Carla Casulucan, shareholder relations manager for Huna Totem, gives public testimony Monday night in support of the Huna Totem development and urged the city to vote against an ordinance that would have allowed the city to spend $300,000 to help plan the location of a proposed cruise ship dock at the downtown subport. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)

Carla Casulucan, shareholder relations manager for Huna Totem, gives public testimony Monday night in support of the Huna Totem development and urged the city to vote against an ordinance that would have allowed the city to spend $300,000 to help plan the location of a proposed cruise ship dock at the downtown subport. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)

City decides against spending on cruise ship dock planning

Assembly votes down ordinance after more than a dozen public comments against it.

This article has been updated to clarify that Carla Casulucan’s testimony was given strictly in her capacity as a Juneau resident.

The city Assembly on Monday voted against an ordinance that would have allowed the city to spend $300,000 to help plan the location of a proposed cruise ship dock at the downtown subport.

After it was announced in August that Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings had donated the waterfront property in Juneau that it purchased in 2019 for $20 million to Huna Totem Corp., the Alaska Native corporation has sought to get its proposed cruise ship dock and waterfront development into fruition.

At Monday night’s Assembly meeting, more than a dozen members of the public provided testimony mainly in opposition to the ordinance, and in a late-night decision after multiple failed motions and amendments, the ordinance was voted down by Juneau Assembly members Carole Triem, Waahlaal Giidaak Barbara Blake, Alicia Hughes-Skandijs, Wade Bryson and Michelle Bonnet Hale.

They outnumbered Assembly members Maria Gladziszewski, Greg Smith and Mayor Beth Weldon who voted in favor of passing the ordinance. Assembly member Christine Woll was not present at the meeting.

Assembly member Wade Bryson discusses the whether the Assembly should vote in favor or against an ordinance that would have allowed the city to spend $300,000 to help plan the location of a proposed cruise ship dock at the downtown subport. Bryson was one of the five Assembly members who voted down the ordinance. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)

Assembly member Wade Bryson discusses the whether the Assembly should vote in favor or against an ordinance that would have allowed the city to spend $300,000 to help plan the location of a proposed cruise ship dock at the downtown subport. Bryson was one of the five Assembly members who voted down the ordinance. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)

According to the proposed master plan, the city’s involvement and the $300,000 appropriation from marine passenger fees would have gone toward funding preliminary engineering and planning consultation services through CBJ to “ensure competing interests are synchronized” and enable “CBJ decision makers to expand economic opportunities while balancing local priorities.”

Nearly all public comments — including from Huna Totem officials, project architects, private developers and Greater Juneau Chamber of Commerce officials — said the city’s efforts would be redundant to the typical permitting process and delay Huna Totem’s project timeline. Many called it an overreach of private development.

“CBJ doing its own partial study of the port is duplicative to what the private developer is already doing,” said John Blasco, president of the Greater Juneau Chamber of Commerce. He said he represents the chamber that collectively opposed the ordinance because it could delay the fiscal benefits that could be made from the development of the subport.

Carla Casulucan, a Juneau resident, shareholder relations manager for Huna Totem and past member of the CBJ Systemic Racism Review Committee Member, also offered testimony. Casulucan specified her testimony was strictly in her capacity as a resident of Juneau.

She said she supports the Huna Totem development and expressed disappointment toward city officials who she said have been critical or “wishy-washy” of the development and said she feels CBJ has placed a level of scrutiny on Alaska Native corporations’ development that goes beyond the other waterfront developments.

“Through 100% private investment this development stands to enhance the beauty of downtown and serve to complement the efforts of Sealaska and Alaska Heritage Institute to indigenize the true aesthetic of the Juneau area,” she said. “Your constant adversarial stance on this project with ‘do it my way or else’ tactics is just another variation of the systematic racism that has been pitted against us here.”

Each member of the Assembly spoke about the project which varied in support and opposition to the city planning. Hughes-Skandijs said it should be noted that the city’s goals and interests for the project and its timeline is going to be different from private developers regardless of the developer.

“It is our job to be concerned about the best and highest use of the city property and whether all the interests of everyone in the city is being represented — that is always going to be based on and coming from a different place than a private developer,” she said.

An initial motion to vote down the ordinance failed with an even split of votes among the Assembly members. Following the failed motion the Assembly voted on amendments, including making the study area smaller and requiring the new cruise ship dock planning to be done within three months, but ultimately the ordinance as a whole was voted down.

City Manager Rorie Watt told the Empire the decision is just another step in the public process. He emphasized that there is still much public process that needs to happen. That process, Watt said, includes approval by the Assembly and negotiations and an agreement with the U.S. Coast Guard and possiblythe National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration before it can begin development. He said Huna Totem has submitted an application for a conditional use permit and the planning commission will likely review it this spring.

“Democracy is messy and trying to weigh conflicting interests isn’t easy, we joke that all the easy decisions have already been made,” he said. “My position was the public would have benefited from a broader perspective, and I think Huna Totems’ perspective was they wanted to propose a specific project and I think both opinions are equally valid.”

Huna Totem marketing director Mickey Richardson said in an interview he was pleased to see the amount of public and Assembly dialogue on the topic at the meeting and is excited to work with the city and public moving forward.

“There was just a lot of redundancy and it was clear it was going to increase in scale and slow down the process and we felt like we were already doing a lot of this work,” he said. “We will continue to engage with the city. The outcome allows us to continue the dialogue and engage in the process.”

• Contact reporter Clarise Larson at clarise.larson@juneauempire.com or (651)-528-1807. Follow her on Twitter at @clariselarson.

More in News

(Juneau Empire File)
Aurora forecast for the week of Nov. 27

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

Girls teams face off on the twin courts of the main gym at Juneau-Douglas Yadaa.at Kalé High School during the Juneau Invitational Volleyball Extravaganza on Oct. 15, 2022. The Juneau Board of Education on Friday unanimously voted to seek advice from outside council on a new state policy banning transgender girls from high school sports teams. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
School board unanimously votes to seek outside legal advice on new statewide transgender sports ban

Juneau reportedly first district to take step that may lead to lawsuit challenging policy.

A Capital City Fire/Rescue truck parks outside the main entrance of the Riverview Senior Living complex Monday after Nathan Bishop, 58, is found alive in the attic 40 hours after being reported missing from the facility where he is a resident. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
State reviewing Riverview Senior Living after missing resident found in attic 40 hours later

Officials unaware of similar cases in Alaska; facility says steps to prevent such incidents underway

Search and rescue officials examine the area about 11 miles south of the center of Wrangell where a landslide occurred on Nov. 20. Five people are confirmed dead from the landslide and one still missing. (Photo courtesy of Alaska Department of Public Safety)
Body of fifth Wrangell landslide victim found; one person still missing

Otto Florschutz, 65, found Thursday evening; Derek Heller, 12, still missing among family of five.

Varieties of kelp are seen underwater. A U.S. Department of Energy-funded project will investigate whether kelp and other seaweed in the waters off Alaska’s Prince of Wales Island can absorb significant amounts of rare earth elements that leach out from the Bokan Mountain site. (National Marine Sanctuary photo provided by NOAA)
Federally funded project will search for rare earth elements in Southeast Alaska seaweed

What if prized rare earth elements could be extracted from seaweed, avoiding… Continue reading

Angie Flick (center), finance director for the City and Borough of Juneau, provides details of an early draft of next year’s municipal budget to Assembly members as City Manager Katie Koester (left) and Budget Manager Adrien Wendel listen during a Finance Committee meeting Wednesday night in the Assembly Chambers. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Assembly members prepare to retreat so they can move ahead on next year’s budget

“Very draft” $190 million spending plan for FY25 based on status quo has $1 million deficit.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Police calls for Monday, Nov. 27, 2023

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

The front page of the Juneau Empire on Nov. 30, 2005. (Photo by Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Empire Archives: Juneau’s history for the week of Dec. 3

Three decades of capital city coverage.

Cheyenne Latu (left), a pharmacy technician at Ron’s Apothecary Shoppe, and business co-owner Gretchen Watts hang a poster at the front counter Thursday announcing the store’s closure after Dec. 6 as Jessica Kirtley, another pharmacy technician, works at the front register. The nearby Safeway supermarket has agreed to take the prescriptions of all customers as well as hire all of the independent pharmacy’s employees, according to the co-owners who are retiring. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Ron’s Apothecary Shoppe closing after nearly 50 years as co-owners retire; last day is Dec. 6

Safeway taking over all prescriptions and offering jobs to all employees, according to owners.

Most Read