Someone holds up an inflatable Alaska Marine Highway ferry at at a rally to support of the Alaska Marine Highway System on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2020. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)

Someone holds up an inflatable Alaska Marine Highway ferry at at a rally to support of the Alaska Marine Highway System on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2020. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)

Opinion: Reshaping coastal Alaska transportation

The focus of the Alaska Marine Highway System Reshaping Work Group was too narrow

  • Saturday, January 23, 2021 6:30am
  • Opinion

The focus of the Alaska Marine Highway System Reshaping Work Group was too narrow. There was no effort spent on evaluating and comparing the fares of AMHS service against fares of commercial marine freight lines and airlines. There was no consideration given to the potential for subsidizing commercial marine freight lines and commercial airlines to reduce costs to the state but provide equivalent service to meet outlying communities’ transport needs.

Over long-haul routes, commercial carriers transport up to 99 percent of passengers and freight to Alaska. Had the workgroup gone online and compared commercial airfares, they would find that it is significantly cheaper to fly to and from Alaska and rent a car for a month at your destination than to travel by ferry with your car. They would find that over long distances, shipping rates for cars on commercial barge lines are competitive with AMHS rates. Also, when it comes to frequency of service and speed, you cannot beat the airlines.

Over shorter distances, subsidized AMHS fares from commercial centers to small outlying communities are substantially lower than commercial carriers. This adversely impacts the level and cost of commercial services provided to small communities. Unfortunately, the low traffic demand generated by these communities falls far short of covering AMHS’s operating cost to provide service. AMHS vessels are too large to economically serve the low traffic demand and the fleet is too small to provide adequate service frequency. Yet commercial air carriers are operating and providing a superior sustainable service and several small communities continue to receive some barge service. Unlike AMHS, commercial carriers must cover all costs out of fares and tariffs, including cost of periodic refurbish and eventual replacement of infrastructure, aircraft, barges, equipment, and all overhead costs plus profit.

The state needs to provide the total cost of AMHS service by route, including prorated amortized refurbishment, capital replacement costs and all administrative overhead cost and estimate the average total cost per user it costs AMHS to transport passengers and vehicles by route on a seasonal and annual basis. A comparison of the average total cost per passenger and commercial fares over each route should demonstrate that subsidizing commercial carriers to achieve AMHS fares would save the state millions. AMHS competes directly with commercial carriers by stripping traffic from carriers that otherwise would support better commercial services to coastal communities.

It is not surprising that most Alaskans from communities with ferry service, choose to fly and rent a car because, aside from cost, AMHS is too slow, infrequent, or unavailable. Residents who do take the ferry often end up flying one-way, because they cannot afford hotel and restaurant meals until the next ferry departure.

Commercial freight and air carriers spend millions across the state to transport the majority of passenger and freight movements to, from, and across Alaska. Commercial carriers pay the state for land leases, taxes, and fees for use of infrastructure and support services provided by the state. Air carriers transport most independent tourists to Alaska. The current state budget deficit warrants scrutiny of AMHS expenditures to determine whether funds allocated to AMHS would be better spent to support subsidies of commercial transportation services to small coastal communities, to free up funds for other state priorities.

In conclusion, air carriers and commercial freight carriers provide essential and sustainable transportation to all of Alaska at minimal cost to the state. AMHS should discontinue mainline ferry service to Bellingham and across Gulf of Alaska as nonessential and unsustainable, as it presents a high opportunity cost to both the traveler and the state. The state should stop competing with commercial carriers and retire the mainline ferries. The state should offer the Interisland Ferry Authority a transitional subsidy to test viability of reinstatement of their northern route to Petersburg and Wrangell and offer the ferry Lituya to the Metlakatla Indian Community. The state should utilize the two new Alaska class ferries, supported by ferry terminal improvements, in Lynn Canal to connect the capital city Juneau to the continental road system via Haines and Skagway. The state should update the regional transportation plans to identify and support private and commercial transportation infrastructure needs.

• Andy Hughes has resided in Juneau resident since 1973. Hughes is a retired in 2017 as regional chief of planning for the Southcoast Region of the Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities.

More in Opinion

Opinion: Why governments cry wolf

What happens in a society that grows accustomed to well-intentioned alerts?

(Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: The possibility of increasing independent visitors to Southeast Alaska

Discussion of how we might boost independent tourism is ongoing — and vital.

Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

"I’ll tell you, one reason I got the COVID vaccines is because wearing a mask is getting old, and I want to do my part in helping us get past necessary mask mandates," writes Dr. Emily Kane. (Courtesy Photo)
Opinion: Why I got vaccinated

It’s the most responsible approach to the health of your neighbors and fellow community members.

Opinion: Yes, families still matter

Let’s admit that without a healthy family, kids suffer – sometimes for life.

Opinion: We need more information on meeting growing power needs

More renewable energy could put Juneau on the map as a sustainable community.

Opinion: Some principles of Earth based climate change

“As for the next ice age, it’s about time. But no worries. CO2 has saved us.”

Opinion: Laws like the Equality Act shouldn’t hide behind masks

The far left is obscuring the implications of their vote.

Most Read