Former Alaska Gov. Frank Murkowski is traveling the state at the request of current Gov. Bill Walker to promote a railway connecting Alaska to Canadian rails. Murkowski is holding a Rails to Resources informational packet his office produced in June 2000 when he was a U.S. Senator for Alaska. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire)

Frank Murkowski tries to revive dream of rail link to Canada

Frank Murkowski has never lost his railroad dream. Now, he has another chance to make it reality.

In March, the former governor and U.S. Senator signed an agreement with Gov. Bill Walker to serve as a “special envoy” charged with finding a way to build a rail link between Alaska and the Canadian rail system.

Murkowski said he doesn’t have a timeline for finishing his investigation.

Murkowski will be unpaid in this job, and he doesn’t get state benefits, but the state will reimburse him for pre-approved travel and expenses.

On Tuesday, Murkowski spoke to the Empire, accompanied by his son Brian and former chief of staff Jim Clark.

As Brian unrolled a map of the Arctic, Murkowski explained the challenge.

The easternmost end of the Alaska Railroad is 38 miles short of Delta Junction, which itself is 220 miles from the Canadian border. That border is another 800 miles distant from Fort Nelson, the northern end of BC Rail.

“If the economics aren’t favorable, you’ve got a fairly significant problem,” he said.

With the state facing a multibillion-dollar annual deficit and the Alaska Railroad operating at a loss, any rail extension has to pay for itself. The state (or Alaska Railroad) could borrow the money for construction, but the new line would have to pay that money back.

“This thing isn’t going to happen unless there’s a way to amortize the cost,” Murkowski said. “If there is, there’s the possibility that capital will come in.”

To do that, Murkowski needs to find enough shippers willing to pay fees for using the railroad. That means finding mines, cargo companies and oil companies that would use the line.

“I’m not interested in running a railroad, I’m not interested in a route. I’m interested in – can we identify the economic viability?” Murkowski said.

That’s not an easy task: It’s one that has bedeviled every Alaska-Canada railroad proposal, and it’s one that Murkowski has failed to solve before.

The records of the 1899 Harriman Expedition include discussion of a railroad to Alaska, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers studied the idea during World War II, surveying a route from Prince George to Port Clarence at the western end of the Seward Peninsula.

A railroad was examined during the trans-Alaska Pipeline System boom, then again in the 1980s when the state was flush with money.

As a U.S. Senator, Murkowski encouraged the idea of an Alaska-Canada railroad, guiding a Rails to Resources Act through Congress. Signed by President Clinton, that act would have formed a commission to develop the idea, but Canada balked.

After Murkowski became governor, Alaska joined with the government of the Yukon to study the concept. The study, completed in 2006, found that linking Alaska to the Canadian rail system would cost about $11 billion but would generate $170 billion in economic development.

Last year, an Alberta-funded study indicated Alaska could be a railroad route for tar sands mined from that Canadian province, but linking Alberta to Alaska would cost between $28 billion and $34 billion (2016 Canadian dollars).

The state’s current rail plan, in draft form, quotes a 2007 feasibility study that determined a Canadian rail link “was not economically feasible and would not create enough revenue to support the project’s cost.”

Speaking to the Empire, Murkowski said he feels the project is worth a second look. New technology could change the costs and economics, and in 2007, the Alberta tar sands weren’t as developed as they are today.

“Maybe now, with technology and a couple of other factors, you could find enough tonnage,” he said.


Contact reporter James Brooks at james.k.brooks@juneauempire.com or call 419-7732.


More in News

A sign on a city bus urges the use of face coverings, but following an ordinance passed by the City and Borough of Juneau Assembly, all passengers will now be required to wear masks on buses and while using other city facilities. Friday, May 29, 2020. (Peter Segall | Juneau Empire)
Face coverings now required on buses, in city facilities

Masks will be provided for those who cannot afford them.

Juneau City Hall on Monday, March 30, 2020. (Peter Segall | Juneau Empire)
Finance committee votes to hold line on property tax

“Projects will still go on. Services will still go on.”

Police calls for Friday, May 29, 2020

This report contains public information available to the Empire from law enforcement… Continue reading

Police calls for Thursday, May 28, 2020

This report contains public information available to the Empire from law enforcement… Continue reading

Police calls for Wednesday, May 27, 2020

This report contains public information available to the Empire from law enforcement… Continue reading

Michael S. Lockett | Juneau Empire 
                                Henry Williams runs from Douglas to the Mendenhall Valley on Memorial Day to honor dead service members, including his relative, Air Force Tech Sgt. Leslie Dominic Williams, who died in Afghanistan in 2011.
Memorial Day passes quietly amid coronavirus concerns, damp weather

People found their own ways to honor the hallowed dead.

Archie (center), Ella (left) and Arrow (right) enjoy the dog-friendly Field 2 in Melvin Park on April 26, 2020. The field, Dimond Park, and the grassy area on top of Gold Street are all closed to dogs indefinitely due to a rising amount of unremoved dog poop. (Ben Hohenstatt | Juneau Empire)
Poop piles pose problem for parks

Three areas are closed, and more may follow if behavior does not improve.

Most Read