Report: Short review didn’t compromise lease sale

ANCHORAGE — A federal agency rushed through an environmental review of an Alaska offshore petroleum lease sale at the insistence of high-level managers but did not compromise its quality, a federal reviewer has concluded.

The Office of the Inspector General, which investigates fraud, abuse and misconduct, concluded that managers edited an environmental review of the 2008 Chukchi Sea lease sale and established an “expedited timeline” for its completion by an Interior Department agency.

The Environmental Protection Agency, however, concluded that the review contained adequate scientific information, according to the report. And the short timeframe for the review, ordered by Interior Department chief of staff Tommy Beaudreau, was put in place to protect the Interior Department from blame if Royal Dutch Shell PLC had decided it could not drill exploratory wells on its Chukchi leases in 2015, he told inspectors.

The report outlines factors faced by the federal Bureau of Ocean Energy Management in completing the sale for federal offshore drilling. Alaska officials seeking more oil for the trans-Alaska pipeline strongly support offshore drilling. Drilling is bitterly opposed by environmental groups that say a spill would devastate a fragile marine environment that’s home to polar bears, walrus, endangered whales and the Native Alaskans who rely on them.

The 2008 Chukchi lease sale was scheduled in the waning days of the administration of George W. Bush. It generated $2.6 billion in high bids, including $2.1 billion from Shell, which eventually would spend upward of $7 billion in the Arctic before it drilled into petroleum-bearing rock this summer.

Environmental and Alaska Native groups successfully sued over the inadequacy of the sale’s first environmental review. A federal court judge ordered a supplemental review.

A complaint by an Alaska regional environmental officer for a BOEM sister agency, the Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement, led to the Inspector General report.

The unnamed complainant alleged scientific findings in the second review were manipulated for political purposes. The complainant also said upper level management set a short timeline for the review to benefit the oil and gas industry and that the Interior Department intended to sign off on the review, allowing drilling to proceed, even before the review was completed.

BOEM employees told investigators the environmental review was rushed and dozens of hours of extra time had to be worked to meet the short deadline. Some employees quit or retired because they concluded their work had been compromised.

Beaudreau was head of BOEM before he was promoted to be chief of staff for Interior Secretary Sally Jewell. Other environmental reviews have taken two years or more but Beaudreau proposed in May 2014 that the supplemental review of the Chukchi sale be completed by February 2015 and a record of decision issued in March 2015. He overruled agency officials who said it could not be done that fast and offered to pay overtime or bring in employees from elsewhere to complete the job.

Beaudreau told investigators he set an aggressive timeline that would allow Shell to drill during the short 2015 open water season because the federal judge in the case expected it and could impose his own.

He said Alaska’s congressional delegation, including U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, would criticize BOEM if the environmental review was not done in a timely manner. He also said Shell could use BOEM as a scapegoat for its own failures if the company decided not to drill in 2015.

The review ultimately was accepted in the short timeframe. Shell drilled in 2015, found little oil and announced it was pulling out of the U.S. Arctic for the immediate future.

Erik Grafe, an Earthjustice attorney who worked on the challenge to the original review, said the report confirms that federal environmental review of the sale was flawed.

“The report emphatically confirms that the Bureau rushed its environmental review of the Chukchi Sea lease sale in order to allow for possible drilling in 2015 and that agency scientists and managers concluded they could not adequately do their review on this short timeframe,” he said by email. “Scientists could not engage in basic review of their work or peer review of other’s work; managers were concerned that legal requirements were not being met. It went so far that staff felt forced to end their careers at the agency because the agency wasn’t allowing them to conduct defensible science.”

It’s not surprising, he said, that the environmental review is now the subject of a lawsuit.

More in News

The Aurora Borealis glows over the Mendenhall Glacier in 2014. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Aurora forecast

Forecasts from the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute for the week of Nov. 27

Mountain reflections are seen from the Mendenhall Wetlands. (Courtesy Photo / Denise Carroll)
Wild Shots: Photos of Mother Nature in Alaska

Superb reader-submitted photos of wildlife, scenery and/or plant life.

Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire 
At Wednesday evening’s special Assembly meeting, the Assembly appropriated nearly $4 million toward funding a 5.5% wage increase for all CBJ employees along with a 5% increase to the employer health contribution. According to City Manager Rorie Watt, it doesn’t necessarily fix a nearly two decade-long issue of employee retention concerns for the city.
City funds wage increase amid worker shortage

City Manager says raise doesn’t fix nearly two decade-long issue of employee retainment

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Saturday, Dec. 3

This report contains information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Molly Yazwinski holds a 3,000-year-old moose skull with antlers still attached, found in a river on Alaska’s North Slope. Her aunt, Pam Groves, steadies an inflatable canoe. (Courtesy Photo /Dan Mann)


2. A 14,000-year-old fragment of a moose antler, top left, rests on a sand bar of a northern river next to the bones of ice-age horses, caribou and muskoxen, as well as the horns of a steppe bison. Photo by Pam Groves.


3. Moose such as this one, photographed this year near Whitehorse in the Yukon, may have been present in Alaska as long as people have. Photo by Ned Rozell.
Alaska Science Forum: Ancient moose antlers hint of early arrival

When a great deal of Earth’s water was locked up within mountains… Continue reading

FILE - Freight train cars sit in a Norfolk Southern rail yard on Sept. 14, 2022, in Atlanta. The Biden administration is saying the U.S. economy would face a severe economic shock if senators don't pass legislation this week to avert a rail worker strike. The administration is delivering that message personally to Democratic senators in a closed-door session Thursday, Dec. 1.  (AP Photo / Danny Karnik)
Congress votes to avert rail strike amid dire warnings

President vows to quickly sign the bill.

Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire
Juneau state Sen. Jesse Kiehl, left, gives a legislative proclamation to former longtime Juneau Assembly member Loren Jones, following Kiehl’s speech at the Juneau Chamber of Commerce’s weekly luncheon Thursday at the Juneau Moose Family Center.
Cloudy economy, but sunnier political outlook lie ahead for lawmakers, Kiehl says

Juneau’s state senator tells Chamber of Commerce bipartisan majority a key to meaningful action

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Friday, Dec. 2

This report contains information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Alaska State Troopers logo.
Hunter credits community members for Thanksgiving rescue

KENAI — On Thanksgiving, Alaska Wildlife Troopers released a dispatch about a… Continue reading

Most Read