Alaska issue gets spot on Supreme Court agenda

Alaska is headed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The nation’s highest legal body began its new term this month, and among the 80 or so cases this term is at least one appeal dealing specifically with Alaska. The court is also being asked to deal with a thorny Southeast topic.

On the surface, Sturgeon v. Masica deals with — of all things — a hovercraft. Below the surface, it’s the knotty question of where the rights of the state and Native organizations end and those of the federal government begin.

The court’s acceptance of Sturgeon’s appeal was announced Oct. 1.

In 2007, John Sturgeon was operating his hovercraft on a river in eastern Alaska, en route to a moose hunt. The hovercraft broke down, and while he worked on it, he was approached by National Park Service officers.

Since Sturgeon was working within the boundaries of the Yukon-Charley National Preserve, and hovercraft are prohibited in National Park Service territory, he was told to remove it.

In 2011, Sturgeon sued, claiming that while the National Park Service might have authority over the land around the Nation River — where Sturgeon was — the state of Alaska has authority over submerged lands beneath navigable waterways, courtesy of the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act. As a result, state rules, not those of the Park Service, should have been applied.

Alaska’s U.S. District Court rejected Sturgeon’s argument, as did the court of appeals that heard it, and Sturgeon’s attorneys appealed to the highest court. A date has not yet been set for oral arguments.

The Supreme Court appeal was pushed by Sturgeon’s lawyers, but the state of Alaska has also chimed in on their side. In a brief filed with the Supreme Court, assistant attorneys general Ruth Botstein and Janell Hafner wrote that Alaska has “a direct and profound interest in maintaining its authority to keep its waterways open without federal regulatory interference, as Congress intended.”

Seven regional Native corporations are supporting Sturgeon and the state, as are two village corporations. The corporations fear that any land claims they have that are surrounded by Park Service land could be subject to federal regulations governing public land.

While the 49th state is frequently affected by the actions of the court, having a case specifically address an Alaska question is unusual. Sturgeon’s case isn’t expected to have nationwide effects because ANILCA is an Alaska-specific law.

The court receives about 10,000 petitions per year, according to its figures, and hears just 75-80 of those in oral argument.

On Tuesday, the Alaska Department of Law announced it will try to put a second Alaska case among that select group. It is seeking an appeal for a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision that effectively prohibited the construction of new roads in the Tongass National Forest.

The Roadless Rule, implemented in the final days of the Clinton administration, prohibits road construction, maintenance and timber harvesting on almost 60 million acres of U.S. Forest Service land.

An exemption to the Roadless Rule, approved in 2003, prohibited the rule’s application to the Tongass National Forest, but that exemption was challenged in 2009 by groups including the Sierra Club, Greenpeace and the Organized Village of Kake.

In 2011, an Alaska U.S. District Court judge ruled on the Kake v. USDA lawsuit by agreeing with the challengers.

The state of Alaska appealed that decision, and a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit in 2014 agreed with the state’s argument. That decision was appealed to a full 11-judge panel, and on July 29, the panel ruled that exempting the Tongass from the nationwide rule was illegal.

“I think we have a strong argument,” said assistant attorney general Dario Borghesan.

He added that the chances of getting the Supreme Court to hear any particular appeal are low, but the state has a compelling case.

“I think the court would be interested in the way the Ninth Circuit treated what is basically a policy change from one administration to another,” Borghesan said.

More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast for the week of Feb. 19

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan, R-Alaska, addresses a joint session of the Alaska Legislature on Wednesday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Sullivan touts new ocean cleanup headquarters in Juneau, attacks Biden in annual speech to legislators

Senator calls Trump “the best president ever” for Alaska, has harsh words for Iran and migrants

The Norwegian Bliss arrives in Juneau on April 17, 2023, the first cruise ship of the 2023 season. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire file photo)
Free public downtown Wi-Fi, park upgrades, more buses among proposals for marine passenger fees

Public comments being accepted until March 25 for more than $19 million in recommended projects.

Andy Mills (left), legislative liaison for the state Department of Transportation and Public Facilities, and Commissioner Ryan Anderson testify before the Senate Transportation Committee on Tuesday about an executive order that would give the governor full control of the Alaska Marine Highway System’s operations board. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Governor says he wants control of ferry board so it’s not ‘at odds’ with him; senators express skepticism

Resolution to reject Dunleavy’s executive order among many being considered by legislators.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire)
Police calls for Monday, Feb. 19, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Paul Peterson, author of the Harvard study on national charter school performance. (KTOO 360TV screenshot)
Alaska lawmakers grapple with test-score performance gap between charters and other public schools

Charter study does not show how their testing success can be replicated in regular public schools.

An underwater image captured in 2016 shows sockeye salmon swimming up the Brooks River in Alaska’s Katmai National Park to spawn. The U.S. Department of Agriculture is buying about 50 million pounds of Alaska fish — pollock, pink salmon and sockeye salmon — to use in its food and nutrition-assistance programs. (Photo provided by the National Park Service)
Agriculture Department commits to big purchase of Alaska salmon and pollock for food programs

The U.S. Department of Agriculture will purchase about 50 million pounds of… Continue reading

Juneau-Douglas High School: Kalé students hold up signs during a rally along Egan Drive on Tuesday afternoon protesting a proposal to consolidate all local students in grades 10-12 at Thunder Mountain High School to help deal with the Juneau School District’s financial crisis. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
JDHS students, teachers rally to keep grades 9-12 at downtown school if consolidation occurs

District’s proposed move to TMHS would result in loss of vocational facilities, ninth-grade students.

Deven Mitchell, executive director of the Alaska Permanent Fund Corp., gives a tour of the corporation’s investment floor to Sen. Jesse Kiehl, D-Juneau, and other attendees of an open house on Friday. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
Alaska Permanent Fund Corp. leaders approve proposal to borrow up to $4 billion for investments

Plan must be OK’d by legislators and Gov. Mike Dunleavy because it requires changes to state law.

Most Read