Opinion: An outside the box schools solution

Opinion: An outside the box schools solution

Let us look to what we already have.

  • By Kali Hofman
  • Wednesday, August 19, 2020 4:47pm
  • Opinion

By Kali Hofman

Inside this storm of a pandemic, revolution for civil rights and economic instability lies a silver lining. We have a perfect opportunity to think outside the box, both figuratively and literally. The box I am referring to is the school building. The School Board and Juneau School District Administration have made their decision: This school year will begin as distance education. I worry about families who cannot support such education. Even if the students were to go back to school, all those disinfecting chemicals have me recoiling. We all need our microbiomes as healthy as possible to protect us, not compromised by sterilizing chemicals.

Challenging times call for creative problem solving, but what I am proposing has historical precedent. According to an article in the New York Times titled “Schools Beat Earlier Plagues With Outdoor Classes. We Should, Too.” during outbreaks of tuberculosis in the early 20th Century, children in New England attended schools on rooftops, abandoned ferries or with windows wide open to ensure that they could breathe fresh air, even during frigid winters. Here in Juneau, we have an excellent setting for schools to embrace the outdoors. A recent article in The Atlantic, “Why Can’t We Just Have Class Outside?” states that some schools actually are making plans to start the school year out of doors. We should, too.

Marginalized and suppressed communities — Indigenous, Black, elderly, disabled and immigrant — are the ones bearing the brunt of this pandemic. They work on the front lines, under-protected and exposed to toxic chemicals, if they have work at all. Their stress levels run high even without a pandemic breathing down their necks. Their children tend to be the ones who will suffer the most difficulties from screen-based distance education.

The benefits of outdoor education are many. The CDC’s current guidelines recommend frequent hand washing, wearing a cloth face mask when around people outside of one’s household, and staying at least six feet apart from others. That sort of distancing is much easier to achieve outside. According to a Japanese study published in MedRxiv, evidence is showing that virus transmission is almost 20 times less likely to happen outside. Children who would otherwise not get much of an education this year would be able to attend school. Parents would not have to choose between working and homeschooling, and reduced chances of contracting the virus would help protect our valuable teachers.

Moving education outside can lead to other, greater benefits. Studies referenced in the article, “Childhood Nature Exposure Predicts Adult Mental Health,” published in Townsend Letter show that children with frequent access to the great outdoors have much better mental health as adults than those deprived of such access. Moreover, taking school outside can help to mend the rift between people and our natural world, instilling a better understanding and a love for our Earth in the generation that will need to buckle down and deal with the looming climate disaster.

The JSD and the School Board have spent months working to design a re-entry plan. We can use that model, but just change the venue. Our community can brainstorm with teachers to transfer curricula out of doors. Small groups of students can meet with their teachers in open-sided park shelters or tents when the weather is less than optimal. We can look to established forest schools in the U.S. and Europe, including Finland and Germany. If the Finns can teach their kids outside, then so can we. Instead of buying disinfectant sprays, we can redirect funds to long-term investments, such as warm clothing and footwear for students in need, bus driver salaries so students can travel in socially-distanced, open-windowed buses and rechargeable headset microphones so students can hear their teachers along the trail.

Are we willing to compromise the health of our community by investing further in confining our lives inside chemically sanitized boxes? Let us instead look to what we already have: an abundance of accessible outdoor recreation facilities, the teachers and parents already interested in creating outdoor schooling opportunities, and thousands of years of Native wisdom on how to thrive in our environment. Juneau has the resources and creative minds necessary to make this school year come together — outside!

• Kali Hofman is a resident of Juneau, Alaska, mother of three and a frequent volunteer at both Juneau Coop Preschool and Montessori Borealis. Columns, My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire. Have something to say? Here’s how to submit a My Turn or letter.

More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

President Trump as he visits Sheikh Zayed Grand Mosque in Abu Dhabi, Thursday, May, 15, 2025. During the first major foreign trip of his second term, President Trump has told audiences in the Middle East that he’s willing to set the past aside in the interests of peace and profit. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
Opinion: Count on Sullivan to erase another red line

“If you want President Trump to succeed, this kind of skeezy stuff… Continue reading

Michelle Bonnet Hale is a former deputy mayor of Juneau. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Sen. Sullivan and Rep. Begich are complicit in destruction of US democracy

I have found myself struggling, these past few months, to find the… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Demolishing Telephone Hill won’t save downtown businesses

In a recent front-page article of the Juneau Empire was a demolition… Continue reading

Dick Maitland, a foley artist, works on the 46th season of “Sesame Street” at Kaufman Astoria Studios in New York, Dec. 15, 2025. (Ariana McLaughlin/The New York Times)
Opinion: Trump’s embarrassing immaturity Republicans won’t acknowledge

It was only a matter of time before President Donald Trump took… Continue reading

An architect’s rendering of the proposed Capital Civic Center. (NorthWind Architects and Jensen Yorba Wall)
My Turn: Capital Civic Center will be an economic driver for Juneau

At the urging of the mayor, Travel Juneau, the Juneau Chamber of… Continue reading

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Clean up the Tulsequah Chief Mine

The Tulsequah Chief mine in northwest British Columbia, about 30 miles upstream… Continue reading

Republican U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan, standing with Alaska Public Media President Ed Ulman, at left, accepted a “champion of public broadcasting” award in 2020 from a coalition of public television stations. Amid efforts to strip federal funding of public media, Sullivan calls NPR “overly partisan” but says he “understands that Alaska’s public radio stations are essential to our state.” (Photo courtesy of America’s Public Television Stations)
Public media is in the crosshairs. How will Alaska’s congressional delegation vote?

Should public media be spared the budget cutting axe of President Donald… Continue reading

Most Read