My Turn: The PFD a powerful idea, not just a check

  • By ALEXANDER HOKE
  • Thursday, March 3, 2016 1:00am
  • Opinion

Gov. Jay Hammond fought hard to create the Permanent Fund Dividend program so that a portion of one-time oil wealth would be shared equally with all future Alaskans. He specifically stated that earnings from the fund belong “to the people, not the government.”

Now, in the face of a $3.5 billion budget shortfall, Gov. Bill Walker’s Sovereign Wealth Plan (SB 128) and Sen. Lesil McGuire’s fiscal plan (SB 114) propose to solve this problem by rewriting state laws such that the incredible economic engine of the Permanent Fund will no longer be working for the people — it will be working for government.

In both plans, future dividends eventually lose value because they are tied to oil royalties. Sen. McGuire’s plan promises $1,000 from the general fund, but there are two problems with this idea. First, no statute can bind a future Legislature; and second, inflation will eventually destroy McGuire’s $1,000 payout. Given the same rate of inflation since the first dividend in 1982, a $1,000 dividend distributed 100 years from now will be worth $153, on its way toward zero with the passage of time.

Over the last three and a half decades, the legislative appropriation process has been conducted primarily as a tension between special interest lobbyists and the people’s elected representatives. The citizen’s one-person, one-vote relationship appears feeble compared to the daily interaction between lobbyist and legislator, where long-term friendships are cultivated through after-hours socializing and campaign contributions. There are clear winners in the creation of a budget under the pressure of political hard-bargaining. By contrast, the Permanent Fund Dividend promises everyone an equal share; there is no “privileged class.”

Both Gov. Walker’s plan and Sen. McGuire’s plan envision an endowment concept for budget stability. For example, in the governor’s plan, $3.3 billion in endowment funds is available each year for expenditure. The problem with this idea is that no real accountability will exist for this base level of spending. When legislators have to tax citizens to pay for government, someone “cares” how that money is spent — the taxpayer. The group that will care most about how endowment funds are spent are special interest lobbyists.

In the recent statewide Senate hearing, Alaskans strongly argued to preserve the Permanent Fund Dividend while cutting the budget. Most Alaskans favor a state income tax so it should be enacted now. About 45 percent of households nationwide pay no federal income tax, and so they also would pay no state tax. In order to spread the burden of paying for government expenses, a small state sales tax is almost certainly necessary. That way, all Alaskans and our visitors would share in paying for services.

The main effort must be to reduce the size of the state budget, but this is difficult and takes time to accomplish intelligently. To give the Legislature time, our dividends must be shared temporarily with government. Our Legislature presently has complete control over the dividend payout. They can fund a smaller dividend during this crisis and appropriate the remaining earnings to close the budget gap, giving us time to find ways to cut the budget.

Before we accept a slow death for the PFD under the proposed fiscal plans, we really need to reflect on what the dividend truly means. The Permanent Fund Dividend is a powerful idea, not just a check, and therein lies its greatness. The dividend idea is truly an Alaskan invention: that all future Alaskans share equally in one-time wealth creation. Just as the idea of democracy liberates the individual from powerlessness over governing his own life, the dividend idea liberates the individual, in a modest way, from controlled or no access to a share of the wealth inherent in our land and in our social contract. We live in a wealthy state; the dividend defines us as owners of this wealth.

The dividend concept is unique among modern societies; a grand experiment, one whose value we are only just beginning to comprehend. There are dozens of sovereign wealth funds in the world, but only one society, ours, has perfected the claim that all citizens deserve to share directly in their common wealth. We demonstrate by our example a deeply held respect for the inheritance right of this wealth for every generation.

Moreover, if you are concerned about inequality in modern society, the Permanent Fund Dividend might be the only curative solution that all of us can believe in regardless of political persuasion. We must not let this grand experiment disappear into history. Please support Sen. Bill Wielechowski’s resolution (SJR 1) to protect the dividend.

• Alexander Hoke is a 40-year Alaska resident, currently engaged in property management and construction. His work experience also includes legislative policy analyst, president of a Rural Electric Utility (GHEA) and service as a City and Borough of Juneau Assembly member.

More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

(Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: Alaskans should support Ocean Ranger program

Alaskans should be concerned that these floating cities could go unchecked.

Gavel (Courtesy photo)
Opinion: The foolish men claiming self-defense

By Rich Moniak A not guilty verdict “will not be a miscarriage… Continue reading

teaser
Opinion: Why giving is part of our Alaska way of life

GCI is encouraging our fellow Alaskans to offer a hand to our most vulnerable neighbors in need.

teaser
Opinion: Peeling the onion on Thanksgiving

“Peeling the onion” is an expression often used as a metaphor for… Continue reading

(Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: State defends its right to cut nonexistent taxes

By Larry Persily There is an inescapable irony to the fact that… Continue reading

teaser
Opinion: We’re on a road to ochlocracy

The conclusion of the Rittenhouse trial reminded us of the summer of 2020. It is a painful reminder.

Most Read