Eric Forrer, left, and Joe Geldhof, right, have sued the state of Alaska in an attempt to stop a plan that calls for borrowing up to $1 billion from global bond markets to pay oil and gas tax credits owed by the state. They are pictured May 22, 2018 in an interview at the Juneau Empire. (James Brooks | Juneau Empire)

Eric Forrer, left, and Joe Geldhof, right, have sued the state of Alaska in an attempt to stop a plan that calls for borrowing up to $1 billion from global bond markets to pay oil and gas tax credits owed by the state. They are pictured May 22, 2018 in an interview at the Juneau Empire. (James Brooks | Juneau Empire)

Opinion: Why the judge was wrong in throwing out my lawsuit on state debt

We are watching the abhorrence of debt.

In May 2018, I filed a lawsuit alleging that House Bill 331 is unconstitutional, in that it authorizes $1 billion of bonded debt by the State of Alaska, in violation of the constitutional restrictions on debt.

Earlier this month, Superior Court Judge Jude Pate upheld the state’s motion to dismiss the suit. This decision was described in a closely reasoned 44-page opinion. The judge relies on a number of precedent opinions from cases in the record, as well as an overarching theme of similar cases of state debt as practiced and adjudicated nationwide.

This conflict is playing out on at least three levels. One is the interpretation of the law as tracked through previous cases. A second is the public policy as expressed by the action of the Legislature and the long-term consequences of HB 331. (In a full page of his opinion, Judge Pate forthrightly acknowledges these issues.) A third is the organization of government and the way it works. The newspaper is not the place to argue the merits of Pate’s legal pathway. However, this is a constitutional case and there are several points to be made:

Pate states: “… it is not the role of this court to make economic policy judgments or second guess the wisdom of the legislature’s financial decisions …”

[Why two Juneau men are standing in the way of the Legislature, Gov. Walker and a billion-dollar debt]

In the definition of the three branches of government, I find:

“The courts, given the sole power to interpret the Constitution and the laws, can uphold or overturn acts of the Legislature … this is part of their relationship of checks and balances …”

I therefore find that Pate has abdicated the primary role of the judicial branch of which he is a stellar part. If the judicial branch doesn’t have the power to stop the Legislature from creating unconstitutional law, why would there ever be a constitutional challenge, of which there have been many? On his first page, the judge is telling us he won’t use the power on which this case depends.

As far as “legislative wisdom” is concerned, the Legislature has no wisdom. What the Legislature has is ideologically driven political power subject to the winds of chance. In the search for wisdom, I pray to find some of it residing with the judiciary.

[Volatile oil market prompts conservative forecasts]

A second piece of the puzzle of having this case dismissed is that it was dismissed based on something called Civil Rule 12(B)(6). This one is simple, and states that a case can be dismissed if the plaintiff “fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.” Since the relief requested was clearly spelled out, the state’s success in using a transparently inapplicable rule remains a mystery.

In this vein, Pate applied what feels very much like a double standard of accepting testimony from the parties. He accepted everything supplied by the state in support of its motion to dismiss. But because it was not yet a trial or a motion for judgment, the judge declined to accept much of the evidence I supplied. Pate sailed past the notion of dismissal, went on ahead to make a constitutional determination on the merits, and then got back to the dismissal with logic that has nothing at all to do with a “failure to state relief.” It is essentially impossible to track this pathway.

In defending HB331 and deciding that the debt it allows is not “state debt” and “passes constitutional muster,” language and debt structures are used that did not exist at the time the constitution was written. One of the points of this case is that the authors of the constitution could not describe things they had never heard of as unconstitutional. In allowing this debt structure to be defined as constitutional, Judge Pate has essentially set himself up as a committee-of-one, and written a constitutional amendment that flies in the face of acknowledged constitutional intent regarding debt.

We are watching the abhorrence of debt and the conservative fiscal stability intended by the framers be discarded by pubic guardians under the pressure of state budget stress, a situation that has been predicted for 30 years.


• Eric Forrer is a resident of Juneau. My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire.


More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

Pete Hegseth, President-elect Donald Trump’s nominee for defense secretary, at the Capitol in Washington on Monday, Dec. 2, 2024. Accusations of past misconduct have threatened his nomination from the start and Trump is weighing his options, even as Pete Hegseth meets with senators to muster support. (Kenny Holston/The New York Times)
Opinion: Sullivan plays make believe with America’s future

Two weeks ago, Sen. Dan Sullivan said Pete Hegseth was a “strong”… Continue reading

Dan Allard (right), a flood fighting expert for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, explains how Hesco barriers function at a table where miniature replicas of the three-foot square and four-foot high barriers are displayed during an open house Nov. 14 at Thunder Mountain Middle School to discuss flood prevention options in Juneau. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Our comfort with spectacle became a crisis

If I owned a home in the valley that was damaged by… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Voter fact left out of news

With all the post-election analysis, one fact has escaped much publicity. When… Continue reading

The site of the now-closed Tulsequah Chief mine. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Maybe the news is ‘No new news’ on Canada’s plans for Tulsequah Chief mine cleanup

In 2015, the British Columbia government committed to ending Tulsequah Chief’s pollution… Continue reading

The Alaska Psychiatric Institute in Anchorage. (Alaska Department of Family and Community Services photo)
My Turn: Rights for psychiatric patients must have state enforcement

Kim Kovol, commissioner of the state Department of Family and Community Services,… Continue reading

People living in areas affected by flooding from Suicide Basin pick up free sandbags on Oct. 20 at Thunder Mountain Middle School. (City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Opinion: Mired in bureaucracy, CBJ long-term flood fix advances at glacial pace

During meetings in Juneau last week, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE)… Continue reading

Rosa Parks, whose civil rights legacy has recent been subject to revision in class curriculums. (Public domain photo from the National Archives and Records Administration Records)
My Turn: Proud to be ‘woke’

Wokeness: the quality of being alert to and concerned about social injustice… Continue reading

The settlement of Sermiligaaq in Greenland (Ray Swi-hymn / CC BY-SA 2.0)
My Turn: Making the Arctic great again

It was just over five years ago, in the summer of 2019,… Continue reading

The Alaska Psychiatric Institute in Anchorage. (Alaska Department of Family and Community Services photo)
My Turn: Small wins make big impacts at Alaska Psychiatric Institute

The Alaska Psychiatric Institute (API), an 80-bed psychiatric hospital located in Anchorage… Continue reading

President Donald Trump and Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy pose for a photo aboard Air Force One during a stopover at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson in Anchorage in 2019. (Sheila Craighead / White House photo)
Opinion: Dunleavy has the prerequisite incompetence to work for Trump

On Tuesday it appeared that Gov. Mike Dunleavy was going to be… Continue reading