Web posted September 6, 2007

'3:10 to Yuma' proves the Western genre can still shoot straight

By RICK BENTLEY
McClatchy Newspapers

Courtesy of Lions Gate Films
  Draw: Russell Crowe, left, stars as Ben Wade in a remake of the Western "3:10 to Yuma."
You can't accuse director Jim Mangold of resting on his laurels. On the heels of his Oscar-nominated "Walk the Line," Mangold has tackled a remake of the classic Western "3:10 to Yuma." The original 1957 movie is heralded by film fans for its cinematography, story structure and performances.

Those are some mighty big boots to fill.

Mangold not only pays tribute to the original, but improves on it with even more impressive sweeping cinematography, a host of standout performances and tension that has not been generated in a Western since Gary Cooper walked the dusty streets alone in "High Noon."

"3:10 to Yuma" is the story of Civil War veteran Dan Evans (Christian Bale in the role played by Van Heflin in the original). His efforts to farm a small piece of land are hampered by a war injury and the unscrupulous men who run the community. The Evans land is worth more to the railroad than it is as a farm.

Fate steps in at the exact second Evans is to lose his farm. The notorious bandit Ben Wade (Russell Crowe in the role played by Glenn Ford in the original) has been captured. The problem is that Wade commands a gang that will stop at nothing to free their boss.

Evans volunteers to help transport Wade to a nearby town where the outlaw can be put on a train that will take him to Yuma to stand trial.

On an action level, Mangold does a remarkable job of staging chase scenes, shootouts and bloody battles that are on par with any contemporary set movie. And he does this without fast cars and automatic weapons.

These scenes are made stronger by the way the film is shot. Mangold manages to convey the isolation of the western world that is as raw as the primal urges that drive most men.

The real joy is watching how Bale and Crowe play their characters. At first glance, the farmer and bandit would seem as different as night and day. Mangold slowly peels away the facades both men have erected to reveal that at their very hearts, these are two men driven by the same strong urges of honor, pride and integrity.

Supporting performances by Peter Fonda as a cantankerous bounty hunter, Ben Foster as a psychotic killer and Logan Lerman as Dan's misguided son just add to the positive acting mix.

But - and you knew there had to be a "but" somewhere - the remake falls into the same trap as the original. The ending just seems a little too pat to go along with what has been to that point a very honest movie. It is a small problem, though, and not enough to keep "3:10 to Yuma" from being a first-rate effort.

All of those critics who say the Western is dead should take a look at this film. This movie certainly proves that there is plenty of life left in the genre.

Print This
E-Mail This
Send editor a comment
Hooligan Archives

January 17, 2008:
Robbie Burns Night

January 10, 2008:
Brain Gain

January 03, 2008:
'Imagination gone wild'

December 27, 2007:
'Smile When You're Lying'

December 20, 2007:
Juneau's holiday wish list

December 13, 2007:
Reindeer mind games

December 06, 2007:
The Final Countdown

November 29, 2007:
Evolving culture

November 22, 2007:
Songs for the Deaf

November 15, 2007:
Hold the juice

November 08, 2007:
The birth of karaoke

November 01, 2007:
Where the going gets tough

October 25, 2007:
Halloween Do's and Don'ts

October 18, 2007:
Light up your life

October 11, 2007:
Mixed signals

October 04, 2007:
The rise of the yeast

September 27, 2007:
Captivated by 'Guitar Hero 2'

September 20, 2007:
To Post, or Not to Post?

September 13, 2007:
Riding the concrete Wave

September 06, 2007:
Ready to be a Legend?

August 30, 2007:
From the Bay to the Channel

August 23, 2007:
Organic apprehension

August 16, 2007:
Buskers: Modern minstrels

August 09, 2007:
Slow Ride, take it easy

August 02, 2007:
All's Fair

July 26, 2007:
Letting it all Hang out

July 19, 2007:
Kiss your quarters goodbye

July 12, 2007:
Taking the Plunge

July 05, 2007:
Nowhere to go but up

June 28, 2007:
To Boldly Go

June 21, 2007:
Riding the White Limousine

June 14, 2007:
From China, with love

June 07, 2007:
Our own slice of the World Wide Web

Complete Hooligan archives