A man stands in the doorway of a downtown shop on Tuesday, July 21, 2020, the day after the  City and Borough of Juneau passed an ordinance requiring masks in public places. When passed, the rules included a $25 fine for non-compliance. This week, assembly members reinstated the fine, after they had voted to drop it earlier this summer. (Peter Segall/Juneau Empire File)

City officials explain why COVID fines are back

City officials share why they matter

After the City and Borough of Juneau voted to reestablish a fine for people who don’t follow the city’s COVID-19 mitigation measures, many are asking why the change and wondering how the fine will work.

The Wednesday evening decision to re-establish the fine was part of the vote that renewed the city’s ordinance aimed at curbing the spread of the virus. Without the renewal, the ordinance would have expired on Oct. 31.

The $25 fine was included in the initial mitigation measures passed last year. It was in effect until July 31, when the assembly voted to drop it.

At the time, overall case counts were slowly creeping up and the city extended the mitigation measures, minus the fine. In the last several weeks, case counts have swelled with the city routinely reporting 30 to 40 cases a day.

[City extends COVID mitigation measures, restores fines for violations]

Although often referred to as the “mask mandate,” the measures are a collection of mitigation strategies and the fine could be assessed based on a violation of any of them.

The strategies the city follows vary based on factors such as the level of viral spread, hospital capacity locally and regionally, and public health’s ability to conduct contract tracing. As the community risk level changes, the corresponding mitigation measures adjust.

Mitigations include limiting the size of public gatherings and requiring bars and restaurants to operate at reduced capacity. Public masking is a measure in place during times of high community spread—and the area that tends to generate the most attention.

The current community risk level is “Level 3-High,” a level that calls for vaccinated and unvaccinated people to wear masks inside public places. In addition, capacity limits apply to many businesses, and bars and restaurants must close at 11:00 p.m.

An important tool

While the fine has never been levied, city officials say that it’s an essential tool in giving the ordinance teeth and making it easier to enforce.

“When we have the option, the conversation becomes easier,” said Robert Barr, deputy city manager, in a Friday morning phone interview.

Barr said that when the fine is in place, the community service or police officer can use it as part of the conversation.

“The officer can say something like, ‘I really need to ask you to wear a mask. I don’t want to issue a fine, so help me out here,’” Barr said.

Barr said that having the option of a fine makes the mitigation measures a requirement rather than a suggestion.

He said that Juneau’s police officers are not “generally hunting around” for mitigation scofflaws, but that the city does follow up when complaints come in.

“We aren’t out and about looking for people not wearing masks,” Barr said. “We don’t have the capacity for that.”

During Wednesday’s meeting, Assembly member Loren Jones said that most of the violations that come to his attention revolve around businesses with employees who are not wearing masks.

Jones said he supported reinstating the fine because it provides a tool for people tasked with enforcing the rules.

“We aren’t trying to raise revenue or do anything like that,” Jones said. “But, if the community service officer goes out and people just thumb their nose, that puts a lot of staff in an uncomfortable situation.”

[Aid aloft: Medevac organization gets new aircraft

According to newspaper accounts shared online by Alaska historian David Reamer, during the 1918 flu pandemic, the Common Council of the City of Juneau, Alaska, imposed a $21 fine on people who did not wear masks “upon our streets and in all public places.”

If the 1918 fine was adjusted for inflation, the 2021 equivalent fine would be about $380.

“This is a duty you owe not only to yourself but to your fellow citizens, for is not the saving of one human life recompense enough for the few days of discomfort that the wearing of the masks may cause? Show your Juneau spirit, wear your mask for a few days so that we may again open our schools and our commercial activity may become normal once more,” reads the clip from November 1918.


Barr said the volume of complaints around mitigation misses are pretty low — generally a few a week.

He also said the city staff members seek voluntary compliance by talking with people and trying to change behavior first. He said sometimes officers simply supply a mask.

Barr said the fine could apply to a business or a person, depending on the circumstances.

“It’s natural, human nature to focus on the negative and to pay attention to those interactions that aren’t the best. It’s super important to realize there are so many good things that outweigh the bad. More than 90% of the time, the interactions are good,” he said.

The assembly will revisit the ordinance early next year to consider if it needs to be renewed beyond March 1.

• Contact reporter Dana Zigmund at dana.zigmund@juneauempire.com or 907-308-4891.

More in News

(Juneau E
Aurora forecast for the week of Nov. 27

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

Harborview Elementary School was briefly evacuated Friday after a bomb threat was received at midday, according to the Juneau Police Department. (Michael S. Lockett / Juneau Empire file photo)
Harborview Elementary School briefly evacuated after bomb threat

Police say incident appears connected to other threats at Alaska schools in recent months.

Michael Carter selects chips from a large box while Kalie Purkey wheels their 1-year-old daughter, Oaklynn Carter, along the row of tables at the Southeast Alaska Food Bank’s weekly food pantry on Thursday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
‘New normal’ is long waits for SNAP benefits and long lines at food pantries

Juneau residents cite variety of reasons for being part of backlog of more than 12,000 applicants.

Constantine president Peter Mercer descends from a helicopter after a tour of drilling sites in August. Mercer said drilling work will be similar in the next two or three years, as the company starts to transition to more economic, environmental,. and engineering analysis that will result in a full plan for how to access the ore, which the company is shooting to release in 2026. (Lex Treinen / Chilkat Valley News)
Constantine Mining president lays out timeline for Palmer Project work

Project north of Haines at least five years from decisions about mine development, executive says

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Wednesday, Dec. 6, 2023

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

A bit of a sun break as seen from the John Muir Cabin, submitted on Dec. 6. (Photo by Deborah Rudis)
Wild Shots

To showcase our readers’ work to the widest possible audience, Wild Shots… Continue reading

The Southeast Alaska village of Metlakatla. (Photo courtesy of the Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities)
Biden administration could wade into lawsuit over Southeast Alaska tribal fishing rights

The Biden administration could jump into a high-profile lawsuit involving a Southeast… Continue reading

The gates are locked at the Pipeline Skate Park at midday Thursday, after Juneau’s Parks and Recreation Department announced the facility will be open limited hours until further notice due to an increase in vandalism and drug paraphernalia. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
City: Pipeline Skate Park open reduced hours due to ‘sharp increase’ of vandalism, drug activity

Extra patrols by police and parks staff also planned for facility at Jackie Renninger Park.

A car drives by Mendenhall River Community School on Back Loop Road on Thursday morning. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Woman, two children struck by vehicle while crossing road near Mendenhall River Community School

Victims in stable condition, initial investigation shows driver not at-fault, according to police.

Most Read