In this Feb. 27, 2019 photo, U.S. President Donald Trump shakes hands with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un in Hanoi. (Evan Vucci | Associated Press File)

In this Feb. 27, 2019 photo, U.S. President Donald Trump shakes hands with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un in Hanoi. (Evan Vucci | Associated Press File)

Opinion: ‘Peace through strength’ is Orwellian call to arms

What does the history and future of nuclear weapons proliferation mean for Alaskans?

  • By Shelby Surdyk
  • Tuesday, March 5, 2019 9:32am
  • Opinion

Eleven years ago, Lijon Eknilang came to Juneau to speak at the World Nuclear Awareness Conference, hosted at the University of Alaska Southeast. A survivor of the U.S. Nuclear Testing Program (NTP) in the Marshall Islands and a victim of the secret human radiation experiment called Project 4.1, Lijon dedicated her life raising awareness about the human and environmental costs of nuclear weapons testing and development.

Today is her birthday, March 1. In honor of Lijon, who passed away in 2012, I would like to take a moment to reflect on the history and future of nuclear weapons proliferation — and ask, what does this mean for Alaskans?

March 1, 2019, is also the 65th anniversary of Castle Bravo — the largest atmospheric thermonuclear test ever conducted by the United States. At 15 megatons, Castle Bravo was 1,000 times more powerful than the bomb dropped on Hiroshima.

After Castle Bravo, the U.S. thought that it had won the global arms race.

It had not.

Less than a decade after Castle Bravo, the Soviet Union responded with an even larger test: Tsar Bomba.

The Soviet test had a blast radius of 58 megatons, nearly 4,000 times larger than Hiroshima, and the shockwave broke windowpanes 560 miles away.

Tsar Bomba shook the planet and woke the world to the madness of the arms race. Within two years of test, the U.S. and the Soviet Union, along with 120 other countries, had signed the Partial Test Ban Treaty (PTBT) — banning nuclear tests in the atmosphere, underwater, or outer space.

After the PTBT came into force, atmospheric testing stopped, but global stockpiles continued to grow. By 1986, more than 70,000 nuclear warheads were stockpiled worldwide.

The pattern of proliferation changed in 1987, when U.S. President Ronald Reagan and Soviet Prime Minister Mikhail Gorbachev signed the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty. That bilateral agreement, signed at the height of the Cold War, eliminated an entire class of nuclear weapons, and restricted the stockpiles of both countries. It marked a turning point in the arms race. Some say it saved the world.

Since the INF Treaty was signed, global stockpiles have steadily decreased. Today, the number of nuclear warheads worldwide stands at 14,000; an 80 percent reduction since with INF Treaty was signed.

But on Feb. 1, 2019, the INF treaty expired when President Donald Trump formally withdrew the U.S. from the agreement.

In an opinion piece published in the Juneau Empire last month, James Jay Carafano argued that America needed “peace through strength,” and so should disregard arms control agreements (such as the INF Treaty) that put limits on the growth of the U.S. nuclear arsenal.

Peace through strength? I have never heard such an Orwellian call to arms.

As a lifelong Alaskan who has spent the last 15-years studying the history of nuclear weapons development and policy, I disagree that nuclear proliferation can bring peace. The dissolution of the INF Treaty signals the start of a 21st century nuclear arms race. If the race escalates into full-scale confrontation (whether due to accident or aggression), Alaska’s proximity to nuclear armed states could make it the closest target. The end of the INF treaty could also invite a new era of nuclear weapons testing. In the 1960s and ‘70s, nuclear testing directly impacted Alaska when underground tests were carried out on the island of Amchitka. Alaska was also impacted indirectly by nuclear testing; radiocesium from global atmospheric fallout remains concentrated in Arctic foodwebs, threatening human-ecological health.

I do agree with Carafano that the world needs “peace through strength” — but a different kind of strength. It needs the kind of strength that people like Lijon embodied. A fearlessness in the face of power. It needs the kind of strength shown by the community members of Point Hope when they stopped the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission from detonating five thermonuclear explosions on the North Slope as part of Project Chariot. It needs the determination and commitment from a group of people who believe that another future, one without nuclear weapons, is possible.

The world needs that kind of strength again today. The world needs it now.


• Shelby Surdyk is an activist and organizer from Skagway. She’s working with Veterans for Peace to organize a youth congress for the global elimination of nuclear weapons, to be held in Juneau in the Spring of 2020.


More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

A demonstrator holds a sign in front of the U.S. Supreme Court as arguments are heard about the Affordable Care Act, Tuesday, Nov. 10, 2020, in Washington. (AP Photo / Alex Brandon)
My Turn: The U.S. is under health care duress

When millions become uninsured, it will strain the entire health care system.

The U.S. Coast Guard Cutter Storis is underway, June 3, 2025, from Pascagoula, Mississippi. The Storis is the Coast Guard’s first new polar icebreaker acquisition in 25 years and will expand U.S. operational presence in the Artic Ocean. (Photo courtesy of Edison Chouest Offshore)
My Turn: Welcoming the Coast Guard for a brighter future

Our community is on the verge of transformation with the commissioning of the icebreaker Storis.d

Photo by Nathaniel Herz/Northern Journal
Text messages between Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy and President Donald Trump.
Commentary: Alaska’s governor said he texts Trump. I asked for copies.

A couple of months ago, I was reporting on the typhoon that… Continue reading

Faith Myers stands at the doors of the Alaska Psychiatric Institute in Anchorage. (Photo courtesy Faith Myers, file)
Alaska’s system of protecting Trust beneficiaries is 40 years behind best practice

The lower 48 has a 3-century headstart on protecting people in locked psychiatric facilities.

veggies
File Photo 
Community organizations that serve food at their gatherings can do a lot by making menus of whole, nutritious offerings according to health and wellness coach Burl Sheldon.
Food served by “groups for good” can be health changemakers

Health and wellness coach thinks change can start on community event menus

Construction equipment operating at night at the White House. (photo by Peter W. Stevenson/The Washington Post)
Opinion: Gold at the center of power

What the White House’s golden ballroom reveals about Modern America

Win Gruening (courtesy)
Opinion: Affordability message delivered to Juneau Assembly; but will it matter?

On October 7, frustrated voters passed two ballot propositions aimed at making… Continue reading

Alaska Children’s Trust Photo
Natalie Hodges and Hailey Clark use the online safety conversation cards produced by the Alaska Children’s Trust.
My Turn: Staying connected starts with showing up

When our daughter was 11 and the COVID lockdown was in full… Continue reading

Telephone Hill as seen from above (Photo courtesy of City and Borough of Juneau)
Letter: For Telephone Hill, remember small is adaptable

Writer finds the finances don’t add up on planned development

Doug Mills/The New York Times 
President Donald Trump disembarks the USS Harry S. Truman before delivering remarks for the Navy’s 250th anniversary in Norfolk, Va., Oct. 5, 2025.
Opinion: Trump’s job is done

The ultra-rich have completed their takeover of America.

Google Maps screenshot
The star shows the approximate location of the proposed Cascade Point Ferry terminal by the Alaska Department of Transportation & Public Facilities in partnership with Goldbelt, Inc.
Opinion: An open letter to Cascade Point ferry terminal proponents

To: Governor Dunleavy, DOT Directors, and Cascade Point ferry terminal project consultants,… Continue reading