Alaskans scorchingly reject Permanent Fund amendment

A proposal to enshrine the Permanent Fund Dividend in the Alaska Constitution met scorching opposition in public testimony Monday and Tuesday as Alaskans picked apart its language and criticized it for failing to accomplish its principal goal: protecting the dividend.

“It’s like throwing the public a bone after you’ve kicked them in the groin,” said Kurt Schmitt, a Delta Junction resident testifying by phone.

Forty-five Alaskans offered their thoughts on House Joint Resolution 23 between 7 p.m. and 9:15 p.m. Monday night. Not a single one offered definitive support for the amendment under consideration, though several offered support for alternative language.

In a Tuesday afternoon meeting of the House Finance Committee, more Alaskans voiced their disapproval. Two high school students from Southeast Alaska offered unqualified support.

HJR 23, containing the text of the proposed constitutional amendment, is being proposed by members of the coalition House Majority. According to its text, 4.75 percent of the average value of the Alaska Permanent Fund would be available for spending. Two-thirds of that draw would be spent on government expenses. One-third would be reserved for dividends.

Michael Chambers, testifying from Anchorage, said he believes “the most important thing out there is the language of ‘shall’ and ‘may.’”

Critically, HJR 23 states that “the legislature may provide for a dividend payment to state residents of not less than $1,250 for each resident each year.”

That language, if approved as a constitutional amendment, would allow the Legislature to approve a zero-dollar dividend, completely negating the concept behind the amendment.

Doug Gardner, the Legislature’s lead attorney, said on Tuesday that a constituional amendment including the word “shall” instead of “may” would run into legal problems with other portions of the Alaska Constitution.

“I think if we put the word ‘shall’ in, we’ll end up with, possibly, a bad litigation result … and none of this will go forward,” he said.

HJR 23 is also opposed by the Alaska Permanent Fund Corporation, whose director, Angela Rodell, told lawmakers that the corporation’s board of trustees disagrees with its approach because it allows the Legislature to take more money out of the Permanent Fund, even after the average-draw system is implemented.

Doing so, under HJR 23, would require a three-quarters supermajority vote of the House and Senate.

The risk of an extra draw creates instability, Rodell warned.

“It introduces that instability for perpetuity,” she said.

In a Tuesday morning meeting with reporters, Gov. Bill Walker was noncommittal about the measure, pointing out that he doesn’t get a say when it comes to constitutional amendments. Under the Alaska Constitution, if a supermajority of lawmakers (2/3 in the House and 2/3 in the Senate) approve an amendment, it goes on the ballot in the next statewide general election. If a majority of voters approve the amendment at the ballot box, it is accepted.

Any amendment approved by lawmakers this session would show up on this fall’s ballot because 2018 is a general election year.

In addition to the issue of “shall” and “may,” those offering public testimony keyed in on the amount of the split between state services and the dividend. Many advocated a 50/50 split first proposed by former Gov. Jay Hammond in his book “Diapering the Devil.”

That idea has since been proposed by several lawmakers but has not garnered any traction among the leadership of the House Majority or the Senate Majority.

“You guys are letting down the people of Alaska. You guys are ruining this state,” said Sally Johnson of Palmer.

Many of the people offering public testimony said recent cuts to the dividend and the proposed formula split amount to “stealing” the dividend.

Karen Perry of Chugiak pointed out Rep. Paul Seaton’s habit of wearing a flat cap in the Capitol.

“Rep. Seaton, I suggest you take off that silly hat and put on a pirate hat,” she said.

“You must stop violating God’s laws. The eighth commandment is thou shalt not steal,” she added.

Many also said they want to see a vote of the people on any Legislative action affecting the Permanent Fund and the Permanent Fund Dividend. They also cautioned that they will remember any action taken this session when November’s general election arrives.

“We’re looking at you. And we disagree with you. And we vote,” said William Lambert of North Pole.


• Contact reporter James Brooks at jbrooks@juneauempire.com or 523-2258.


More in News

Suicide Basin as of 10:01 a.m. on Thursday, July 10, 2025, taken by a U.S. Geological Survey camera at the basin entrance facing northeast, into the basin. (Screenshot from National Weather Service Juneau page)
Glacial lake outburst swells Salmon River near Hyder

The isolation of Salmon River limits the impact of flooding

Kahyl Dybdahl, left, and Bronze Chevis eat an egg sandwich breakfast before school at Dzantik’i Heeni Middle School on Wednesday, Sept. 6, 2017. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
School board allocates extra state funds

More state funds available, but funding issues and federal uncertainty abound

Max Webster stands with Lemon Creek Correctional Center staff in front of new control tower on Tuesday, July 9, 2025. (Natalie Buttner / Juneau Empire)
A towering accomplishment for new Eagle Scout

Max Webster honored at Firearms Training Center Control Tower ribbon-cutting ceremony

Andy Engstrom (left) uses bitcoin to buy lemonade and cookies from business owner Denali Schijvens (right) on Saturday, July 5, 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire)
Alaska’s 1st Bitcoin conference held in Juneau

State leaders discuss integrating Bitcoin in Alaska energy, investment and universities

Rep. Nick Begich III, R-Alaska, delivers his keynote address to approximately 40 people, most of whom are from out of state, at the end of the Bitcoin Alaska conference on Sunday. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire)
Begich and Bitcoin fly to Juneau after passage of ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’

Protesters seek town hall with representative; he delivers keynote address at ticketed conference

Brad Hogarth, one of four finalists to be the new music director of the Juneau Symphony, guides the ensemble through a rehearsal at Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
A pink peony blooms in Chris Urata’s garden on Saturday, July 5, 2025. (Ellie Ruel / Juneau Empire)
Master Gardeners Tour showcases excellence in landscaping

Annual fundraising event features gardens on 11 properties

Seven- and 8-year-olds compete in the watermelon-eating contest at Savviko Park on Thursday, July 3, 2025. (Ellie Ruel / Juneau Empire)
Douglas picnic marks the beginning of 4th of July celebrations

Community members enjoy barbecue, watermelon eating contest

Most Read