Opinion: Coeur’s ‘higher standard’

There is no responsible way to operate a sulfide mine in salmon habitat.

“We pursue a higher standard.”

That’s Coeur Alaska’s slogan, the owner/operator of Kensington Mine. Coeur’s “higher standard” recently led to them settling with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) over 200 wastewater discharge violations. Additional violations included unauthorized discharge of acid rock drainage into Lower Slate Lake, multiple effluent sampling violations, and failure to repair a fuel storage containment structure for over two years, among others. The EPA press release cited violations that can harm fish, smother eggs, erode stream banks, and result in streambank failure. Coeur settled for $534,500 — fines that amount to “cost of doing business.” Instead of requiring corrective action, ADEC simply changed Coeur’s permit to let them discharge acid rock drainage into Lower Slate Lake.

The problem lies not only with Coeur, but with state and federal regulatory processes that privilege mines over communities, salmon habitat and clean water. Mine discharge and waste management permits are set up to allow mines to legally pollute our waters, not to protect water quality. Look at the waste management permit ADEC recently issued to Constantine-Palmer VMS at the headwaters of the Chilkat River. At the very least, ADEC should require wastewater discharge to meet state water quality standards. Instead, they set “trigger limits” allowing Constantine to discharge water with elevated levels of heavy metals like copper and aluminum that harm salmon and human health. Constantine’s permit allows 70 micrograms of copper/liter. State water quality standards allow only 11.4. There is no responsible way to operate a sulfide mine in salmon habitat.

Shannon Donahue,


• My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire.