagleman who police say after going missing on Jan. 11 was seen leaving town on Jan. 12 via airport surveillance.
Police: Man reported missing took plane out of town

A Juneau man recently reported as missing was found leaving town on… Continue reading

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Thursday, Jan. 26

This report contains information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Most Read