U.S. Rep. Don Young speaks during an interview at the Juneau Empire on Feb. 21, 2018. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

U.S. Rep. Don Young speaks during an interview at the Juneau Empire on Feb. 21, 2018. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

The MSA and Don Young’s partisan dilemma

Like the breakup of a marriage, there are two sides to this story.

“We must remain committed to the bipartisan, bicameral tradition of fisheries management,” Rep. Don Young wrote last Sunday, “and my legislation accomplishes just that.” He was referring to the reauthorization of Magnuson-Stevens Act. But when the House passed it on Wednesday, only nine Democrats voted in favor of it. Which explains why, in the same opinion piece, Young complained about “the hyper-partisan mentality” his “Democratic colleagues subscribe to.”

[Partisanship shouldn’t undermine our fisheries]

Like the breakup of a marriage, there are two sides to this story. The reason why Young is arguing from both might be that he was caught in the middle.

The original MSA is a landmark piece of legislation passed in 1976. Young says he authored it and worked with Alaska’s Ted Stevens and Warren Magnuson, a Washington State Democrat, to get it passed in the Senate. Its goal, as explained by Sam Cotton, Commissioner of the Alaska Department of Fish and Game, “is to get the most benefit from our fisheries for food and economic well-being while conserving ecosystem health and fish stocks for continued productivity to benefit future generations of fishing families and coastal communities.”

“Economic well-being” is a rightward leaning idea that “ecosystem health” attempts to balance from the left. Satisfying both demands in one complex regulation is no easy task.

Regulation is a key word in this dispute. Republicans today, including Young, are focused giving more authority to the states by reducing them on the federal side. That is, unless it’s one like the MSA that comes to the aid of their constituents. Those they salute, as Young did when he referred to the current law as a “true testament to how bipartisan efforts can improve policies that impact millions and affect our economy.”

When Young and Stevens collaborated with Magnuson four decades ago, they were almost entirely driven by economic concerns. Unregulated foreign fishing fleets were a serious threat to America’s commercial fishing industry. The law countered it by establishing an exclusive economic zone that extended 200 nautical miles out from our shores.

The MSA “worked so well that domestic fishing soon replaced foreign fleets in overexploiting U.S. fisheries” wrote Democrats on House Natural Resources Committee in the dissenting statement they attached to the committee’s report. “Everybody recognized the need to address the number of declining and collapsed fish stocks.”

That’s why there was bipartisan support for the 1996 Sustainable Fisheries Act. It amended the MSA to prevent overfishing, reduce unintended bycatch, rebuild depleted stocks and protect essential fish habitat. And in 2007 both sides agreed to require annual catch limits in all fisheries be science-based.

Title III of Young’s bill is “Healthy Fisheries Through Better Science.” But titles don’t establish policy. And in cases like climate change, Republicans don’t trust scientists if their findings aren’t compatible with the party’s vision of economic freedom.

That record lends credibility to the Democrats’ complaint that the flexibility the bill gives to fishery councils will allow them to make “politically-driven management decisions that hurt fishing communities in the long run.” And it may be why Republicans rejected amendments that Democrats claim would “ensure catch limits are based on sound science” and “integrate climate change considerations in fishery management.”

Young doesn’t mention any of these details in his opinion piece. And I wonder why. Because Democrats aren’t blaming him for what they see as the bill’s fatal flaws. He “agreed to work with Democratic Members and staff to develop a bipartisan bill” they wrote, but Rep. Rob Bishop, the committee chairman, “pulled the plug on promising negotiations and rushed to markup with a half-baked mashup of bad ideas that … deserves to be called the Empty Oceans Act.

That certainly sounds like the “partisan rancor” Young complained about. But perhaps he should be pointing his finger at Bishop instead of Democrats. The Utah representative arrived in Congress too late to appreciate the value of bipartisan cooperation. And that his state’s Great Salt Lake is indeed empty may be why the health of fish stocks in the ocean isn’t a priority for him or his constituents.

In any case, the bill is now headed to the senate where Sen. Lisa Murkowski’s chairs its Committee on Natural Resources. Alaska’s commercial fisheries are important to her. Maybe she’ll deliver a bipartisan version of the MSA reauthorization that Young really wants.


• Rich Moniak is a Juneau resident and retired civil engineer with more than 25 years of experience working in the public sector. He contributes a weekly “My Turn” to the Juneau Empire.


More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

Mist from Nugget Falls has a prism-like effect in September 2020. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire File)
Multiple vehicles line up at the entrance of Waste Management’s Capitol Disposal Landfill in Lemon Creek Monday morning. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)
The absence of economic incentives to reduce waste

This week, Waste Management, the Texas based company that owns and operates… Continue reading

Over 200 people attended LunaFest (Courtesy Photo)
Opinion: JPCC owes a huge debt of gratitude to two LunaFest guest speakers

LunaFest 2023 was JPCC’s most successful fundraising event ever.

(Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: Education funding is complicated and political

At a recent Alaska State Senate Education Committee hearing at the Capitol,… Continue reading

At Wednesday evening’s special Assembly meeting, the Assembly appropriated nearly $4 million toward funding a 5.5% wage increase for all CBJ employees along with a 5% increase to the employer health contribution. According to City Manager Rorie Watt, it doesn't necessarily fix a nearly two decade-long issue of employee retention concerns for the city. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)
Opinion: Assessment needs additional oversight

A win in dealing with City and Borough of Juneau is when… Continue reading

This photo shows the Mendenhall Glacier Visitor Center. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: Deja vu for the Mendenhall Glacier Recreation Area

Three new alternatives don’t go far enough.

In this Nov. 29, 2018 photo, clouds swirl over Douglas Island. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: The Roadless Rule is a misnomer for what’s really happening in the Tongass

The Roadless Rule, as currently comprised with an exception provision, works.

Faith Myers stands at the doors of API. (Courtesy Photo)
Opinion: Psychiatric patient care report could be catalyst for improvements

Will good suggestions get lost in state bureaucracy?

Most Read