Lynch & Kennedy Dry Goods is owned by Skagway shopkeeper Rosemary Libert, who was found not guilty Friday of misrepresenting art as Alaska Native-made.

Lynch & Kennedy Dry Goods is owned by Skagway shopkeeper Rosemary Libert, who was found not guilty Friday of misrepresenting art as Alaska Native-made.

Skagway shopkeeper wins federal Native art scam case

“Mhmm,” is a slight hum of the lips usually in response to a question as a way of agreeing — that’s the argument federal prosecutors used in trying to prove a Skagway shopkeeper misrepresented art as Alaska Native-made.

But a jury wasn’t convinced.

Twelve members of a U.S. District Court jury in Juneau decided unanimously on Friday that Rosemary V. Libert, 56, was not guilty of misrepresenting Indian produced goods, which is a violation of the Indian Arts and Crafts Act.

Libert is the fifth person among Southeast Alaska shop owners or employees brought into federal court after an undercover U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service investigation named them as falsely selling art in their stores to tourists under the guise that it was made by Alaska Native artists. In court Friday, Assistant U.S. Attorney Jack Schmidt played portions of the audio the undercover agent recorded between his interaction with Libert on June 30, 2015 at her store Lynch & Kennedy Dry Goods.

[Two Juneau shop owners tied to Native art scam]

“So are we looking at a piece of Eskimo art?” the agent was heard asking in the audio recording. Schmidt argued that the two were both looking at a blanket toss carving that the agent knew before entering the store was crafted by Chupak, an artist of Cambodian descent who works out of Juneau.

“Yes,” Libert replied.

“This is a great Indian piece,” the agent later comments.

“Yeah, it’s pretty cool,” Libert is heard saying.

“So you know this artist? … So he would be like, ah, like an Alaska native?”

“Mhmm,” Libert replied.

“Perfect,” the agent said.

But defense attorney Michael Satin argued on behalf of his client that the exchange was far from perfect. Instead, he said in court that audio alone was not enough to be sure both Libert and the undercover agent were looking at the same piece while the conversation was carrying on. Also, he mentioned several times that the store was seeing an influx of customers and with background music playing, there was too much going on to know that Libert clearly understood the questions being asked by this seemingly curious tourist.

As proof that his client would normally be direct about the sales of Native and non-Native pieces, under less busy circumstances and with more clearly asked questions, Satin turned to an email exchange between Libert and the undercover agent one year prior when the agent used a different name to inquire about a piece by Chupak.

The agent made himself appear willing to buy the piece that was upwards of $2,000, then asked if it was an Alaska Native piece. Libert’s emailed response: “Chupak is NOT native indian or eskimo (Alaskan native).”

“You asked a direct question and a direct answer followed,” Satin told the agent on the witness stand.

“Mhmm,” the agent responded, then quickly said “yes” instead, realizing he was slipping into an unofficial but common form of agreement.

Satin argued that without more direct questions asked by the agent, and without a video recording to help follow along what was truly taking place, a not-guilty verdict was the only logical choice for jurors, even telling them it should take them no longer than five minutes to come to such a conclusion.

Prosecutor Schmidt countered that on three occasions that June day in the store, Libert heard the words “Eskimo,” “Indian,” and “Native,” and never once did it occur to her she should use clearer words with the person she was speaking with about the artwork he was about to buy. The Chupak carving of a blanket toss, which represents an Alaska Native tradition of holding animal skin within a circle of people while another person jumps in the middle as though on a trampoline, was not actually made by an Alaska Native artist. The burden is on the shopkeeper and other employees to make sure tourists are completely aware of those differences, Schmidt said in his closing statement.

“This law is a truth and advertising law to protect customers,” Schmidt said. “She let the assumption continue.”

More than an hour after deliberation, the verdict came back not guilty.

Libert’s was the only case of the five in the undercover USFW investigation to head to trial. Two Juneau shop owners, Norma M. Carandang, 60, with Northstar Gift Shop, and Vinod “Vinny” L. Sippy, 38, with Diamond Island, Icy Strait, and Gemstone Heaven, both pled out of their cases, agreeing to pay fines and make donations to the Indian Arts and Crafts board.

[Guilty plea ends Native art scam in Juneau]

Puerto Rican resident and Ketchikan business owner Gabriel T. Karim, 33, with Alaskan Heritage, appears to be in the final stages of a plea deal, according to online federal court records, while Judy M. Gengler, 65, a seasonal employee for Libert, seems to have had her case dismissed by prosecutors.

• Contact reporter Paula Ann Solis at 523-2272 or paula.solis@juneauempire.com.

Read more news:

Two hospitalized as Ketchikan forfeits over safety concerns

This misleading photo spread in Marie Claire shows Mendenhall Glacier completely gone

Coffee-stand robber heads to prison for eight years

More in News

Jasmine Chavez, a crew member aboard the Quantum of the Seas cruise ship, waves to her family during a cell phone conversation after disembarking from the ship at Marine Park on May 10. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Ships in port for the week of July 20

Here’s what to expect this week.

Michele Stuart Morgan (right), a Juneau Board of Education candidate, signs a qualifying petition for Jeff Redmond (center), who is also seeking one of three school board seats in the Oct. 1 municipal election, just before Monday’s filing deadline at City Hall. At left, Deputy Municipal Clerk processes last-minute paperwork filed by candidates. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Here’s the candidates certified for the Oct. 1 municipal election ballot as the filing deadline passes

Two running for mayor, seven for two Assembly seats, six for three school board seats.

A U.S. Coast Guard Air Station Sitka helicopter hovers over Sitka Sound during routine hoist training on April 25, 2023. (Lt. Cmdr. Wryan Webb/U.S. Coast Guard)
Coast Guard calls off search for trio who went missing flying from Juneau to Yakutat

Haines pilot Samuel Wright, Yakutat residents Hans Munich and Tanya Hutchins were on plane.

Juneau Municipal Attorney Robert Palmer reacts to praise for his service from Assembly members after his resignation was announced during a May 13 meeting. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Three city attorney finalists to be interviewed in public sessions this week by Juneau Assembly

Two Juneau residents with CBJ experience and D.C.-based Army attorney seek to replace Robert Palmer.

Angela Rodell, former CEO of the Alaska Permanent Fund Corp., speaks to the House Finance Committee on Thursday, June 24, 2021. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire file photo)
Angela Rodell, former Alaska Permanent Fund Corp. CEO, says she’s running for mayor

First-time candidate to challenge incumbent Beth Weldon; filing deadline for local election is today.

Republican U.S. House candidate Nick Begich, with sign-holding supporters, waves to Midtown Anchorage motorists on Election Day in 2022. (Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon)
Some Alaska Republican candidates pledge to withdraw if they aren’t atop GOP votes in primary

Pledges are a way to circumvent ranked choice voting, according to one supporter.

People protesting the death of Steven Kissack gather at Marine Park after marching through downtown Juneau on Sunday afternoon. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire)
Protesters demand police accountability following death of Steven Kissack

Advocates gather where he was shot, say they are raising their voices because “he’s unable to speak.”

A U.S. Coast Guard Air Station Sitka helicopter hovers over Sitka Sound during routine hoist training. (U.S. Coast Guard Photo by Lt. Cmdr Wryan Webb)
Yakutat-bound charter flight missing from Juneau

Flight departed from Juneau on Saturday with three people aboard, according to U.S. Coast Guard.

President Biden at the White House on July 3. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
President Joe Biden drops out of race, scrambling the campaign for the White House

Withdraws under pressure from fellow Democrats; endorses Vice President Kamala Harris to take on Trump.

Most Read