Moss covers old growth trees along Auke Lake on Thursday, Nov. 29, 2018. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

Moss covers old growth trees along Auke Lake on Thursday, Nov. 29, 2018. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

Review must be site-specific.

Forest Service environmental review process was insufficient, court says

A federal court ruled against a proposed timber sale on Prince of Wales Island, saying the U.S. Forest Service had failed to meet the review standards for the sale set but the National Environmental Protection Act.

Plaintiffs in the case argued the Forest Service failed to do the site-specific analysis required by NEPA in their Environmental Impact Statement. An Alaska District Court Judge Sharon Gleason agreed.

“NEPA requires that environmental analysis be specific enough to ensure informed decision making and meaningful public participation,” Gleason wrote in her opinion. “The Project EIS’s omission of the actual location of proposed timber harvest and road construction within the Project Area falls short of that mandate.”

The Forest Service’s sale used what they called “activity cards” for the different parcels that would eventually be auctioned. Those cards gave details on the various activities that could take place on a particular parcel. But those cards did not identify the exact areas which would be impacted, plaintiffs argued, and thus the Forest Service’s review of potential impacts was insufficient.

[Prince of Wales timber sale goes to court]

Plaintiffs in the case were Juneau-based environmental group Southeast Alaska Conservation Council who were represented by lawyers from environmentally focused nonprofit law firm Earthjustice.

At a Feb. 7, hearing in the Robert Boochever U.S. Courthouse at the Hurff Ackerman Saunders Federal Building in downtown Juneau, Earthjustice lawyer Tom Waldo argued the use of activity cards was both insufficient and would create and dangerous precedent for environmental review.

“The EIS doesn’t disclose the location of any timber sale or any roads to be logged over the next 15 years on Prince of Wales Island, and that is completely inadequate for an EIS. No court has ever upheld an EIS with so little detail,” Waldo told reporters following the hearing.

Erika Norman, trial attorney with the U.S. Department of Justice representing the Forest Service argued the review process for the activity cards was thorough and rigorous.

“The Forest Service has analyzed the overall plan for the project, they have analyzed every logging scenario that could be implemented,” Norman said.

But the court disagreed.

“The Forest Service contends that the EIS provides the specificity required by NEPA because it identifies potential areas of harvest within the project area,” Gleason wrote. “Here, the Project EIS does not identify individual harvest units; by only identifying broad areas within which harvest may occur, it does not fully explain to the public how or where actual timber activities will affect localized habitats.”

SEACC had argued the activity cards had circumvented public input by not designating exactly where timber harvest would take place. In a statement, SEACC Executive Director Meredith Trainor said the process should not be a “guessing game.”

“Today’s court decision upholds the rights of Southeast Alaskans to weigh in on where logging happens not once our lands are changed forever,” she said.

Paul Robbins, Forest Service public affairs officer for the Tongass National Forest declined to comment as the litigation was still ongoing.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture, which oversees the Forest Service, did not immediately respond to request for comment.

• Contact reporter Peter Segall at 523-2228 or psegall@juneauempire.com.

More in News

The Norwegian Bliss arrives in Juneau on Monday, April 14, 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire file photo)
Ships in port for the week of May 12

This information comes from the Cruise Line Agencies of Alaska’s 2024 schedule.… Continue reading

Juneau Assembly members hear a report from Eaglecrest Ski Area leaders during a Finance Committee meeting on Wednesday, May 14, 2025, at City Hall. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Juneau Assembly taking on pretty much the entire town with 59-item agenda Monday night

Items include mutitude of projects, faster release of police bodycams, stopping Mendenhall Glacier from being sold.

The Alaska House of Representatives is seen in action on Monday, May 5, 2025. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
Republican opposition kills bill intended to fix Alaska’s absentee voting problems

Senate Bill 64 passed the Senate this week, but the House doesn’t have enough time to address it, legislators said.

Fu Bao Hartle (center), a Juneau Special Olympics athlete, crosses a bridge with family and supporters during the annual Alaska Law Enforcement Torch Run on Saturday, May 17, 2025. (Ellie Ruel / Juneau Empire)
Community spirit shines at Juneau’s Law Enforcement Torch Run for Special Olympics

Energy was high at race to fundraise to send Juneau’s athletes to Anchorage Summer Games.

The Alaska State Capitol is seen behind a curtain of blooming branches on Saturday, May 17, 2025. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
Most state services will see no new funding in final Alaska state budget draft

Flat funding, combined with inflation, will mean service cuts in many places across the state.

Steve Whitney (left) is sworn in as a Juneau Board of Education member by Superior Court Judge Amy Mead in the library at Thunder Mountain Middle School on Saturday, May 17, 2025, after five candidates were interviewed by the other board members to fill the seat vacated when Will Muldoon resigned last month. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Steve Whitney returns to Juneau school board six years after departure to temporarily fill vacant seat

Fisheries manager and parent selected from among five candidates to serve until October’s election.

A used gondola purchased from an Austrian ski resort is seen as the key to Eaglecrest Ski Area’s year-round operations and a secure financial future. (Eaglecrest Ski Area photo)
Board chair: Eaglecrest’s gondola pushing limits of 2028 completion deadline under Goldbelt agreement

Company can nix $10M deal if work not finished on project ski area calls vital to its financial future.

Two spawning pink salmon head upstream in shallow water in Cove Creek in Whittier on Aug. 5, 2024. While last year’s pink salmon runs and harvests were weak, big increases are expected this year. (Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon)
Alaska officials forecast improvements for the state’s commercial salmon harvest

Total catch is projected to be twice the size of last year’s weak harvest.

Juneau law enforcement officers stand in formation while Alaska Wildlife Trooper Sgt. Branden Forst reads the names of Southeast Alaska’s fallen officers on Friday, May 16, 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire)
Fallen officers remembered in annual ceremony during National Police Week

Memorial recognizes their sacrifice and the highest officer assault rate in the past decade.

Most Read