The dangers of a three-way race for governor

The dangers of a three-way race for governor

I was hoping to write this week to thank you for letting me represent you this past decade and a half. It’s been a privilege to work with you, and try to make people’s lives a little bit better, one step at a time. But today I’m concerned about what I consider a risky three-way governor’s race that might have devastating ramifications for all of us. Strong public schools, the opportunity to succeed, the right to live and age with dignity, and the right to safety in Alaska’s large and small communities should be the Alaska promise. I believe that promise is at risk this election.

Today the leading candidate has a record of voting against this basic promise, and especially the promise of good public schools so this generation of children and youth can have a fair chance in this world. That’s the future we risk if the majority of Alaskans split their votes between Gov. Bill Walker and former Sen. Mark Begich.

Both the governor and Mark are good men. Despite some attack rhetoric, both men are different shades of moderate. That’s where most Alaskans are. I respect, like, and have worked with both of them. I agree with them on many issues, and disagree with them on others. But each would honor the basic Alaska promise of opportunity and dignity for Alaskans young and older.

In a three-way race, polls show most voters — Independents, Democrats, and moderate and mainstream Republicans — currently split their support between these two men. That split could pave the way for a much more extreme candidate to win the governor’s race with 40 percent or less of the vote.

I’ve heard concern about this from many Alaskans of different political stripes. It should be talked about before we head too far along this path. A respectful public dialogue would serve us well, and I hope the governor and Mark will talk, as they have over the past year, to seek a resolution that’s good for the state.

I don’t mind stating what I believe even if it puts me at odds with some in my party, though in line with many Alaskans of all parties. I say this as someone who’s volunteered and worked hard to help elect good candidates, and helped build our current House bipartisan majority, whose members have worked well together across party lines. Volunteering to work for good election results matters more to me than toeing a party line.

If you quizzed the governor and Mark you’d find individual positions where each is more conservative or moderate than the other. You should do that. But in my view this election isn’t simply about who I agree with most. I don’t see a lot of upside in talking much about which candidate I want to finish in second place and which should finish third, if it’s behind a candidate with extreme views that are contrary to most of our values.

So, how will this end?

Walker and Begich will likely be told to play with fire as they battle for many of the same voters. The most likely way either can win in a three-way race is to personally, or have someone else, attack the other, hoping one will fall in the polls and drop out. That might work, or it might damage both as they stagger, with arrows in their backs, to a second and third place finish. I’d applaud the candidates who do not go down that road.

This leaves me with the final point — why I feel Alaska will suffer if the currently leading candidate wins.

My life has taught me that people deserve opportunity and dignity in life, whether or not they are born to privilege and wealth. But as Senate Education Budget Subcommittee Chair, Mike Dunleavy voted to eliminate all state funded pre-kindergarten for Alaska’s children, threatening the ability of children to achieve (he couldn’t eliminate federal Head Start, which covers a fraction of youth eligible for pre-K). He was proudly vocal in voting for an additional $65 million in harmful cuts to K-12 public education in 2017 — when students have already lost hundreds of needed teachers, counselors and educators. Our House Bipartisan Majority Coalition worked to reverse his attempted education cuts. We were also successful in reversing his votes to cut basic disability, senior, and children’s services.

Republicans, Democrats and Independents have cut $3.4 billion from the budget since 2013. Cutting waste or luxury is smart. Cutting opportunity and dignity with a cleaver isn’t. Whatever our differences, we’re a state that believes in opportunity and dignity. These things are threatened, I believe, unless we engage in a positive dialogue on the wisdom of a three-way race.

• Rep. Les Gara has been a member of the House of Representatives since 2003, and has chosen not to run for re-election this year.

More in Opinion

Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: JDHS is a much better facility for high school students

The Douglas Bridge was completed in 1935, unifying our community in more… Continue reading

The Alaska State Capitol. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire file photo)
My Turn: Defined benefits and economic freedom for state workers

I moved to Alaska 12 years ago. The allure of the Last… Continue reading

Alaska Permanent Fund Corp. board members, staff and advisors meet Monday, Oct. 30, 2023, at the corporation’s headquarters in Juneau. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Risky business not the state’s business

The advice for Las Vegas gamblers is don’t bet more than you… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: JDHS was the high school during stable times; keep it that way if consolidation occurs

In order to financially maintain the high quality of education, tradition and… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Legislature needs to rein in Dunleavy’s power-grab

It’s not surprising to witness so many Republican politicians who’ve been capitulating… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Alaskans favoring secession aren’t thinking things through

I live in Virginia and have no firsthand experience with Alaskan affairs.… Continue reading

An overhead view of Telephone Hill in downtown Juneau. (Photo courtesy of the City and Borough of Juneau)
My Turn: Redevelop our government, not our history with Telephone Hill

At the last Committee of the Whole (COW) meeting, the Juneau Assembly… Continue reading

Joe Orsi (left) and Sam Bertoni stand next to a 3,000-plus garlic bulb harvest in Juneau in late summer of 2023. (Photo courtesy of Joe Orsi)
My Turn: Moving the needle forward for Alaskan agriculture and local food security

As a follow-up to a recent “My Turn” article in the Juneau… Continue reading

Most Read