Archives
Let's just say Frank Murkowski is not a marketing genius. If he were, he would never propose to increase pollution in Alaska salmon streams. As far-fetched as it sounds, however, the state is now taking comments on a new proposed rule to allow more pollution in our prized fish streams. Current rules rightly prohibit such discharges, but heavy lobbying from polluting industries has put the issue on our table.
My Turn: Pollution and salmon marketing don't mix 081604 opinion 2 The Juneau Empire Online Let's just say Frank Murkowski is not a marketing genius. If he were, he would never propose to increase pollution in Alaska salmon streams. As far-fetched as it sounds, however, the state is now taking comments on a new proposed rule to allow more pollution in our prized fish streams. Current rules rightly prohibit such discharges, but heavy lobbying from polluting industries has put the issue on our table.

My Turn: Pollution and salmon marketing don't mix

Let's just say Frank Murkowski is not a marketing genius. If he were, he would never propose to increase pollution in Alaska salmon streams. As far-fetched as it sounds, however, the state is now taking comments on a new proposed rule to allow more pollution in our prized fish streams. Current rules rightly prohibit such discharges, but heavy lobbying from polluting industries has put the issue on our table.

It's important to understand why increased salmon stream pollution reflects bad public policy. Alaska is blessed with a bounty of wild salmon. But farmed fish have wreaked havoc on the Alaska salmon industry and the countless Alaskan families and communities it supports. In response, Alaskans have made impressive strides finding and expanding markets for our magnificent wild fish. How? By meeting consumer demand, and branding and marketing Alaska salmon as healthy, fresh and clean. Salmon marketing hinges largely on consumer perceptions, and consumers have rightly come to expect a superior product from Alaska vendors. The Murkowski administration's new proposal, however, will unravel these important advances by tainting Alaska's wild salmon with a new label - a pollution label.

The state is now amending its water quality protection rules to allow mixing zones" in salmon streams. Under the Clean Water Act, states establish water quality standards to protect people and fish, among other things. Pollution discharges must normally meet these standards when the discharges enter a water body. When the discharge is too polluted to meet state standards, however, regulators often employ a loophole - called a mixing zone - to permit the discharge anyway. Instead of measuring compliance with fish protection standards at the end of the pipe, mixing zones allow compliance to be measured somewhere downstream, after the pollutants have dispersed in the receiving water. This loophole embraces the old, discounted notion that dilution is the solution to pollution. In practice, mixing zones create sacrifice areas in streams where water quality fails to meet the basic fish protection goals of the Clean Water Act.

Print This
E-Mail This
Discuss This
Send editor a comment
Current rules allow mixing zones in non-salmon streams. Due to pressure from industry, mixing zones already have become the rule rather than the exception in those waters. ADEC now routinely allows mixing zones in most wastewater permits outside of salmon streams, making a mockery of laws meant to protect water quality. But until now, no one has been foolish enough to suggest it would be a good idea to allow mixing zones in our salmon streams. Chalk up another first for the Murkowski administration.

This new rule, standing alone, poses sweeping implications for salmon health, salmon habitat and salmon marketing. Yet it's part of a larger wholesale effort by the Murkowski administration to roll back basic safeguards on salmon health and salmon habitat. For example, the governor began his term by muffling biologists in the state's habitat protection agency - the Department of Fish and Game's Habitat Division - by moving them to the resource development agency - the Department of Natural Resources. Similarly, the Governor and his supporters rammed through changes to the Alaska Coastal Management Act which effectively removed local citizens and coastal governments from decisions affecting salmon and other coastal resources. And let's not forget this administration's aggressive drive to allow pesticide spraying around salmon streams. Together, these sweeping changes herald the most anti-salmon, anti-local control agenda ever foisted upon Alaskans, and their effects are felt in permitting decisions every day across the state.

Alaska boasts the healthiest salmon stocks in the world, and they provide jobs, dollars and subsistence to people and communities throughout the state. But Alaska's increasingly successful effort to brand and market clean, fresh and healthy fish will suffer if the state rolls back its common sense protections on our prized fish streams. Predictably, the state's many lawyers and experts and public relations specialists will ensure everyone that Alaska salmon and the people they support will remain unharmed. But when the Murkowski administration speaks, just remember this one fact: The governor's new rule will allow toxic pollution discharges in Alaska salmon streams where none occur now.

Public comments on the proposal are being taken until Sept. 10. For more information, go to www.inletkeeper.org or www.state.ak.us/dec/water/wqsar/trireview/mixingzones.htm.

• Bob Shavelson is the executive director of Cook Inlet Keeper, a nonprofit organization dedicated to protecting the Cook Inlet watershed.



AP Video and News

Updated 1:05 AM ET
Former NFL quarterback McNair killed in Tennessee
More than 1 million seek tix for Jackson memorial
Palin links resignation to 'higher calling'
NYC fireworks highlight US Independence Day events
Exiled Honduran president vows return on Sunday
Obama's trip: A mission to reshape US image
Missiles show NKorea skills improving: officials
More News

Classifieds






Top Jobs

Loading...

Top Homes

Loading...

Top Rentals

Loading...

Top Boats

Loading...

Top Autos

Loading...

Top Jobs

Loading...

Top Homes

Loading...

Top Rentals

Loading...

Top Boats

Loading...

Top Autos

Loading...



Twitter
News
Share
Shop
Life
Visit