Web posted January 3, 2008

'August Rush' preview teases but movie fails to please

Chester Duke Carson
The Big Screen

Courtesy of Warner Bros.
  Hero and villain: Freddie Highmore, left, stars as an orphan and Robin Williams plays the villian in "August Rush."
I've always been a guy who enjoys the 15 minutes of previews before the feature presentation. To me, running late to the movies means missing part of them, and as a result I can get cranky. But for most normal folks, such as the young lady who accompanies me to most films, late means missing part of the actual movie.

I share this because I remember seeing the preview for "August Rush" several months ago - we had gotten to the theater on schedule for once - and thinking, "Now that is a damn good preview."

And it really was. A very cool soundtrack helped weave the two-minute trailer together; the story had "tear-jerker" written all over it to the extent I recall choking up slightly in anticipation for the real movie; Robin Williams looked like he had toned down his attention-deficit-disorder shtick a bit and was playing a feel-good character; and that cute kid from "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" still looked cute. It had all the makings for a great winter release.

Sometimes, previews lie.

The movie is about a boy named August Rush (Freddie Highmore), an orphan boy who is convinced that if he can learn to perform music his real parents will hear him and some how find him.

Much of the film's first half hour overflows with August's narration, because apparently the audience cannot to be trusted to pay attention. But even if you aren't watching that closely, you'll get that August's mom (Keri Russell) meets his dad (Jonathan Rhys Meyers) and gets pregnant; her father then forges her signature giving the baby up for adoption while telling her the baby did not live. Thus, August, his mom and dad are cruelly separated by fate. The only one thing that can bring them back together 11 years later: their music.

Even rehashing the plot, I have to stop myself from getting pumped up to see the movie - like I did months ago after the preview.

The finished product just isn't worth the hype.

In no particular order, here are the problems with "August":

• Robin Williams is nothing like the preview would have you believe. He is hardly a feel-good character. Try villain. And like he seems to do in every movie he makes nowadays, he makes me feel a little uncomfortable when he's on screen. Or maybe that's just me?

• The dialogue is painfully contrived at times and predictable to the point that I was reciting the lines with the actors even though it was opening day.

• While I'm no musical expert, I am guessing that any credible musician who watches this movie will be cringing throughout at the ludicrousness of what we are supposed to buy as realistic.

• Finally, at 133 minutes, "August Rush" is about 40 minutes long in the tooth.

But here's the kicker:

I was ready to forgive everything and buy in completely by bawling my eyes out at the end for a big, teary reunion. I was so ready. And the last 20 minutes are a maddeningly slow buildup to said reunion. At last, when it is just about to happen, we cut to an overhead shot of Central Park and the credits roll.

Excuse me? More than two hours of emotional buildup and then - nothing? Really?

Well, to the makers of "August Rush," this is the sound of a disappointed audience. All you have to do is listen.

Print This
E-Mail This
Send editor a comment
Hooligan Archives

January 17, 2008:
Robbie Burns Night

January 10, 2008:
Brain Gain

January 03, 2008:
'Imagination gone wild'

December 27, 2007:
'Smile When You're Lying'

December 20, 2007:
Juneau's holiday wish list

December 13, 2007:
Reindeer mind games

December 06, 2007:
The Final Countdown

November 29, 2007:
Evolving culture

November 22, 2007:
Songs for the Deaf

November 15, 2007:
Hold the juice

November 08, 2007:
The birth of karaoke

November 01, 2007:
Where the going gets tough

October 25, 2007:
Halloween Do's and Don'ts

October 18, 2007:
Light up your life

October 11, 2007:
Mixed signals

October 04, 2007:
The rise of the yeast

September 27, 2007:
Captivated by 'Guitar Hero 2'

September 20, 2007:
To Post, or Not to Post?

September 13, 2007:
Riding the concrete Wave

September 06, 2007:
Ready to be a Legend?

August 30, 2007:
From the Bay to the Channel

August 23, 2007:
Organic apprehension

August 16, 2007:
Buskers: Modern minstrels

August 09, 2007:
Slow Ride, take it easy

August 02, 2007:
All's Fair

July 26, 2007:
Letting it all Hang out

July 19, 2007:
Kiss your quarters goodbye

July 12, 2007:
Taking the Plunge

July 05, 2007:
Nowhere to go but up

June 28, 2007:
To Boldly Go

June 21, 2007:
Riding the White Limousine

June 14, 2007:
From China, with love

June 07, 2007:
Our own slice of the World Wide Web

Complete Hooligan archives