Juneau Mayor Beth Weldon takes a photo of an interactive spreadsheet showing how adjusting sales tax and property tax rates can compensate for revenue lost if food is exempt from local sales taxes during a meeting of the Juneau Assembly’s Finance Committee on Wednesday. The committee rejected putting several variations of the food tax exemption on the fall municipal ballot, instead suggesting they may favor an advisory vote on the issue. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)

Food sales tax exemption stalls out —for now

Members of Juneau’s Assembly reject proposal for fall ballot, but residents may see advisory vote.

A proposed local sales tax exemption for food is dead — for now. Instead, Juneau residents may see an advisory vote in the Oct. 4 municipal election asking if they favor the exemption in exchange for raising sales taxes on other items or increasing property taxes.

A long and contentious debate in recent months about exempting non-prepared foods from the city’s 5% sales tax, which advocates say will help low-income residents, effectively ending the possibility of such a policy in the immediate future during the Juneau Assembly’s Finance Committee meeting Wednesday.

Exempting food from sales taxes means the city would need to make up for about $6 million in lost revenue. Committee members disagreed sharply about their preference among a trio of options: boosting the sales tax to 6% during summer months, a year-round 5.5% sales tax, or a 1 mill property tax increase.

Ultimately the answer was none of the above — at least until there’s a better sense of what voters prefer.

“Just hearing the Assembly members talk I think we’re pretty divided on this,” said Mayor Beth Weldon, who floated the idea of an advisory vote early during the evening’s two-hour discussion. “I think we’re all looking for a clearer answer.”

Part of the stalemate was due to the various proposals being more, or less, attractive than they appear at first glance due to complexities that could result in consequences beyond those intended.

[Food sales tax exemption likely to appear on municipal ballots]

Increasing sales taxes on non-food items during a six-month period from April through September is seen as a way of putting some of the burden on tourists, for example, but opponents said it will significantly hurt local businesses not catering to tourists during those months.

“I’m so opposed to this I would not even support this on an advisory vote,” said Assembly member Wade Bryson, who has been the strongest voice opposing the seasonal sales tax hike during this year’s discussions.

Significant opposition has also been expressed by numerous business owners and the Greater Juneau Chamber of Commerce, whose additional arguments are targeting tourists is unfair since they drive much of the local summer economy and changing point-of-sale systems twice a year can be more complex than people realize, City Finance Director Jeff Rogers wrote in a memo to Finance Committee members.

A major problem with a year-round 5.5% sales tax is it wouldn’t generate nearly enough to cover the loss of food taxes — to avoid a deficit a 5.7% year-round rate would have to be imposed, Rogers noted.

On the other hand, a 1 mill increase in the current 10.56 mill property tax rate — which means the owner of a $500,000 home would pay $500 more a year in taxes — might seem politically and practically undesirable, especially given recent skyrocketing property values. But arguments in favor, led by Assembly member Alicia Hughes-Skandijs, assert it’s actually the fairest approach if the goal of a food-tax exemption is helping those with lower incomes since the burden is shifted to property owners relative to their presumed wealth.

“My only lament was not being more open to the idea,” Assembly member Greg Smith said after proponents of the mill rate hike made their case. “I guess a big issue for me is it would be really quick acting and we would be making this choice in two weeks (to get it on the ballot in time), and not getting a chance to hear from the public. I think it’s too quick to do it this year.”

Several Assembly members also express concern about the food tax exemption – especially if paid for with some form of sales tax increase – appearing on the same ballot this fall as an extension of a “temporary” 1% sales tax that’s been in place since the early 1990s as voters have renewed it roughly every five years. Bryson noted residents may also be asked to approve a bond to pay for a new City Hall on the same ballot.

“If we ask those major questions and then ask the (food-related) sales tax questions we’re setting ourselves up for failure,” he said.

Motions to move forward in the process of putting the seasonal taxes tax and year-round sales tax on the fall ballot — which would first require approval by the full Assembly after a public hearing — both failed by 5-4 votes. Opposing the seasonal sales tax were Weldon, Bryson, Hughes-Skandijs, Assembly member Carole Triem and Assembly member Michelle Hale. Opposing the year-round increase were Hughes-Skandijs, Triem, Assembly member Maria Gladziszewski, Assembly member Wáahlaal Gíidaak Barbara Blake and Assembly member Christine Woll.

Both options could still appear as advisory questions on the fall ballot. In addition, a motion to keep the mill tax rate increase option as a possibility when discussing an advisory vote was unanimously approved by the committee.

Weldon, in proposing the advisory vote, said she isn’t personally taking a stance on exempting food from sales tax and “I understand the argument on both sides.” But she doesn’t consider it unreasonable to wait a year before again considering concrete action so city leaders have a better sense of what the people who elected them want.

“I’m not trying to squash anything,” she said. “I’ve stood out of the way because I know it’s important to several members of the Assembly. Like our housing dilemma I’m just trying to find a clearer answer.”

• Reach Mark Sabbatini at mark.sabbatini@juneauempire.com

More in News

Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File
The Aurora Borealis glows over the Mendenhall Glacier in 2014.
Aurora Forecast

Forecasts from the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute for the week of March. 19

Gov. Mike Dunleavy discusses his proposed budget for the 2024 fiscal year during a press conference at the Alaska State Capitol in December 2022. A lower-than-expected revenue forecast is raising questions about what the state's spending plan will ultimately look like. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire File)
Lower revenue forecast increases budget woes for state lawmakers

Coming up with a spending plan for next year and beyond will be a complex series of negotiations.

Office Max at the Nugget Mall in the Mendenhall Valley advertised Permanent Fund dividend sales in July 2020. Alaskans have until the end of the month to apply for the PFD. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)
PFD application deadline is next week

Amount in flux as state revenue forecasts lower than expected.

This is a photo of the current site plan of the proposed Capital Civic Center. On Monday night the Assembly authorized $5 million to go toward the project that is expected to cost $75 million. (City and Borough of Juneau)
City OKs $5M toward proposed Capital Civic Center

The money is intended to show the city’s commitment to the project as it seeks federal funding

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Tuesday, March 21, 2023

This report contains information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

This September 2015, photo provided by NOAA Fisheries shows an aerial view of adult female Southern Resident killer whale (J16) swimming with her calf (J50). New research suggests that inbreeding may be a key reason that the Pacific Northwest’s endangered population of killer whales has failed to recover despite decades of conservation efforts. The so-called “southern resident” population of orcas stands at 73 whales. That’s just two more than in 1971, after scores of the whales were captured for display in marine theme parks around the world. (NOAA Fisheries / Vancouver Aquarium)
The big problem for endangered orcas? Inbreeding

Southern resident killer whales haven’t regularly interbred with other populations in 30 generations.

Juneau Brass Quintet co-founding member Bill Paulick along with Stephen Young performs “Shepherd’s Hey” to a packed house at the Alaska State Museum on Saturday as part of the quintet’s season-ending performance. Friends of the Alaska State Library, Archives and Museum sponsored the event with proceeds going to the musicians and FoSLAM. (Jonson Kuhn / Juneau Empire)
Top brass turns out for event at State Museum

Free performance puts a capt on a busy season.

Alaska’s state legislators are slated to get the equivalent of 6,720 additional $5 bills in their salary next year via a $33,600 raise to a total of $84,000 due to a veto Monday by Gov. Mike Dunleavy of bill rejecting raises for legislative and executive branch employees. (AP Photo/Ted Shaffrey, File)
Veto negates rejection of pay hikes for governor, legislators

Dunleavy clears way for 67% hike in legislative pay, 20% in his to take effect in coming months

Most Read