Jane Hale (Courtesy Photo)

Jane Hale (Courtesy Photo)

Coming Out: A creative personal aesthetic

I think aesthetics are more than just politics.

–for Kass

When Picasso died in 1973, the political cartoonist Pat Oliphant published a cartoon tribute to the artist that depicts then-President Richard Nixon–in modified cubist style–at breakfast reading a newspaper with the headline, “Picasso dead at 91.” The cubefied Nixon quips to his wife Pat, “I was always glad he wasn’t a political cartoonist.”

Funny enough, but the real punchline is down in the lower left corner of the cartoon, where Punk, Oliphant’s wry penguin commentator, offers a scorching retort: “He was the best in the business, sport!”

Punk’s commentary brings to mind first, of course, a masterpiece like “Guernica,” Picasso’s visual condemnation of Franco’s aerial attack (using Hitler’s Luftwaffe) on the Basque city in northern Spain. The painting’s images are indeed cartoonish; the anguish and horror are not.

But all art is political, not just works with explicit contemporaneous subjects like Guernica. All great art is subversive.

To stay with “Guernica” for a moment: it was the first painting I ever fell in love with. I remember the first time I saw it as a teenager. As I climbed the wide marble staircase at New York City’s Museum of Modern Art, the 11-by-25-foot canvas of “Guernica” loomed ahead of me, majestic in size, overwhelming in its effect. It gave me a love for large, affective paintings. It shaped my understanding of what art does and how.

Artists make us look again, often at stuff we’ve seen before–a bucolic landscape, an all-night diner, a starry night–and let us see things differently. We discover what we might have missed, and we find ourselves affected in unexpected ways by stuff we’ve become complacent about.

Because what is there to be complacent about, anyway?

“Complacent” is our word for today’s episode of “Etymology with Auntie Jane.” It comes from Latin and means “to be pleased with.” And what is there we can ever be pleased with once and for all?

Nor I nor any man that but man is

With nothing shall be pleased til he be eased

With being nothing.

— (Shakespeare, “Richard II”)

Art won’t let us be complacent.

Maybe that’s what aesthetics are — not some intrinsic attribute of beauty or the passive appreciation of art, but an interaction, an engagement, an opening up to let things change us, to change ourselves, and to change the conditions of our lives. Like politics.

Maybe aesthetics and politics have more in common than our dictionaries acknowledge.

In a recent opinion piece in the New York Times, columnist Charles M. Blow writes about Ida B. Wells, a late 19th-century journalist who was also “a stylish woman…and a genius.” Blow notes how some of Wells’s contemporaries found her stylish dress incongruous with her serious vocation. He writes that “it’s often the case — now as then — that expressions of personal style among serious people are deemed frivolities.”

Blow notes that it’s worse for men, who get regarded “in a boorish society” as effeminate. I would argue that it’s even worse for transgender women and nonbinary femmes who are treated not as frivolous but as subversive for challenging the delusional desirability of things masculine.

We are “subverting the dominant paradigm,” or some other usefully banal cliché like that. And that’s the fun of it. Playful and serious at the same time. Beautiful and incisive. Creative and subversive.

It may seem like “fun” is too frivolous a concept to talk about in the face of all the physical violence and political oppressions we in the transgender community have to be on our guard against. But choosing a creative personal aesthetic, a way of being the beauty that we want to see in the world: that is a political act, a subversive act, wielding our personal freedom against threats of repression and censorship and violence. We are all political cartoons. We are all “Guernicas.”

I’m trying to write about developing a creative personal aesthetic, because there’s some contrarian blood in my veins that loves the subversive side of it. Fun is subversive. I like that.

And I think aesthetics are more than just politics too. When I leave the house in the morning wearing fashions that are fun and a true expression of myself, I’m wearing my freedom, wearing my heart on my frilly pink sleeve. But it’s also a kind of practical spirituality, like wrestling with an angel. It’s dealing with a sometimes dark and dangerous situation in a way that is direct and confident–and creative and beautiful.

I’m taking the bull by the handlebars.

• Jane Hale lives in Juneau with her partner and their two dogs. “Coming Out” appears biweekly on the Empire’s neighbors page.

More in Neighbors

Battered fish fillets frying. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking for Pleasure: Fish and chips with homemade tartar sauce

For years I struggled with different fish batter recipes, usually with lousy… Continue reading

Jackie Renninger Park, which is scheduled to receive structural and safety improvements. (City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Neighbors briefs

See design ideas for Jackie Renninger Park at June 24 public meeting… Continue reading

Students from Juneau Community Charter School listen to a story at the Skagway Public Library. (Photo provided by Clint Sullivan)
Neighbors: Letters of thanks

Thanks to the community of Skagway The K/1 class of Juneau Community… Continue reading

Donna Leigh is a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. (Courtesy photo)
Living and Growing: Small things

Have you ever had a small pebble in your shoe? Very irritating,… Continue reading

Dining out in Croatia. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking for Pleasure: Almond cake from a trip to Croatia

I should have probably titled this week’s column: “Eating For Pleasure.” My… Continue reading

Matushka Olga Michael, a Yup’ik woman from Kwethluk. (Photo provided by Maxim Gibson)
Living and Growing: A new Alaskan saint

“God is wonderful in His saints: the God of Israel is He… Continue reading

Nick Hanson of the NBC show “American Ninja Warrior” kicks off the blanket toss at the 2020 Traditional Games in Juneau. (Lyndsey Brollini / Sealaska Heritage Institute)
Neighbors: Celebration begins Wednesday with mix of traditional and new events

Nearly 1,600 dancers from 36 dance groups scheduled to participate in four-day gathering.

“Curiosities of Alaska” by Junnie Chup, which won first place in Kindred Post’s 2024 statewide postcard art contest. (Photo courtesy of Kindred Post)
Neighbors briefs

Kindred Post announces 2024 statewide postcard art contest winners Kindred Post on… Continue reading

Tanya Renee Ahtowena Rorem at age 17. (Photo provided by Laura Rorem)
Living and Growing: ‘My name is Ahtowena’

My precocious two-year old broke loose from my grip and took off… Continue reading

The Pinkas Synagogue, the second-oldest building in Prague. (World Monuments Fund photo)
Living and Growing: Connecting to family ancestors through names of strangers on a wall in Prague

“Prague never lets you go…this dear little mother has sharp claws.” —… Continue reading

Individual eggplant parmesan rounds ready to serve. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking for Pleasure: Individual eggplant parmesan rounds

These flavorful eggplant parmesans are a great side dish, especially served with… Continue reading